In support of Mason
#21
(11-30-2025, 11:38 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I have been fairly neutral with regards to Mason because I don’t know if he’s a good, bad or indifferent manager and neither does anyone else on here, no matter how they may argue they do. 

My position has crystallised since the final whistle blew last night but, I’ve been heading towards giving him more time over the last few weeks. My reasoning is you cannot judge a rookie manager after 17 matches, with half the squad new to the club, whilst we battle to sort out our finances as a club. We can continue to sack managers every six to twelve months but I cannot see how that will help the club move forward. It was different when we had parachute money but we don’t now, and we don’t have the luxury of buying our way out of the league as we’ve done previously. 

We have to show trust in the manager and give him the season to see what he can do. The caveat is ensuring we don’t look like we are in a relegation battle. We need some stability, a chance to move forward incrementally and with a clear plan, not lurch from one ‘crisis’ to another, like a junky trying to find his next fix. 

Another reason is, I think Mason is passionate, does care and is ambitious, I felt a degree of anger was released last night, now that may be just relief we won, but I think it was satisfying for him to give a ‘f you’ to some of our who have never given him much of a chance, it feels more like they are waiting for him to fail rather than succeed. Every decision he makes is picked apart, every good thing that happens is cautioned with some negative comment. 

So I’m sticking my neck out and saying he should stay for at least the season unless the wheels really do fall off, but when we are only 4-5pts off the playoffs, they really aren’t currently.
Tbf I think a few of us have been saying this for a while.
Every time we change manager (I notice he's no longer a "head coach"!), I post the same stat (CC excepted). That we change our manager every 8 months.
And it gets us F all. So we should (and I think we will) stick with him.

Having said that, at half time yesterday I was not so rational!
Reply
#22
(11-30-2025, 02:09 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-30-2025, 02:05 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Mason in a desperation bid, changed the players and changed the result.
He now knows that we can win games if we press and score goals.
He's reached a crossroads, he either plays like we did in the first half and he gets sacked.
Or he plays like we did in the second half and stays, the choice is his.
We must remember his position is based on results, he gets a tidy wedge to make us a successful team.
Time waits for no man.

… then employ someone with experience, if you want consistency of decision making.

Derek, I am consistent I don't converse with idiots.
Reply
#23
Personally, the jury's still out. After all, beating Swansea isn't such a great achievement and we nearly screwed it up. On the plus side, we didn't screw it up (but we made it difficult). he made changes early and  probably most important, the players seem keen on him.

But on balance, I think Mr. Hardballs is right.

Having said that, I have never clamoured for him to be sacked anyway. I do think it is strange that someone with really no experience would be given the job as manager of a top 50 club, though. Especially one still in a difficult position. It's just not a role for someone to 'learn' in. There can't be many industries where that would happen. Doing it in football where everything is so ruthless and results driven is just bizarre. But, he can't blamed for that.

It doesn't really matter what we think of the appointment, now it's been made. As soon as it was decided to give an inexperienced manager the chance, we almost have to let him learn, otherwise what's the point?

For me, it's more about who is available and willing to come. If Mason starts to learn, then the potential manager has to be special. Right now, I'd only replace him if someone 'quite special' turned up (Guess who?!).
Reply
#24
(11-30-2025, 03:17 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(11-30-2025, 02:09 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-30-2025, 02:05 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Mason in a desperation bid, changed the players and changed the result.
He now knows that we can win games if we press and score goals.
He's reached a crossroads, he either plays like we did in the first half and he gets sacked.
Or he plays like we did in the second half and stays, the choice is his.
We must remember his position is based on results, he gets a tidy wedge to make us a successful team.
Time waits for no man.

… then employ someone with experience, if you want consistency of decision making.

Derek, I am consistent I don't converse with idiots.

Probably best not to talk to yourself then.
Reply
#25
(11-30-2025, 03:21 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-30-2025, 03:17 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(11-30-2025, 02:09 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-30-2025, 02:05 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Mason in a desperation bid, changed the players and changed the result.
He now knows that we can win games if we press and score goals.
He's reached a crossroads, he either plays like we did in the first half and he gets sacked.
Or he plays like we did in the second half and stays, the choice is his.
We must remember his position is based on results, he gets a tidy wedge to make us a successful team.
Time waits for no man.

… then employ someone with experience, if you want consistency of decision making.

Derek, I am consistent I don't converse with idiots.

Probably best not to talk to yourself then.

Merry Xmas  Big Grin
Reply
#26
Weird comment in the after match interview, when asked what he said at halftime he credited the players and said the win was nothing to do with him. Very strange in my book.
Reply
#27
I don't think that's a strange comment.
Reply
#28
Look up Judith Chalmers WYWH
Reply
#29
(11-30-2025, 03:26 PM)sickParrot Wrote: Weird comment in the after match interview, when asked what he said at halftime he credited the players and said the win was nothing to do with him. Very strange in my book.

It did sound a bit odd I admit. Normally a manager will answer something along the lines of " Well we needed to make changes as that first half performance wasn't acceptable " but I guess he was just trying to say the players deserve the credit.

Who knows what was said but the fact remains at halftime yesterday Mason was fighting for his job and threw an almighty Hail Mary and threw on 4 subs. It was pretty much forced rather anything amazingly tactical imo. Whatever, it paid off and the subs made an impact, and Mason looks like a genius.

I'm really pleased because I hate seeing us lose. All I give a shit about is 3 points and we got them. I just really hope now that Mason sees those players that changed things, especially Beilik and Maja, and continues with them. Maja looked great in the 10 role and Beilik has always been a great player and leader.

Fingers crossed our season can turn around as a result of that debacle of a first half.....
Reply
#30
I said I'd seen some small shoots of hope against Blues, they'd all but vanished after that first half against Swansea though, then there they were in the second half again... I kind of expected the first half to be like the second, and if it had been then things would have looked more rosy.

In lieu of that tiny hope I think he does actually deserve a few more games... up to Christmas I think now, where I wanted him gone before. With the games we've got coming up though, I think it really could be sink or swim.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 13 Guest(s)