Posts: 4,258
Threads: 263
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
I, like many on here, was initially impressed with these two. They looked as though they knew how to defend, which frankly was never the case with Semi, while Barts was prone to a meltdown now and then.
OK the coaching is obviously flawed, but why do experienced players somehow forget the very basics of the job? Phillips has been badly rattled by a series of errors in some games, seemingly unable to get his composure back once it's gone. Mepham seems lazy or complacent, always ready to try a flick or a touch too far when a simple clearance would be better. Then he glides on his way, seemingly untroubled by the outcome of his error. I'm not used to seeing this behaviour from Albion defenders, at least not until the last of McAuley, Olsson, Evans, Dawson moved on.
I don't think it's just the coaching, these guys have come here with an attitude that isn't helping us in our present plight. Compare and contrast with the effort put in by long-term spacegoats such as Molumby, Wallace and Grant, new candidates like Campbell and Price. They give the impression that they care. Phillips and Mepham have played relatively few games in their respective careers and have arrived here expecting to be the elder statesmen and settle in for a 5 year spell of success. I expected far more from them.
Worth noting also that it took Mason far too long to realise that Bielik needs to play. From what I've seen so far, he's a level above the other two.
Posts: 2,927
Threads: 44
Joined: Sep 2019
Reputation:
7
Whilst Phillips looked decent in his early games I'm far from convinced by him. I see him as a player who didn't make it in the Premier League and is now on a downward trajectory in his career. Albion fans have referred to him as a being an experienced head - he really isn't. This is a guy who has made fewer professional appearances than lads much younger than him like Griffiths and Heggebo. Most of his game time has been in the bottom half of the Championship with us, Cardiff and Derby. He can't pass, doesn't appear to be a leader or an organiser. I don't see any of that extra bit of quality that you'd expect for someone with his apparent status in the squad.
As for Mepham, I'm not sure what is going on with him. I thought he looked real quality in his first couple of games but he's regressing at the speed of light. His background shows that he clearly is a very capable player. It is the coaching? The players he's playing with?
I do feel with a capable manager and the players we have we'd look much steadier at the back. It was always said with the likes of Hodgson and Pulis that the players were constantly drilled within an inch of their lives and training was very repetitive. But I think that is the case with most players. The lower the level you go the more players keep having to have the basics emphasised to them.
Posts: 3,396
Threads: 176
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
Derby fans did mention that Phillips was very good in a three but might struggle when there are just 2 central defenders. Which makes me wonder why we bought him if we're not going to play that way.
Mepham has the quality but just isnt showing it for whatever reason.
Posts: 830
Threads: 1
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
1
12-28-2025, 05:50 PM
(This post was last modified: 12-28-2025, 05:50 PM by Artist.)
This will be the first season in Phillips career where he has been a regular through the entire season. Ideally if Bielik can stay fit, we can rotate Phillips out of some matches.
Posts: 1,174
Threads: 94
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
4
Phillips eye has been off the ball ever since he became a dad for the first time
Posts: 7,994
Threads: 188
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
37
They both seem to lack belief, which is bizarre given their experience.
There was a high ball clearance yesterday, Mepham, no oppo near him, he could have headed it, chested it or let it bounce. It hit him in the face.
Confidence has to come through coaching and it’s sadly lacking. The self belief of the players under CC and RM are night and day. CC had average players buoyed. RM has decent players crumbling.
Posts: 988
Threads: 43
Joined: Jul 2023
Reputation:
0
Mepham's flicks do my head in. Irresponsible.
Posts: 4,258
Threads: 263
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
(12-28-2025, 06:39 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: They both seem to lack belief, which is bizarre given their experience.
There was a high ball clearance yesterday, Mepham, no oppo near him, he could have headed it, chested it or let it bounce. It hit him in the face.
Confidence has to come through coaching and it’s sadly lacking. The self belief of the players under CC and RM are night and day. CC had average players buoyed. RM has decent players crumbling.
Neither of them has played as many games as you'd expect, age for age. Billy Jones, for example, had played as many games as the two of them together by the time he was 28. And don't get me started on proper decent defenders like Ally Robertson.
Posts: 7,971
Threads: 254
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
(12-28-2025, 06:39 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: They both seem to lack belief, which is bizarre given their experience.
There was a high ball clearance yesterday, Mepham, no oppo near him, he could have headed it, chested it or let it bounce. It hit him in the face.
Confidence has to come through coaching and it’s sadly lacking. The self belief of the players under CC and RM are night and day. CC had average players buoyed. RM has decent players crumbling.
Spot on
Posts: 7,994
Threads: 188
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
37
12-28-2025, 07:24 PM
(This post was last modified: 12-28-2025, 07:25 PM by Bob Fossil.)
(12-28-2025, 07:13 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: (12-28-2025, 06:39 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: They both seem to lack belief, which is bizarre given their experience.
There was a high ball clearance yesterday, Mepham, no oppo near him, he could have headed it, chested it or let it bounce. It hit him in the face.
Confidence has to come through coaching and it’s sadly lacking. The self belief of the players under CC and RM are night and day. CC had average players buoyed. RM has decent players crumbling.
Neither of them has played as many games as you'd expect, age for age. Billy Jones, for example, had played as many games as the two of them together by the time he was 28. And don't get me started on proper decent defenders like Ally Robertson. The fact that they are getting worse is telling.
I just can’t see how it is we are trying to defend. Second goal yesterday Diakite gave the ball away, granted, but it was 40 yards out and both fullbacks were miles out of position. I’m not even sure where Taylor was, think he went for a pie.
It all seems too ad-hoc and Mowbray “I don’t tell them where to stand” -esque.
Even top players need coaching to a plan and defenders need to know where their playing partners should be. At present it looks like every man for himself.
|