In support of Mason
#1
I have been fairly neutral with regards to Mason because I don’t know if he’s a good, bad or indifferent manager and neither does anyone else on here, no matter how they may argue they do. 

My position has crystallised since the final whistle blew last night but, I’ve been heading towards giving him more time over the last few weeks. My reasoning is you cannot judge a rookie manager after 17 matches, with half the squad new to the club, whilst we battle to sort out our finances as a club. We can continue to sack managers every six to twelve months but I cannot see how that will help the club move forward. It was different when we had parachute money but we don’t now, and we don’t have the luxury of buying our way out of the league as we’ve done previously. 

We have to show trust in the manager and give him the season to see what he can do. The caveat is ensuring we don’t look like we are in a relegation battle. We need some stability, a chance to move forward incrementally and with a clear plan, not lurch from one ‘crisis’ to another, like a junky trying to find his next fix. 

Another reason is, I think Mason is passionate, does care and is ambitious, I felt a degree of anger was released last night, now that may be just relief we won, but I think it was satisfying for him to give a ‘f you’ to some of our who have never given him much of a chance, it feels more like they are waiting for him to fail rather than succeed. Every decision he makes is picked apart, every good thing that happens is cautioned with some negative comment. 

So I’m sticking my neck out and saying he should stay for at least the season unless the wheels really do fall off, but when we are only 4-5pts off the playoffs, they really aren’t currently.
Reply
#2
WYWH

All my love,

Derek
Raw Sausage
Reply
#3
(11-30-2025, 11:43 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: WYWH

All my love,

Derek

No idea what that means 

Love Derek
Reply
#4
I think if we do stay away from the relegation zone this year the club will keep him on for the season which is fair enough. The constant chopping and changing of managers never normally leads to any kind of success and as a club I doubt we can afford to be paying up more contracts early on.

The key thing is to see signs from Mason that he is learning from his mistakes as a coach and making progress in his decision making. Yesterday was a sign that this may be happening. I really hope he doesn't revert to type next week though. We'll have to see but I really hope yesterday's comeback was one of the performances on which a more successful season can be built.
Reply
#5
Dekka, I agree with all that.

The criticism of him has been fair, but if yesterday is anything to go by, maybe he's learning.
Reply
#6
Alternatively he's beaten Oxford and Swansea at home, in comeback wins, after making a mess of things initially. These are our only two wins since in 8 games since mid October.

If we don't get something at QPR/Southampton (both below us in the league) we'll be back where we were at 3pm yesterday come Sheffield United at home on Friday week - another must win game to keep fans off his back.
Reply
#7
(11-30-2025, 11:49 AM)Man from delmonte Wrote: I think if we do stay away from the relegation zone this year the club will keep him on for the season which is fair enough. The constant chopping and changing of managers never normally leads to any kind of success and as a club I doubt we can afford to be paying up more contracts early on.

The key thing is to see signs from Mason that he is learning from his mistakes as a coach and making progress in his decision making. Yesterday was a sign that this may be happening. I really hope he doesn't revert to type next week though. We'll have to see but I really hope yesterday's comeback was one of the performances on which a more successful season can be built.

Agree with this but we do need to see evidence of development. The ruthless subs yesterday suggested a change there but we need to see it over weeks rather than just one half.
Reply
#8
(11-30-2025, 12:23 PM)Jacko Wrote: Alternatively he's beaten Oxford and Swansea at home, in comeback wins, after making a mess of things initially. These are our only two wins since in 8 games since mid October.

If we don't get something at QPR/Southampton (both below us in the league) we'll be back where we were at 3pm yesterday come Sheffield United at home on Friday week - another must win game to keep fans off his back.

Congratulations for proving all my points in such a short couple of paragraphs Wink
Reply
#9
(11-30-2025, 11:49 AM)Man from delmonte Wrote: I think if we do stay away from the relegation zone this year the club will keep him on for the season which is fair enough. The constant chopping and changing of managers never normally leads to any kind of success and as a club I doubt we can afford to be paying up more contracts early on.

The key thing is to see signs from Mason that he is learning from his mistakes as a coach and making progress in his decision making. Yesterday was a sign that this may be happening. I really hope he doesn't revert to type next week though. We'll have to see but I really hope yesterday's comeback was one of the performances on which a more successful season can be built.

Agree.

In theory, despite being one of his harshest critics, I would like us to have some stability with Mason, and would like us to give him every opportunity to be a success here, but he has to earn that good will, which taking away the emotion of yesterday, he hasn't done often enough this season. 

On the face of it, we are 5 points off 4th place, which is where many of us expected to be - had we said we'd be in touching distance of the playoffs at this point during pre-season I think we'd have said it would have represented a decent season so far given the transfer constraints and rebuilding efforts. However, what is transpiring this season is that the league is wide open, and even a modicum of consistency is enough to have a team in the playoffs. The frustration for me comes from the sheer number of opportunities we've failed to take, be it overly cautious changes, lack of confidence to push for the win, or even blind stupidity like at Coventry... had we actually showed up against Sheff Wed, turned the screw against Charlton when we were on top, not shot ourselves in the foot at 2-0 up against Coventry, made changes with an intent to win the game in the utterly dire games at home to Pompey and Derby, or even with Blues midweek... who knows where we would be right now... I'm not saying throwing caution to the wind in all those games would have ended in us having another 10+ points on the board but just showing that intention to win games would have brought Mason more good will at the very least.

I really, really hope Saturday was a turning point for Mason, and I hope we go into two winnable away games at a shambolic QPR and a Saints team that although carrying plenty of quality, can be got at with a plan to bloody some noses. If we see the same timid, tepid, cautious, overly patient football there will rightly be pressure on Mason again and Sheff Utd will take a lot more beating than Oxford and Swansea when it comes to again having to save his job with a home win!
Reply
#10
(11-30-2025, 12:28 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-30-2025, 12:23 PM)Jacko Wrote: Alternatively he's beaten Oxford and Swansea at home, in comeback wins, after making a mess of things initially. These are our only two wins since in 8 games since mid October.

If we don't get something at QPR/Southampton (both below us in the league) we'll be back where we were at 3pm yesterday come Sheffield United at home on Friday week - another must win game to keep fans off his back.

Congratulations for proving all my points in such a short couple of paragraphs Wink

What parts of what I've said do you disagree with?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 13 Guest(s)