Villa FFP - it ay over yet
#31
(06-14-2019, 10:11 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(06-14-2019, 06:23 PM)Begley Wrote:
(06-14-2019, 06:14 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(06-14-2019, 06:12 PM)Begley Wrote:
(06-14-2019, 05:21 PM)Peachy Wrote: Doubt anything is going to happen to them now. They cheated and they've won. Plain and simple.

First call I had today was from a villa fan telling me they had  signed Wesley and how they were going for Europe.

What exactly have Villa done that was cheating?

Spent £50m more than anyone is allowed to, funding big last minute deals for Abraham and el-Ghazi, and handed Grealish who effectively promoted them a new deal when they’d been told to reduce their wage bill.

Anything other than conjecture? All clubs have to submit their accounts to EFL for review. If the media is to believed it does appear that Villa has over spent but I haven't seen any evidence to say they have. They haven't done a Derby and sold their ground to themselves and leased it back and the club is saying they are compliant. Apparently Purslow said the other day that the EFL also confirmed they were compliant but EFL has not confirmed. Abraham was a loan, El Ghazi was a loan Grealish was a pay rise, the total for these 3 player would be 7m, maybe 8m.
I wouldn’t say it was conjecture. Swiss ramble delved into their finances and concluded they had a £40m gap to fill to comply with FFFP regs. As a result they were one of 3 clubs to have to submit their accounts in advance for checking. 

Abraham was reported to be paid £75k/wk and Villa were paying the full wages...

As you’ve said, the EFL have yet to confirm any compliance... but anyone with any sense can clearly see they have overspent, it’s just whether or not they have found a loophole.

If they haven’t done a sale and leaseback of their ground then they haven’t found a loophole.

I’m as certain as it’s possible to be that Villa have massively failed FFP.  I fear the EFL have allowed them to get away with it and that all will be revealed next March when they file their audited accounts. Far too late of course, but it will trigger a huge legal case led by Gibson against the EFL for having failed to apply their own regulations.

(06-14-2019, 09:31 PM)Begley Wrote:
(06-14-2019, 09:09 PM)hudds Wrote:
(06-14-2019, 09:04 PM)Begley Wrote:
(06-14-2019, 08:49 PM)hudds Wrote:
(06-14-2019, 08:42 PM)Begley Wrote: Wait and see is a good hint that there is no evidence. 

I do look forward to seeing Villa's accounts when they are published because on the surface it does look like they may have overspent and would like to see what the real numbers are. I expect that they have managed to do something clever but from what is been reported the Villa CEO has confirmed that the EFL said that Villa has passed P&S

I'm more interested now to wait and see.  I don't hate the Villa - you are inconsequential Brummies.  But if there has been non-compliance to the detriment of a complaint club (us),  I am happy to be advised by somebody unlocking legal matters to wait and see.  I can infer a lot from that.

LOL, wait and see rather than act now. 

If any evidence of wrong doing is discovered then the EFL has procedures to follow through with this, they have also recently agreed with the Premier League to apply sanctions to newly promoted teams. However, as there is no evidence and the Villa CEO has stated that the EFL has informed him that AVFC is compliant I guess you will be waiting a long time.

I think things are happening now.  So yes, I'm happy to wait and see.  I think it may be whether/how the sanctions are applied cross-league.

The method for ross league sanctions have been agreed, it wouldn't be that. The big problem with P&S is that if a club breaks the rules and manages to get promoted there really is fcuk all that can be done about it. They won't lose their place in the PL as the PL need 20 teams and it would be very bad PR for the PL. Also, lets say Villa get done for non compliance, there are loads of clubs in the EFL that can claim they missed out as a result. Obviously Baggies, Derby would have a case and Boro too. I can't see Villa getting fined 200m, maybe 20m and that is a fine that a newly promoted team can absorb. The full system is wrong

The issue is that the EFL specifically changed their own regulations 3 years ago so that clubs in breach would be sanctioned before the end of the 3rd season of the 3-year cycle, rather than realising non-compliance only 9 months later when they publish their accounts but have already been promoted.  From February/March onwards, clubs on the watchlist are supposed to be submitting monthly management accounts and monthly updated forecasts for the rest of the season to enable the EFL to confirm non-compliance. The regulations specifically state that the EFL can deny promotion, deny a playoff place, issue fines or transfer embargoes, and any EFL sanctions will be applied by the PL (and vice versa).  I fear that the EFL somehow gave assurance to Villa’s new owners that they would not be sanctioned as part of their takeover deal.

There is not a cat in hell’s chance that Villa have met the “maximum permitted loss of £39m in 3 years” limit, given their losses in 2016/7 and 2017/8, and their spending/lack of big transfer sales in 2018/9 (the third season in the 3-year cycle). Unless they’ve sold Villa Park for a value which probably can’t be considered “arms length”.
Reply
#32
(06-14-2019, 10:42 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(06-14-2019, 10:11 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(06-14-2019, 06:23 PM)Begley Wrote:
(06-14-2019, 06:14 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(06-14-2019, 06:12 PM)Begley Wrote: What exactly have Villa done that was cheating?

Spent £50m more than anyone is allowed to, funding big last minute deals for Abraham and el-Ghazi, and handed Grealish who effectively promoted them a new deal when they’d been told to reduce their wage bill.

Anything other than conjecture? All clubs have to submit their accounts to EFL for review. If the media is to believed it does appear that Villa has over spent but I haven't seen any evidence to say they have. They haven't done a Derby and sold their ground to themselves and leased it back and the club is saying they are compliant. Apparently Purslow said the other day that the EFL also confirmed they were compliant but EFL has not confirmed. Abraham was a loan, El Ghazi was a loan Grealish was a pay rise, the total for these 3 player would be 7m, maybe 8m.
I wouldn’t say it was conjecture. Swiss ramble delved into their finances and concluded they had a £40m gap to fill to comply with FFFP regs. As a result they were one of 3 clubs to have to submit their accounts in advance for checking. 

Abraham was reported to be paid £75k/wk and Villa were paying the full wages...

As you’ve said, the EFL have yet to confirm any compliance... but anyone with any sense can clearly see they have overspent, it’s just whether or not they have found a loophole.

If they haven’t done a sale and leaseback of their ground then they haven’t found a loophole.

I’m as certain as it’s possible to be that Villa have massively failed FFP.  I fear the EFL have allowed them to get away with it and that all will be revealed next March when they file their audited accounts. Far too late of course, but it will trigger a huge legal case led by Gibson against the EFL for having failed to apply their own regulations.

(06-14-2019, 09:31 PM)Begley Wrote:
(06-14-2019, 09:09 PM)hudds Wrote:
(06-14-2019, 09:04 PM)Begley Wrote:
(06-14-2019, 08:49 PM)hudds Wrote: I'm more interested now to wait and see.  I don't hate the Villa - you are inconsequential Brummies.  But if there has been non-compliance to the detriment of a complaint club (us),  I am happy to be advised by somebody unlocking legal matters to wait and see.  I can infer a lot from that.

LOL, wait and see rather than act now. 

If any evidence of wrong doing is discovered then the EFL has procedures to follow through with this, they have also recently agreed with the Premier League to apply sanctions to newly promoted teams. However, as there is no evidence and the Villa CEO has stated that the EFL has informed him that AVFC is compliant I guess you will be waiting a long time.

I think things are happening now.  So yes, I'm happy to wait and see.  I think it may be whether/how the sanctions are applied cross-league.

The method for ross league sanctions have been agreed, it wouldn't be that. The big problem with P&S is that if a club breaks the rules and manages to get promoted there really is fcuk all that can be done about it. They won't lose their place in the PL as the PL need 20 teams and it would be very bad PR for the PL. Also, lets say Villa get done for non compliance, there are loads of clubs in the EFL that can claim they missed out as a result. Obviously Baggies, Derby would have a case and Boro too. I can't see Villa getting fined 200m, maybe 20m and that is a fine that a newly promoted team can absorb. The full system is wrong

The issue is that the EFL specifically changed their own regulations 3 years ago so that clubs in breach would be sanctioned before the end of the 3rd season of the 3-year cycle, rather than realising non-compliance only 9 months later when they publish their accounts but have already been promoted.  From February/March onwards, clubs on the watchlist are supposed to be submitting monthly management accounts and monthly updated forecasts for the rest of the season to enable the EFL to confirm non-compliance. The regulations specifically state that the EFL can deny promotion, deny a playoff place, issue fines or transfer embargoes, and any EFL sanctions will be applied by the PL (and vice versa).  I fear that the EFL somehow gave assurance to Villa’s new owners that they would not be sanctioned as part of their takeover deal.

There is not a cat in hell’s chance that Villa have met the “maximum permitted loss of £39m in 3 years” limit, given their losses in 2016/7 and 2017/8, and their spending/lack of big transfer sales in 2018/9 (the third season in the 3-year cycle). Unless they’ve sold Villa Park for a value which probably can’t be considered “arms length”.

I know fugg all about the financial & legal niceties of FFP but it seems to me that(and yet to be confirmed) Villa cheated the system and the EFL stood by and allowed it as its a big club and if they sanction them they would have then set a precedent that the EFL  themselves would be unable to keep in future plus Villas owners have lots of money and clout for legal battles, better the EFL come down on the likes of blues etc who ain't got the ability to make the EFL'S life awkward in court, call me an old cynic but money talks and Vile have loads, plus the EFL are fuggin toothless wankers. Let's hope Gibson and a few others rentlessly push this and make the EFL'S life a misery.
Reply
#33
(06-14-2019, 08:01 PM)Begley Wrote:
(06-14-2019, 07:57 PM)hudds Wrote:
(06-14-2019, 07:27 PM)Begley Wrote:
(06-14-2019, 07:11 PM)hudds Wrote:
(06-14-2019, 05:21 PM)Peachy Wrote: Doubt anything is going to happen to them now. They cheated and they've won. Plain and simple.

First call I had today was from a villa fan telling me they had  signed Wesley and how they were going for Europe.

I've never once claimed to be ITK or speculated.

Last night was a summer party for top chambers - heaving with lawyers letting their hair down.  One QC I work with introduced me to another lawyer, telling him I was a Baggie.  Lawyer B says - "good decent club to deal with".  I said "too decent - look what happens when you play by the rules - or when you don't. Like the Villa.  They got away with it."  Lawyer B  then said something very interesting.    I further gleaned that Gibson is still on the warpath.  Lot of work for lawyers....

Sounds as credible as the leaked PL fixtures  Smile
The Chambers does a lot of representative work, for the EFL as well as the clubs.  As well as representing players (including one of ours who was a big name and caused us hassle...)  My QC mate introduced me to the brief on that job (just to say hello as a Baggie).  It's wholly credible albeit a brief comment.  Bear in mind this is a dispassionate lawyer, not a Villa-hating Baggie on a web site who's pored over the accounts wishing them the worst...

Lawyers do not gossip and in particular leak sensitive information. Not only is it illegal and they would be disbarred if they they were caught it would also seriously undermine their credibility.
Big Grin Big Grin Big Grin Big Grin Big Grin Big Grin Big Grin Big Grin ...........
The naivety points at Ziz for me.
Reply
#34
(06-14-2019, 10:34 PM)The liquidator Wrote:
(06-14-2019, 08:31 PM)Begley Wrote:
(06-14-2019, 08:14 PM)Old Stroller Wrote:
(06-14-2019, 08:11 PM)tiptontown Wrote:
(06-14-2019, 08:08 PM)Old Stroller Wrote: Begley’s calling you a liar Hudds. The Villa twat (him, not you).

Just thinking the same thing. It seems to have got under his skin a bit.


Oh, he’s openly Villa. Check back to his posts during the play offs.


Yes do check them out. All polite and reasoned and wishing the Baggies luck next season and the amount abuse I got was amazing. Is there a problem with football fans discussing football and debating issues? Personally I think it is a good thing for different fans to post on different club's blogs. I would be really interested to see information about Villa and FFP. If one was to believe some of the stuff in the media then Villa look to have failed FFP but if I look for any evidence to back it up there is none and any of the people who claim Villa cheated can't provide any. Can you provide any?

Fuck off you villa cunt
you can always rely on the idiot support to raise his head on a blog. Well done, did you come up with that comment all or your own or did u manage to get some help with it?

(06-14-2019, 10:42 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(06-14-2019, 10:11 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(06-14-2019, 06:23 PM)Begley Wrote:
(06-14-2019, 06:14 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(06-14-2019, 06:12 PM)Begley Wrote: What exactly have Villa done that was cheating?

Spent £50m more than anyone is allowed to, funding big last minute deals for Abraham and el-Ghazi, and handed Grealish who effectively promoted them a new deal when they’d been told to reduce their wage bill.

Anything other than conjecture? All clubs have to submit their accounts to EFL for review. If the media is to believed it does appear that Villa has over spent but I haven't seen any evidence to say they have. They haven't done a Derby and sold their ground to themselves and leased it back and the club is saying they are compliant. Apparently Purslow said the other day that the EFL also confirmed they were compliant but EFL has not confirmed. Abraham was a loan, El Ghazi was a loan Grealish was a pay rise, the total for these 3 player would be 7m, maybe 8m.
I wouldn’t say it was conjecture. Swiss ramble delved into their finances and concluded they had a £40m gap to fill to comply with FFFP regs. As a result they were one of 3 clubs to have to submit their accounts in advance for checking. 

Abraham was reported to be paid £75k/wk and Villa were paying the full wages...

As you’ve said, the EFL have yet to confirm any compliance... but anyone with any sense can clearly see they have overspent, it’s just whether or not they have found a loophole.

If they haven’t done a sale and leaseback of their ground then they haven’t found a loophole.

I’m as certain as it’s possible to be that Villa have massively failed FFP.  I fear the EFL have allowed them to get away with it and that all will be revealed next March when they file their audited accounts. Far too late of course, but it will trigger a huge legal case led by Gibson against the EFL for having failed to apply their own regulations.

(06-14-2019, 09:31 PM)Begley Wrote:
(06-14-2019, 09:09 PM)hudds Wrote:
(06-14-2019, 09:04 PM)Begley Wrote:
(06-14-2019, 08:49 PM)hudds Wrote: I'm more interested now to wait and see.  I don't hate the Villa - you are inconsequential Brummies.  But if there has been non-compliance to the detriment of a complaint club (us),  I am happy to be advised by somebody unlocking legal matters to wait and see.  I can infer a lot from that.

LOL, wait and see rather than act now. 

If any evidence of wrong doing is discovered then the EFL has procedures to follow through with this, they have also recently agreed with the Premier League to apply sanctions to newly promoted teams. However, as there is no evidence and the Villa CEO has stated that the EFL has informed him that AVFC is compliant I guess you will be waiting a long time.

I think things are happening now.  So yes, I'm happy to wait and see.  I think it may be whether/how the sanctions are applied cross-league.

The method for ross league sanctions have been agreed, it wouldn't be that. The big problem with P&S is that if a club breaks the rules and manages to get promoted there really is fcuk all that can be done about it. They won't lose their place in the PL as the PL need 20 teams and it would be very bad PR for the PL. Also, lets say Villa get done for non compliance, there are loads of clubs in the EFL that can claim they missed out as a result. Obviously Baggies, Derby would have a case and Boro too. I can't see Villa getting fined 200m, maybe 20m and that is a fine that a newly promoted team can absorb. The full system is wrong

The issue is that the EFL specifically changed their own regulations 3 years ago so that clubs in breach would be sanctioned before the end of the 3rd season of the 3-year cycle, rather than realising non-compliance only 9 months later when they publish their accounts but have already been promoted.  From February/March onwards, clubs on the watchlist are supposed to be submitting monthly management accounts and monthly updated forecasts for the rest of the season to enable the EFL to confirm non-compliance. The regulations specifically state that the EFL can deny promotion, deny a playoff place, issue fines or transfer embargoes, and any EFL sanctions will be applied by the PL (and vice versa).  I fear that the EFL somehow gave assurance to Villa’s new owners that they would not be sanctioned as part of their takeover deal.

There is not a cat in hell’s chance that Villa have met the “maximum permitted loss of £39m in 3 years” limit, given their losses in 2016/7 and 2017/8, and their spending/lack of big transfer sales in 2018/9 (the third season in the 3-year cycle). Unless they’ve sold Villa Park for a value which probably can’t be considered “arms length”.

I don't know what Villa did in the last season but they haven't sold the ground. It is a protected building and cannot be sold without approval which is in the public domain. In Bruce's term as manager there was a net profit on player sales albeit he did spend a fortune on wages. To be compliant in the recent season Villa could only make a loss of about 8m to be within the 39m limit. The HS2 compensation money will be contributing to the P&S in Villa's favour but there is a limit as to how much that can be. Villa's last 10 home games are so were all in excess 40k attendances which is about 1.2m in revenue per game, plus there were some televised games. I can't see that the EFL would give Villa a special deal at the time Xia sold, that would be cause all sorts of shit with other clubs. I am sure the fact that Purslow was on the committee that created the original FFP rules can only help Villa in their understanding of how to manage them

(06-14-2019, 11:21 PM)TETLEY74 Wrote:
(06-14-2019, 10:42 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(06-14-2019, 10:11 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(06-14-2019, 06:23 PM)Begley Wrote:
(06-14-2019, 06:14 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Spent £50m more than anyone is allowed to, funding big last minute deals for Abraham and el-Ghazi, and handed Grealish who effectively promoted them a new deal when they’d been told to reduce their wage bill.

Anything other than conjecture? All clubs have to submit their accounts to EFL for review. If the media is to believed it does appear that Villa has over spent but I haven't seen any evidence to say they have. They haven't done a Derby and sold their ground to themselves and leased it back and the club is saying they are compliant. Apparently Purslow said the other day that the EFL also confirmed they were compliant but EFL has not confirmed. Abraham was a loan, El Ghazi was a loan Grealish was a pay rise, the total for these 3 player would be 7m, maybe 8m.
I wouldn’t say it was conjecture. Swiss ramble delved into their finances and concluded they had a £40m gap to fill to comply with FFFP regs. As a result they were one of 3 clubs to have to submit their accounts in advance for checking. 

Abraham was reported to be paid £75k/wk and Villa were paying the full wages...

As you’ve said, the EFL have yet to confirm any compliance... but anyone with any sense can clearly see they have overspent, it’s just whether or not they have found a loophole.

If they haven’t done a sale and leaseback of their ground then they haven’t found a loophole.

I’m as certain as it’s possible to be that Villa have massively failed FFP.  I fear the EFL have allowed them to get away with it and that all will be revealed next March when they file their audited accounts. Far too late of course, but it will trigger a huge legal case led by Gibson against the EFL for having failed to apply their own regulations.

(06-14-2019, 09:31 PM)Begley Wrote:
(06-14-2019, 09:09 PM)hudds Wrote:
(06-14-2019, 09:04 PM)Begley Wrote: LOL, wait and see rather than act now. 

If any evidence of wrong doing is discovered then the EFL has procedures to follow through with this, they have also recently agreed with the Premier League to apply sanctions to newly promoted teams. However, as there is no evidence and the Villa CEO has stated that the EFL has informed him that AVFC is compliant I guess you will be waiting a long time.

I think things are happening now.  So yes, I'm happy to wait and see.  I think it may be whether/how the sanctions are applied cross-league.

The method for ross league sanctions have been agreed, it wouldn't be that. The big problem with P&S is that if a club breaks the rules and manages to get promoted there really is fcuk all that can be done about it. They won't lose their place in the PL as the PL need 20 teams and it would be very bad PR for the PL. Also, lets say Villa get done for non compliance, there are loads of clubs in the EFL that can claim they missed out as a result. Obviously Baggies, Derby would have a case and Boro too. I can't see Villa getting fined 200m, maybe 20m and that is a fine that a newly promoted team can absorb. The full system is wrong

The issue is that the EFL specifically changed their own regulations 3 years ago so that clubs in breach would be sanctioned before the end of the 3rd season of the 3-year cycle, rather than realising non-compliance only 9 months later when they publish their accounts but have already been promoted.  From February/March onwards, clubs on the watchlist are supposed to be submitting monthly management accounts and monthly updated forecasts for the rest of the season to enable the EFL to confirm non-compliance. The regulations specifically state that the EFL can deny promotion, deny a playoff place, issue fines or transfer embargoes, and any EFL sanctions will be applied by the PL (and vice versa).  I fear that the EFL somehow gave assurance to Villa’s new owners that they would not be sanctioned as part of their takeover deal.

There is not a cat in hell’s chance that Villa have met the “maximum permitted loss of £39m in 3 years” limit, given their losses in 2016/7 and 2017/8, and their spending/lack of big transfer sales in 2018/9 (the third season in the 3-year cycle). Unless they’ve sold Villa Park for a value which probably can’t be considered “arms length”.

I know fugg all about the financial & legal niceties of FFP but it seems to me that(and yet to be confirmed) Villa cheated the system and the EFL stood by and allowed it as its a big club and if they sanction them they would have then set a precedent that the EFL  themselves would be unable to keep in future plus Villas owners have lots of money and clout for legal battles, better the EFL come down on the likes of blues etc who ain't got the ability to make the EFL'S life awkward in court, call me an old cynic but money talks and Vile have loads, plus the EFL are fuggin toothless wankers. Let's hope Gibson and a few others rentlessly push this and make the EFL'S life a misery.

I don't believe this 'big club' conspiracy theory. Blues failed P&S and were given a slap on the wrist and put under an embargo as a punishment. While they were under embargo they then broke the rules and effectively gave two fingers to the EFL. They or any other team that does that deserves a punishment.
Reply
#35
(06-14-2019, 05:21 PM)Peachy Wrote: Doubt anything is going to happen to them now. They cheated and they've won. Plain and simple.

First call I had today was from a villa fan telling me they had  signed Wesley and how they were going for Europe.

The seals have invested about 50m so far....let's see what they done. 

Hause - 3m - didn't play much last season - squad player. 

Jota - ???? 3/4m replacement for Adomah - didn't pull any trees up at Blose but maybe Smith can play a tune.

El Ghazi - 8m  - not an improvement as there last season 

Wesley 22m - Belgian League no where near as good as the Prem.  Massive, massive gamble.  

Others linked;

Butland - 25m  lol please do

Phillips -  14m bid  - decent player nothing special.  Bid rejected by Leeds. 

Their defence is shite and they will have to pay 20m for Mings (made a big mistake in not doing a temp to perm. 

Also linked with Dunk but doubtful.  Another 20m if Brighton sell. 

So looks like it's heading towards 100m plus without really improving the overall quality of their team that finished the season. 

Has Fulham written all over it.   Big Grin
Reply
#36
(06-15-2019, 12:22 AM)Hopalong Wrote:
(06-14-2019, 05:21 PM)Peachy Wrote: Doubt anything is going to happen to them now. They cheated and they've won. Plain and simple.

First call I had today was from a villa fan telling me they had  signed Wesley and how they were going for Europe.

The seals have invested about 50m so far....let's see what they done. 

Hause - 3m - didn't play much last season - squad player. 

Jota - ???? 3/4m replacement for Adomah - didn't pull any trees up at Blose but maybe Smith can play a tune.

El Ghazi - 8m  - not an improvement as there last season 

Wesley 22m - Belgian League no where near as good as the Prem.  Massive, massive gamble.  

Others linked;

Butland - 25m  lol please do

Phillips -  14m bid  - decent player nothing special.  Bid rejected by Leeds. 

Their defence is shite and they will have to pay 20m for Mings (made a big mistake in not doing a temp to perm. 

Also linked with Dunk but doubtful.  Another 20m if Brighton sell. 

So looks like it's heading towards 100m plus without really improving the overall quality of their team that finished the season. 

Has Fulham written all over it.   Big Grin

10 players were released already taking about 400k a week off the wage bill. Villa didn't have a team capable of surviving the PL, only managed 5th in the Chumps, scraped past Baggies in the semis and a close final. There is no choice but to try and buy a completely new team and try and survive. 3 players brought in for about 30m so far, Hause is not a Villa player (yet). Villa need to buy another 8 or 9 players just to have a 1st 11 and a bit of depth to cover injuries next season so will probably spend 100m+ this season. Yes it could be another Fulham and maybe it won't, however I would much prefer to be having a go in the Premier League and having the cash to do so that slumming it in the Championship not being able to keep hold of the players and shopping in Poundland for new ones  Big Grin
Reply
#37
(06-15-2019, 12:22 AM)Hopalong Wrote:
(06-14-2019, 05:21 PM)Peachy Wrote: Doubt anything is going to happen to them now. They cheated and they've won. Plain and simple.

First call I had today was from a villa fan telling me they had  signed Wesley and how they were going for Europe.

The seals have invested about 50m so far....let's see what they done. 

Hause - 3m - didn't play much last season - squad player. 

Jota - ???? 3/4m replacement for Adomah - didn't pull any trees up at Blose but maybe Smith can play a tune.

El Ghazi - 8m  - not an improvement as there last season 

Wesley 22m - Belgian League no where near as good as the Prem.  Massive, massive gamble.  

Others linked;

Butland - 25m  lol please do

Phillips -  14m bid  - decent player nothing special.  Bid rejected by Leeds. 

Their defence is shite and they will have to pay 20m for Mings (made a big mistake in not doing a temp to perm. 

Also linked with Dunk but doubtful.  Another 20m if Brighton sell. 

So looks like it's heading towards 100m plus without really improving the overall quality of their team that finished the season. 

Has Fulham written all over it.   Big Grin

As much as I'd like this to be true, you also insisted we'd go up this season and that didn't happen either, so don't counter-jinx Villa.

There are quite a few weak teams in the PL this season, it won't be hard to get 17th.
Reply
#38
(06-14-2019, 11:43 PM)Begley Wrote:
(06-14-2019, 10:34 PM)The liquidator Wrote:
(06-14-2019, 08:31 PM)Begley Wrote:
(06-14-2019, 08:14 PM)Old Stroller Wrote:
(06-14-2019, 08:11 PM)tiptontown Wrote: Just thinking the same thing. It seems to have got under his skin a bit.


Oh, he’s openly Villa. Check back to his posts during the play offs.


Yes do check them out. All polite and reasoned and wishing the Baggies luck next season and the amount abuse I got was amazing. Is there a problem with football fans discussing football and debating issues? Personally I think it is a good thing for different fans to post on different club's blogs. I would be really interested to see information about Villa and FFP. If one was to believe some of the stuff in the media then Villa look to have failed FFP but if I look for any evidence to back it up there is none and any of the people who claim Villa cheated can't provide any. Can you provide any?

Fuck off you villa cunt
you can always rely on the idiot support to raise his head on a blog. Well done, did you come up with that comment all or your own or did u manage to get some help with it?

(06-14-2019, 10:42 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(06-14-2019, 10:11 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(06-14-2019, 06:23 PM)Begley Wrote:
(06-14-2019, 06:14 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Spent £50m more than anyone is allowed to, funding big last minute deals for Abraham and el-Ghazi, and handed Grealish who effectively promoted them a new deal when they’d been told to reduce their wage bill.

Anything other than conjecture? All clubs have to submit their accounts to EFL for review. If the media is to believed it does appear that Villa has over spent but I haven't seen any evidence to say they have. They haven't done a Derby and sold their ground to themselves and leased it back and the club is saying they are compliant. Apparently Purslow said the other day that the EFL also confirmed they were compliant but EFL has not confirmed. Abraham was a loan, El Ghazi was a loan Grealish was a pay rise, the total for these 3 player would be 7m, maybe 8m.
I wouldn’t say it was conjecture. Swiss ramble delved into their finances and concluded they had a £40m gap to fill to comply with FFFP regs. As a result they were one of 3 clubs to have to submit their accounts in advance for checking. 

Abraham was reported to be paid £75k/wk and Villa were paying the full wages...

As you’ve said, the EFL have yet to confirm any compliance... but anyone with any sense can clearly see they have overspent, it’s just whether or not they have found a loophole.

If they haven’t done a sale and leaseback of their ground then they haven’t found a loophole.

I’m as certain as it’s possible to be that Villa have massively failed FFP.  I fear the EFL have allowed them to get away with it and that all will be revealed next March when they file their audited accounts. Far too late of course, but it will trigger a huge legal case led by Gibson against the EFL for having failed to apply their own regulations.

(06-14-2019, 09:31 PM)Begley Wrote:
(06-14-2019, 09:09 PM)hudds Wrote:
(06-14-2019, 09:04 PM)Begley Wrote: LOL, wait and see rather than act now. 

If any evidence of wrong doing is discovered then the EFL has procedures to follow through with this, they have also recently agreed with the Premier League to apply sanctions to newly promoted teams. However, as there is no evidence and the Villa CEO has stated that the EFL has informed him that AVFC is compliant I guess you will be waiting a long time.

I think things are happening now.  So yes, I'm happy to wait and see.  I think it may be whether/how the sanctions are applied cross-league.

The method for ross league sanctions have been agreed, it wouldn't be that. The big problem with P&S is that if a club breaks the rules and manages to get promoted there really is fcuk all that can be done about it. They won't lose their place in the PL as the PL need 20 teams and it would be very bad PR for the PL. Also, lets say Villa get done for non compliance, there are loads of clubs in the EFL that can claim they missed out as a result. Obviously Baggies, Derby would have a case and Boro too. I can't see Villa getting fined 200m, maybe 20m and that is a fine that a newly promoted team can absorb. The full system is wrong

The issue is that the EFL specifically changed their own regulations 3 years ago so that clubs in breach would be sanctioned before the end of the 3rd season of the 3-year cycle, rather than realising non-compliance only 9 months later when they publish their accounts but have already been promoted.  From February/March onwards, clubs on the watchlist are supposed to be submitting monthly management accounts and monthly updated forecasts for the rest of the season to enable the EFL to confirm non-compliance. The regulations specifically state that the EFL can deny promotion, deny a playoff place, issue fines or transfer embargoes, and any EFL sanctions will be applied by the PL (and vice versa).  I fear that the EFL somehow gave assurance to Villa’s new owners that they would not be sanctioned as part of their takeover deal.

There is not a cat in hell’s chance that Villa have met the “maximum permitted loss of £39m in 3 years” limit, given their losses in 2016/7 and 2017/8, and their spending/lack of big transfer sales in 2018/9 (the third season in the 3-year cycle). Unless they’ve sold Villa Park for a value which probably can’t be considered “arms length”.

I don't know what Villa did in the last season but they haven't sold the ground. It is a protected building and cannot be sold without approval which is in the public domain. In Bruce's term as manager there was a net profit on player sales albeit he did spend a fortune on wages. To be compliant in the recent season Villa could only make a loss of about 8m to be within the 39m limit. The HS2 compensation money will be contributing to the P&S in Villa's favour but there is a limit as to how much that can be. Villa's last 10 home games are so were all in excess 40k attendances which is about 1.2m in revenue per game, plus there were some televised games. I can't see that the EFL would give Villa a special deal at the time Xia sold, that would be cause all sorts of shit with other clubs. I am sure the fact that Purslow was on the committee that created the original FFP rules can only help Villa in their understanding of how to manage them

(06-14-2019, 11:21 PM)TETLEY74 Wrote:
(06-14-2019, 10:42 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(06-14-2019, 10:11 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(06-14-2019, 06:23 PM)Begley Wrote: Anything other than conjecture? All clubs have to submit their accounts to EFL for review. If the media is to believed it does appear that Villa has over spent but I haven't seen any evidence to say they have. They haven't done a Derby and sold their ground to themselves and leased it back and the club is saying they are compliant. Apparently Purslow said the other day that the EFL also confirmed they were compliant but EFL has not confirmed. Abraham was a loan, El Ghazi was a loan Grealish was a pay rise, the total for these 3 player would be 7m, maybe 8m.
I wouldn’t say it was conjecture. Swiss ramble delved into their finances and concluded they had a £40m gap to fill to comply with FFFP regs. As a result they were one of 3 clubs to have to submit their accounts in advance for checking. 

Abraham was reported to be paid £75k/wk and Villa were paying the full wages...

As you’ve said, the EFL have yet to confirm any compliance... but anyone with any sense can clearly see they have overspent, it’s just whether or not they have found a loophole.

If they haven’t done a sale and leaseback of their ground then they haven’t found a loophole.

I’m as certain as it’s possible to be that Villa have massively failed FFP.  I fear the EFL have allowed them to get away with it and that all will be revealed next March when they file their audited accounts. Far too late of course, but it will trigger a huge legal case led by Gibson against the EFL for having failed to apply their own regulations.

(06-14-2019, 09:31 PM)Begley Wrote:
(06-14-2019, 09:09 PM)hudds Wrote: I think things are happening now.  So yes, I'm happy to wait and see.  I think it may be whether/how the sanctions are applied cross-league.

The method for ross league sanctions have been agreed, it wouldn't be that. The big problem with P&S is that if a club breaks the rules and manages to get promoted there really is fcuk all that can be done about it. They won't lose their place in the PL as the PL need 20 teams and it would be very bad PR for the PL. Also, lets say Villa get done for non compliance, there are loads of clubs in the EFL that can claim they missed out as a result. Obviously Baggies, Derby would have a case and Boro too. I can't see Villa getting fined 200m, maybe 20m and that is a fine that a newly promoted team can absorb. The full system is wrong

The issue is that the EFL specifically changed their own regulations 3 years ago so that clubs in breach would be sanctioned before the end of the 3rd season of the 3-year cycle, rather than realising non-compliance only 9 months later when they publish their accounts but have already been promoted.  From February/March onwards, clubs on the watchlist are supposed to be submitting monthly management accounts and monthly updated forecasts for the rest of the season to enable the EFL to confirm non-compliance. The regulations specifically state that the EFL can deny promotion, deny a playoff place, issue fines or transfer embargoes, and any EFL sanctions will be applied by the PL (and vice versa).  I fear that the EFL somehow gave assurance to Villa’s new owners that they would not be sanctioned as part of their takeover deal.

There is not a cat in hell’s chance that Villa have met the “maximum permitted loss of £39m in 3 years” limit, given their losses in 2016/7 and 2017/8, and their spending/lack of big transfer sales in 2018/9 (the third season in the 3-year cycle). Unless they’ve sold Villa Park for a value which probably can’t be considered “arms length”.

I know fugg all about the financial & legal niceties of FFP but it seems to me that(and yet to be confirmed) Villa cheated the system and the EFL stood by and allowed it as its a big club and if they sanction them they would have then set a precedent that the EFL  themselves would be unable to keep in future plus Villas owners have lots of money and clout for legal battles, better the EFL come down on the likes of blues etc who ain't got the ability to make the EFL'S life awkward in court, call me an old cynic but money talks and Vile have loads, plus the EFL are fuggin toothless wankers. Let's hope Gibson and a few others rentlessly push this and make the EFL'S life a misery.

I don't believe this 'big club' conspiracy theory. Blues failed P&S and were given a slap on the wrist and put under an embargo as a punishment. While they were under embargo they then broke the rules and effectively gave two fingers to the EFL. They or any other team that does that deserves a punishment.

My rant was aimed more at the EFL than either the Villa or yourself, they sat on their hands and refused or couldn't enforce their own bloody rules it seems to me and it has tto be said Derby seem as guilty as anyone with their ground sell/lease back scam. Fwiw if Villa have broken the rules and cheated fair play to them if the authorities are reluctant to do anything they gambled and won, the EFL/PREM/FA have to enforce the rules ridgedly and fairly or scrap the whole idea of FFP and let clubs spend what they like I'm sure once the first big name club goes into liquidation it may stop.
Reply
#39
Big fines and big pints deductions, with the fine being distributed to the league teams that have been cheated.
With no consistency, its become a farce. QPR had a £42 million pound fine, Blues a points deduction, Derby Nothing, Seals Nothing
Sheff Wed transfer embargo, Dingles nothing. Massaging figures selling the grounds to themselves is how silly it has become.
The EFL management team are a toothless bunch and the clubs know it. Gibson has the right idea tbf. - although it looks a little like sour grapes. One thing is for sure over spending is never a problem we're going to have Big Grin
Reply
#40
(06-15-2019, 10:20 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Big fines and big pints deductions, with the fine being distributed to the league teams that have been cheated.
With no consistency, its become a farce. QPR had a £42 million pound fine,  Blues a points deduction, Derby Nothing, Seals Nothing
Sheff Wed transfer embargo, Dingles nothing. Massaging figures selling the grounds to themselves is how silly it has become.
The EFL management team are a toothless bunch and the clubs know it. Gibson has the right idea tbf. - although it looks a little like sour grapes. One thing is for sure over spending is never a problem we're going to have Big Grin

Just getting anything to spend will be our problem Big Grin
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: