The Ashes
Archer has a side strain and is out of the last two games.  Pope dropped at last.
Reply
I've nothing against Jacob Bethel, and this may come back to bite me on the arse, but how do they think the answer to a failing number three is to bring in a kid who averages 28 in FC cricket with no hundreds to his name. Penny for the thoughts of the lads who've piled on runs in the CC last couple of summers having to watch this unfold. No wonder we're losing so many to the franchise circuit is it?

No issues with Archer being allowed to recover, he's more than justified his selection.
Reply
Bethel will become a great player for England. But its a lot expecting him to come in and bat 3 from the off. If we bat first, Stokes should go in at 3, if we bat 2nd, Root should bat 3.
Reply
(12-24-2025, 08:05 AM)Wednesburybaggie Wrote: Bethel will become a great player for England. But its a lot expecting him to come in and bat 3 from the off. If we bat first, Stokes should go in at 3, if we bat 2nd, Root should bat 3.

He needs to prove he can score a hundred first. Stokes can hold our batting, bowling and fielding together all whilst being captain. That's one way to ensure he only plays for another 12 months.

Personally I'd be looking to bring another opener in to bat three with a view to moving up the order (as Strauss did). Bethel I think needs to come in and bat 5-6 if he's going to learn on the job. Root is our best ever batter, if he wants to bad four he can.
Reply
I see Stokes is asking for empathy towards the squad.

I am sure it is tough being on tour and away from your families etc. but the on and off field actions of the players will hardly garner much.

The behaviour in Noosa was particularly arrogant and selfish. The players will do what they are allowed to and this indiscipline is evident in all aspects of this tour. Starts at the top, needs to be chopped from there too.
Reply
(12-24-2025, 07:17 AM)Old Fart Wrote: Archer has a side strain and is out of the last two games.  Pope dropped at last.

Archer injured? Surely not...... Big Grin
Reply
(12-24-2025, 07:17 AM)Old Fart Wrote: Archer has a side strain and is out of the last two games.  Pope dropped at last.

So the guys who were going to blitz Oz and win the Ashes - Wood lasts one match and Archer lasts three. Who could possibly have predicted that?

Archer has actually done the Jimmy Anderson job so far, the only seamer who could nail an end down as well as taking wickets. Atkinson, Carse and Tongue don't have that capability between the three of them, and Stokes is probably not fully fit after his efforts in the first three Tests. With hindsight, will they wonder whether they were right to discard Ollie Robinson and sideline Matt Potts?

(12-24-2025, 09:59 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: I see Stokes is asking for empathy towards the squad.

I am sure it is tough being on tour and away from your families etc. but the on and off field actions of the players will hardly garner much.

The behaviour in Noosa was particularly arrogant and selfish. The players will do what they are allowed to and this indiscipline is evident in all aspects of this tour. Starts at the top, needs to be chopped from there too.

Yeah, it's quite entertaining that Stokes has shifted to "I'll do everything I can to help the guys through this". Yes, what a fucking terrible time they're having, going across the world to Australia and playing in some of the best stadia in the world. I'm glad I was never an elite international sportsman, or a rock star for that matter. Couldn't handle all that "pressure".

I'll be delighted when this arrogant and ignorant man is gone from England's cricket set-up. "Inspirational" he may have been, but as cricketers and as human beings the last few captains (Root, Cook, Strauss) have been head and shoulders above him.
Reply
(12-24-2025, 08:05 AM)Wednesburybaggie Wrote: Bethel will become a great player for England. But its a lot expecting him to come in and bat 3 from the off. If we bat first, Stokes should go in at 3, if we bat 2nd, Root should bat 3.

We have no idea if he’ll become a decent player, let alone a great player. He hasn’t made a first class century yet!
Reply
(12-24-2025, 12:34 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(12-24-2025, 08:05 AM)Wednesburybaggie Wrote: Bethel will become a great player for England. But its a lot expecting him to come in and bat 3 from the off. If we bat first, Stokes should go in at 3, if we bat 2nd, Root should bat 3.

We have no idea if he’ll become a decent player, let alone a great player. He hasn’t made a first class century yet!

Keep the faith, BSB, Bethell and Bashir will both be awesome!! Be told  Big Grin
Reply
(12-24-2025, 07:21 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: I've nothing against Jacob Bethel, and this may come back to bite me on the arse, but how do they think the answer to a failing number three is to bring in a kid who averages 28 in FC cricket with no hundreds to his name. Penny for the thoughts of the lads who've piled on runs in the CC last couple of summers having to watch this unfold. No wonder we're losing so many to the franchise circuit is it?

No issues with Archer being allowed to recover, he's more than justified his selection.

Not to mention the McCullum mantra Play without pressure. Here you go Jacob, I know you barely played a game all year but can you just step in at no.3 in front of 90000 people....
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 4 Guest(s)