Our owners are naive.
#11
(12-07-2025, 06:53 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: I'd imagine Dashworth will offer a similar response to McInnes...

This is the correct answer to all our questions. He’s ready
Reply
#12
(12-07-2025, 07:01 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: I see your point and raise you a similarly inexperienced owner coming in and appointing a huge amount of footballing experience in John Williams and Nicky Hammond who proceeded to give Pulis a new deal when he should have been waved off with a handshake and a thank you, then appointed Alan Pardew.

My concern with Nestor is that his stats based recruitment model may have been a huge competitive advantage 5 years ago, but now it is par for the course for most competitive Championship sides - at best currently we are merely keeping up with our peers behind the scenes, when with our financial disparity, we need to lead.

I think you're right. They really thought clubs weren't actually doing this already!? But, if you don't know what you're doing and nor does anybody else, you're going to have to heavily rely on stats. Except, bizarrely, when it came to appoint the manager. I wonder how long his stats sheet was... Column A - Not applicable, Column B - Not applicable, Column C - Not applicable, Column D - Not applicable....
Reply
#13
We HAVE to wait until next year to judge. The money sorts itself out and we'll find out if Mason was a cheap asset stand in or an error that Nestor made and can't buy his way out of.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#14
(12-07-2025, 07:35 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: We HAVE to wait until next year to judge. The money sorts itself out and we'll find out if Mason was a cheap asset stand in or an error that Nestor made and can't buy his way out of.

Money sorts itself out?

You mean PSR, which has jack shit to do with money.
Reply
#15
(12-07-2025, 06:53 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: I'd imagine Dashworth will offer a similar response to McInnes...


Yep. Such is the value of our stock presently.
Reply
#16
All fair points, Fuzzbox.

However, like SWBaggie said, we've had experience and "sensible appointments" and that was a mess too.

Despite football being a simple game, I look at various clubs and their owners and think that maybe it's not so easy. Look at Stoke. Local owners with deep pockets and we've outperformed them pretty much every season since we were both relegated. Norwich another club who have talked a lot, spent a lot and are now in the bottom three.
Reply
#17
I personally believe they bought us partly as a bet that the FFP rules will change in their favour. They've certainly spent a lot of time in talks with them.
Reply
#18
(12-07-2025, 09:51 PM)Squid Wrote: All fair points, Fuzzbox.

However, like SWBaggie said, we've had experience and "sensible appointments" and that was a mess too.

Despite football being a simple game, I look at various clubs and their owners and think that maybe it's not so easy. Look at Stoke. Local owners with deep pockets and we've outperformed them pretty much every season since we were both relegated. Norwich another club who have talked a lot, spent a lot and are now in the bottom three.

Stoke have probably made more cock ups in the transfer market than we have in the past ten years! Both of them have constantly changed managers, although Stoke have an excellent manager at the moment. I think Norwich will go down this season, they have bought badly and do not seem to produce young players like they used to nor buy good youngsters like Maddison
Reply
#19
(12-07-2025, 07:35 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: We HAVE to wait until next year to judge. The money sorts itself out and we'll find out if Mason was a cheap asset stand in or an error that Nestor made and can't buy his way out of.

Is how I see it. Once the PSR is off our backs, more flexibility to deal, get new players in, give Mason (who I believe will be here - disaster excluded - until the end of the season at least) their bet is that progress can be made.
Until then they expect to be treading water.
All it needs from fans is patience.
And of course football fans are renowned for that virtue.....
Reply
#20
(12-08-2025, 07:57 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote:
(12-07-2025, 07:35 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: We HAVE to wait until next year to judge. The money sorts itself out and we'll find out if Mason was a cheap asset stand in or an error that Nestor made and can't buy his way out of.

Is how I see it. Once the PSR is off our backs, more flexibility to deal, get new players in, give Mason (who I believe will be here - disaster excluded - until the end of the season at least) their bet is that progress can be made.
Until then they expect to be treading water.
All it needs from fans is patience.
And of course football fans are renowned for that virtue.....

That’s the crux of the matter.  How close are we to breaking PSR for the 3 years ending 25/26?  We may not be able to afford to pay off Mason’s remaining 2 1/2 year contract.  Then there’s the cost of compo if we recruit someone who is under contract. 

Come 1st  July 2026, we have a lot more flexibility re PSR, as the massive loss (of 23/24) is then excluded from the rolling 3 years average PSR calculation. 

So we may have to wait until the 1st July to sack him, unless of course we sell another player in Jan that generates a profit  (if we need that profit to cover the impact of replacing Mason).
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: