Our owners are naive.
#1
They have an American optimism that can either help you do more, 'break things' and learn as you go. However, on the negative side get you into positions where your hopelessly out of your depth without the humility to learn from your mistakes and climb out of the hole you've just dived into.

1) Employing the wrong director of football

He is vastly underqualified. The only experience in football he has is with a team that draws the same average attendance as Gillingham
He is a good friend of the owner (who is also inexperienced)
He is only doing the job part time 
The director then went and employed his friend who is a co-director in his ACTIVE company and who also has no experience in football. His CV is made up of hyped up positions in failed internet sites. He is also only working at wba part-time.
Is it too much to ask for total commitment in such an important job?

2) Employing the wrong manager

He is also vastly underqualified and the only experience he has is for a couple of matches as a 'stand-in'
The only thing I can think is that our footballing director got over-excited and thought he'd engineered a coup attracting a manager in waiting from one of the biggest clubs in Europe. If he had a little more knowledge he would have realised that Mason was never going to get a chance at tottenham on account of erm....he never has.  In truth, he had been passed over multiple times.

He says he is stats based, but his delight at getting a tottenham 'manager in waiting' blinded him to the fact he has no stats to his name.
Perhaps he should have come up with a young up and coming manager who actually had stats, and I don't know maybe employed an adviser who actually had experience and wouldn't be a threat to a new manager? That way they could fill a massive gap in the senior staff knowledge base.

Only in football would they buy a top 50 club with no relevant experience and then fill it with a senior management team that also has no absolutely no direct experience.

If the owner had any self-awareness, he would look at what's gone wrong and fix it. Unfortunately, it's a bit awkward when it's your mates that are primarily to blame.
Reply
#2
It's not the owners
It's not the managers
It's Nestor

It's the owners' blindness to Nestor is the problem imo.

All just my opinion. Doesn't make it true, just the way I see it.
Reply
#3
(12-07-2025, 06:31 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote: It's not the owners
It's not the managers
It's Nestor

It's the owners' blindness to Nestor is the problem imo.

All just my opinion. Doesn't make it true, just the way I see it.

As I said at end "Unfortunately, it's a bit awkward when it's your mates that are primarily to blame."  But ultimately, he made that choice. Why he thought it was the appropriate one is beyond me.
Reply
#4
(12-07-2025, 06:28 PM)fuzzbox Wrote: They have an American optimism that can either help you do more, 'break things' and learn as you go. However, on the negative side get you into positions where your hopelessly out of your depth without the humility to learn from your mistakes and climb out of the hole you've just dived into.

1) Employing the wrong director of football

He is vastly underqualified. The only experience in football he has is with a team that draws the same average attendance as Gillingham
He is a good friend of the owner (who is also inexperienced)
He is only doing the job part time 
The director then went and employed his friend who is a co-director in his ACTIVE company and who also has no experience in football. His CV is made up of hyped up positions in failed internet sites. He is also only working at wba part-time.
Is it too much to ask for total commitment in such an important job?

2) Employing the wrong manager

He is also vastly underqualified and the only experience he has is for a couple of matches as a 'stand-in'
The only thing I can think is that our footballing director thought he'd engineered a coup attracting a manager in waiting from one of the biggest names in Europe. If he had a little more knowledge he would have realised that Mason was never going to get a chance there on account of erm....he never has.  In truth, he had been passed over multiple times.

He says he is stats based, but his over excitement at getting a tottenham big name blinded him to the fact he has no stats to his name.
Perhaps he should have come up with a young up and coming manager who actually had stats, and I don't know maybe employed an adviser who actually had experience and wouldn't be a threat to a new manager. That way they could fill a massive gap in the senior staff knowledge base.

Only in football would they let people come to a top 50 club with absolutely no direct experience.

If the owner had any self-awareness, he would look at what's gone wrong and fix it. Unfortunately, it's a bit awkward when it's your mates that are primarily to blame.

I suggest you write to them offering your services or a point by point letter telling how they are getting it so wrong. It's about time these millionaires were taught a thing or 2.
Reply
#5
Isn't writing on here enough? I think they know who I am and understand how important and learned I am. I'm pretty certain they have me flagged as one of their 'favorites' on this site.

Failing that, I might just go the source of his money and write a strongly worded letter to his daddy and tell him his little boy needs to look after his toys better.
Reply
#6
If the club want to keep with the leadership structure they need to bring in someone to operate as a Director of Football I'm at least an advisory capacity to cover Nestor's deficiencies. Pearce is not that person

I know it's unlikely but he's currently out of a job and as far as I know not doing much right now given his advisory role with Warwickshire CCC is hardly that relevant in December, get Dashworth in for 18 months as an advisor until they learn what is actually needed.
Reply
#7
(12-07-2025, 06:46 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: If the club want to keep with the leadership structure they need to bring in someone to operate as a Director of Football I'm at least an advisory capacity to cover Nestor's deficiencies. Pearce is not that person

I know it's unlikely but he's currently out of a job and as far as I know not doing much right now given his advisory role with Warwickshire CCC is hardly that relevant in December, get Dashworth in for 18 months as an advisor until they learn what is actually needed.

He's back in post at the FA.
Reply
#8
(12-07-2025, 06:31 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote: It's not the owners
It's not the managers
It's Nestor

It's the owners' blindness to Nestor is the problem imo.

All just my opinion. Doesn't make it true, just the way I see it.

Nestor ain’t going nowhere.  He’s part of the Patel clan. Get used to it.
Reply
#9
I'd imagine Dashworth will offer a similar response to McInnes...
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#10
I see your point and raise you a similarly inexperienced owner coming in and appointing a huge amount of footballing experience in John Williams and Nicky Hammond who proceeded to give Pulis a new deal when he should have been waved off with a handshake and a thank you, then appointed Alan Pardew.

My concern with Nestor is that his stats based recruitment model may have been a huge competitive advantage 5 years ago, but now it is par for the course for most competitive Championship sides - at best currently we are merely keeping up with our peers behind the scenes, when with our financial disparity, we need to lead.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)