Do coaches actually come back from this situation?
#1
Not wishing to labour the point around staying or going as that's been done to death.

But just wondering what the statistics look like in terms of coaches who manage to make a come back from:-

14 points in the last 15 games 
Lost 8 away games in a row

Any ideas? can anyone recall managers who have stunk a place up so bad and managed to turn it around? odds must be very small surely.

Not limited to WBA as I appreciate this is a very "special" situation Ryan is in.

Fergie is the obvious one but I don't think Mason is quite of that calibre.
Reply
#2
CC at Huddersfield and Dean Smith at Vile

I know - I’m clutching….
Reply
#3
(12-27-2025, 08:01 PM)HeggebøsBarnDoor Wrote: Not wishing to labour the point around staying or going as that's been done to death.

But just wondering what the statistics look like in terms of coaches who manage to make a come back from:-

14 points in the last 15 games 
Lost 8 away games in a row

Any ideas? can anyone recall managers who have stunk a place up so bad and managed to turn it around? odds must be very small surely.

Not limited to WBA as I appreciate this is a very "special" situation Ryan is in.

Fergie is the obvious one but I don't think Mason is quite of that calibre.

Good question. Most are sacked by this point. I recall stubborn owners keeping managers too long. Bruce and Pardew spring to mind. Seems this will be the case with Mason
Reply
#4
I really want nothing more than for Mason to turn it around, and have patience in a young coach rewarded.

I actually like Mason, and I'm willing so much for it to work out, but I'm really doubtful now, I just can't see it, sadly.

If/when Mason gets sacked, I'll genuinely be sad - because I really like the idea of persisting with a young manager, but I realise that's an Idealistic attitude. Patience is in scant supply within football.

Compare that to when Bruce or Pardew were sacked, it was sheer joy! Ultimately the end results are the same, in terms of the man not being good enough for the job, but there'll be an element of sadness with Mason, that wasn't there with Bruce or Pardew. Hopefully that makes sense to someone!
Reply
#5
(12-27-2025, 08:12 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: I really want nothing more than for Mason to turn it around, and have patience in a young coach rewarded.

I actually like Mason, and I'm willing so much for it to work out, but I'm really doubtful now, I just can't see it, sadly.

If/when Mason gets sacked, I'll genuinely be sad - because I really like the idea of persisting with a young manager, but I realise that's an Idealistic attitude. Patience is in scant suplly.

Compare that to when Bruce or Pardew were sacked, it was sheer joy! Ultimately the end results are the same, in terms of the man not being good enough for the job, but there'll be an element of sadness with Mason, that wasn't there with Bruce or Pardew. Hopefully that makes sense to someone!

Yea he seems like a nice guy and a decent honest chap but i suppose my point is.....if we're a stats club and the stats say that for arguments sake he has a 1/20 chance of turning it around then surely that's got to be something Nestor is aware of and will have to be factored into his decision making.

Might do some more googling on it tomorrow to see.

I suppose my train of thought is, if at some point the odds suggest it's impossible then it's pointless continuing unless you're hoping for a minor miracle.
Reply
#6
As a poster mentioned above CC is a really good example. Highly rated coach who stepped for his first job and really struggled in the first season. I remember reading an article about him and he felt his issue was that he was too committed to a specific, Bielsa-like style that the fans felt was too inflexible, and during the off season he reflected and came back with a more pragmatic approach that took them to the play-offs.

Mason has different short comings, in-game management for one, but I do wonder whether Bilkul are looking at the CC example and trying to repeat that here, especially given this season is generally being seen as one of transition where it was unlikely we would do as well as had previously.

I think he can turn it around, but it will need a bit of reflection from Mason and a good run of results for a month or so at the least.
Reply
#7
Norwich in 2017-18 finished 14th under Daniel Farke and then won the league after. There were calls from Norwich Fans to get rid of him during that season .
Reply
#8
Yeah CC looks to be a good example. Looks like they narrowly escaped relegation the year before so perhaps there were lower expectations when he started. Nevertheless he did managed to turn it around and potentially over achieve to get to the play offs a year later.

If we're stuck with him maybe there is room for some hope providing Ryan can learn and reflect to the same extent.
Reply
#9
the Bournemouth manager could be available soon , no wins in 9 with Chelsea Arsenal and Spurs and Newcastle to come.  

I doubt their owners will fuck about if they sink into the relegation zone.
Reply
#10
(12-27-2025, 08:34 PM)HeggebøsBarnDoor Wrote: Yeah CC looks to be a good example. Looks like they narrowly escaped relegation the year before so perhaps there were lower expectations when he started. Nevertheless he did managed to turn it around and potentially over achieve to get to the play offs a year later.

If we're stuck with him maybe there is room for some hope providing Ryan can learn and reflect to the same extent.
You need some ability though to turn things around.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: