Revees' Budget
#11
Farage will give all the small cocked fans of his a couple of quid off of penis pumps undoubtedly when it's his go.
Reply
#12
Whatever the virtues of lifting the cap, it is a very difficult sell. Caitlin Moran (in her words, one of 6 children born to a seemingly feckless father), wrote a great article about this saying why should the children suffer? It all made sense but try telling that to those working families with one or two kids because they can't afford more. I actually doubt the policy costs much in reality as the money is spent around locally, but it won't change opinion that Labour take your money and give it to the workshy. I'll keep my powder dry arguing the things where I can successfully make my point.
Reply
#13
I suspect there are quite a few on this forum who had grandparents/great grandparents who were one of at least 6 children. They would have worked and not claimed off the state. Ms Moran has an interesting background, according to wikipedia
Reply
#14
(11-28-2025, 01:04 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: Does anyone actually know any dole dossers with 10 kids? I've long felt it was a Daily Mail fantasy that hasn't borne much relevance to the real world since the 80s.

Yes. But I do work in social housing. 

The benefit cap definitely reduced the number of kids being born in workless households. 

I don't think it was the correct call. The extra resource should have been put towards getting older Gen Z and child bearing age millenials, who work and have deferred having a family due to the cost of living and need to work 2 full time jobs, to encourage them to have kids. 

Creating an environment where people can breed unsustainable sized families is never a good thing.

The budget was a bit of a damp squib. It flirted with tax and welfare spend, but flirted with wealth tax. But did neither very well.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#15
(11-28-2025, 09:05 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(11-28-2025, 07:21 AM)Mouse Wrote:
(11-28-2025, 01:04 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: Does anyone actually know any dole dossers with 10 kids? I've long felt it was a Daily Mail fantasy that hasn't borne much relevance to the real world since the 80s.

I wouldn't say I know them but there are a couple of moms of kids in my daughters class, one has five kids and the other has 7 or 8. Neither of the moms work and I've never seen the dads at the school either.

They certainly know the system and how to squeeze every last bit out of it.

They may have genuine reasons not to work but neither of them appear to have any incentive either.

Their kids don't appear to want for anything either, always coming to school with the latest scooter or gadget, get their school meals, trips and uniforms paid for.

As a side, we've had to stop at one child as we simply cannot afford to have anymore and have taken the "sensible" option, but who's the loser here?

I may be wrong but every word of your post is tinged with bitterness, moreso given your last sentence.

Yes and you'd be right and probably not for the reasons you're thinking.

I've paid into the system every month without fail since I started work at 17 with the "implied" agreement that if I fall or one of my family fall the system would catch us and help us.

Guess what? It didn't. My daughter is let down at every turn (wether that be medically or educationally) and yet I see with my own eyes others who have figured the system out and are comfortable to accept everything that is given to them without even attempting to pay back into the system.

I have no problem paying extra tax if it means genuine people get help, what I disagree with is people deliberately screwing the system whilst others who genuinely need it can't get a look in.
Reply
#16
(11-28-2025, 07:21 AM)Mouse Wrote:
(11-28-2025, 01:04 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: Does anyone actually know any dole dossers with 10 kids? I've long felt it was a Daily Mail fantasy that hasn't borne much relevance to the real world since the 80s.

I wouldn't say I know them but there are a couple of moms of kids in my daughters class, one has five kids and the other has 7 or 8. Neither of the moms work and I've never seen the dads at the school either.

They certainly know the system and how to squeeze every last bit out of it.

They may have genuine reasons not to work but neither of them appear to have any incentive either.

Their kids don't appear to want for anything either, always coming to school with the latest scooter or gadget, get their school meals, trips and uniforms paid for.

As a side, we've had to stop at one child as we simply cannot afford to have anymore and have taken the "sensible" option, but who's the loser here?

Is there any chance that you haven't seen the Dad's at school because they are at work?

(11-28-2025, 09:52 AM)Mouse Wrote:
(11-28-2025, 09:05 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(11-28-2025, 07:21 AM)Mouse Wrote:
(11-28-2025, 01:04 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: Does anyone actually know any dole dossers with 10 kids? I've long felt it was a Daily Mail fantasy that hasn't borne much relevance to the real world since the 80s.

I wouldn't say I know them but there are a couple of moms of kids in my daughters class, one has five kids and the other has 7 or 8. Neither of the moms work and I've never seen the dads at the school either.

They certainly know the system and how to squeeze every last bit out of it.

They may have genuine reasons not to work but neither of them appear to have any incentive either.

Their kids don't appear to want for anything either, always coming to school with the latest scooter or gadget, get their school meals, trips and uniforms paid for.

As a side, we've had to stop at one child as we simply cannot afford to have anymore and have taken the "sensible" option, but who's the loser here?

I may be wrong but every word of your post is tinged with bitterness, moreso given your last sentence.

Yes and you'd be right and probably not for the reasons you're thinking.

I've paid into the system every month without fail since I started work at 17 with the "implied" agreement that if I fall or one of my family fall the system would catch us and help us.

Guess what? It didn't. My daughter is let down at every turn (wether that be medically or educationally) and yet I see with my own eyes others who have figured the system out and are comfortable to accept everything that is given to them without even attempting to pay back into the system.

I have no problem paying extra tax if it means genuine people get help, what I disagree with is people deliberately screwing the system whilst others who genuinely need it can't get a look in.

Agree with that but there is an assumption in what you are saying that they are screwing the system and from what you've posted you may not have all of the facts. I'm not saying you're wrong but sometimes there are sometimes parts of the story that we don't know.

Labour have started by re-introducing face to face assessments which will take time due to numbers but it is a step in the right direction. If they are genuine then the f2f should be ok for them. It's a long road and we have to be patient but comments like the OP are the reason why we are heading tio a world where it will become worse.
Reply
#17
There's little debate to be had on this subject when the media constantly bombard us with stories of bloated scammers like these.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#18
(11-28-2025, 12:42 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: There's little debate to be had on this subject when the media constantly bombard us with stories of bloated scammers like these.

Most sensible large tech companies in the UK run their money/transactions through Republic of Ireland and or countries like Netherlands or Luxembourg, so this article is someone moaning about how companies are legally operating and the subsidaries of those, rather than actual tax dodging.
Reply
#19
(11-28-2025, 06:18 PM)SausEggBaton Wrote:
(11-28-2025, 12:42 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: There's little debate to be had on this subject when the media constantly bombard us with stories of bloated scammers like these.

Most sensible large tech companies in the UK run their money/transactions through Republic of Ireland and or countries like Netherlands or Luxembourg, so this article is someone moaning about how companies are legally operating and the subsidaries of those, rather than actual tax dodging.

As opposed to people moaning about poor people legally claiming government support. Punch up not down bro.  

The gig is rigged yet people continue to punch down.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#20
(11-28-2025, 06:49 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:
(11-28-2025, 06:18 PM)SausEggBaton Wrote:
(11-28-2025, 12:42 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: There's little debate to be had on this subject when the media constantly bombard us with stories of bloated scammers like these.

Most sensible large tech companies in the UK run their money/transactions through Republic of Ireland and or countries like Netherlands or Luxembourg, so this article is someone moaning about how companies are legally operating and the subsidaries of those, rather than actual tax dodging.

As opposed to people moaning about poor people legally claiming government support. Punch up not down bro.  

The gig is rigged yet people continue to punch down.

Sadly Tory and Reform types love to punch down and never up. Anyway the people I most feel sorry for are those living in £2m mansions… the downtrodden’strivers’!
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: