Nestor
#11
(12-09-2025, 08:44 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(12-09-2025, 08:41 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Finding a good manager is much harder than finding players.

Yes he has to get the next one right. But I could see the logic in both appointments, but they haven't worked.

I disagree.

Nestor has been all about 'data' but then chose a manager with absolutely no previous records!

There's just so many variables a manager has to contend with, a player just has to manage their own body and performances. And the data is more specific for players. 

Some manager do great at some clubs and shit at others. So it's not always easy to get he right one. 

Mason had tons of coaching experience, experience of being a number 2 to some of the best coaches in world football and had managed u18/21s for spurs. And had a couple of caretaker roles so had some experience. Fwiw, not enough for me. But the logic was there.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#12
Some folk think if they keep repeating something over and over again others might start to give it credence.

Re: wanting CC out, even though it seemed he was looking elsewhere himself.
Reply
#13
You can't defend a manager every 150 days. He doesn't deserve a chance to fuck it up again, especially as we now have sk little room for error.
Reply
#14
Apart from Norwich's manager I think any other manager in this league would do better than Mason is.
Reply
#15
Whether they wanted Carlos out or not, he left us for his hometown club, so not really Nestor's fault there.
Could argue not his fault when his preferred candidate's backroom staff's wife got hold of West Bromwich Tourist Information's material.
Could also argue getting Mowbray back at short notice when we were left in the lurch wasn't unreasonable, although the length of contract seemed odd at the time.
Going for Mason was a complete punt into the unknown - if it had been based on some inside knowledge that he was a diamond you'd have thought we'd be seeing something to back that up by now. How likely is that though? As someone else said, it seems Nestor puts a lot of stall in 'data driven' decisions, yet picks a guy with zero data behind him.
Problem is we can't really afford to sack him this soon, even though it's apparent we are going backwards with zero signs of improvement, given the churn in managers under the new owners.
Too many bad decisions stacking up now under Nestor - if I was the owner he'd be gone along with Mason tomorrow morning, but I reckon he's going to get a minimum one other appointment to screw up.
Reply
#16
I’m not defending the decision to appoint Mason I’m arguing the buck for where we are currently lies with Nestor.
Reply
#17
(12-09-2025, 08:52 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I’m not defending the decision to appoint Mason I’m arguing the buck for where we are currently lies with Nestor.

Agree with you Dekka. How come tonight is the night you've gone on Mason?
Reply
#18
(12-09-2025, 08:53 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(12-09-2025, 08:52 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I’m not defending the decision to appoint Mason I’m arguing the buck for where we are currently lies with Nestor.

Agree with you Dekka. How come tonight is the night you've gone on Mason?

I never wanted him, but I thought it was churlish to want him sacked after a handful of games, however the last two and a half performances have been woeful. 

The manager should be the most important position to fill at any club, particularly one that is trying to stabilise itself after selling most of its best players and yet we gave the position to a rookie, it beggars belief.
Reply
#19
(12-09-2025, 08:58 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-09-2025, 08:53 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(12-09-2025, 08:52 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I’m not defending the decision to appoint Mason I’m arguing the buck for where we are currently lies with Nestor.

Agree with you Dekka. How come tonight is the night you've gone on Mason?

I never wanted him, but I thought it was churlish to want him sacked after a handful of games, however the last two and a half performances have been woeful. 

The manager should be the most important position to fill at any club, particularly one that is trying to stabilise itself after selling most of its best players and yet we gave the position to a rookie, it beggars belief.

Good post
Reply
#20
Deserved from grant
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: