The Mythical Plan B
#81
(11-26-2025, 01:57 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-26-2025, 01:17 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: I hope most of you are wrong, as that'll mean a successful Albion, but I wouldn't be so petty as to drag old posts up! You're entitled to an opinion.

I get the criticisms, I really do, what I struggle to get my head around, and this is probably on me, is the fact a lot of fans aren't showing any patience.

I will let you into a secret, fans talk a great game about patience, building slowly over several transfer windows and giving players and coaches time… this goes out the window as soon as the novelty wears off and a manager loses a few games or a player is out of form. In short it’s a load of old oss shit! It always was and always will be.

I disagree Derek… you use lack of patience to berate any fan that disagrees with you… there was no patience for Val or Mowbray. Fans generally will be patient if they feel a club is delivering, if they see a reason to be optimistic. I believe fans will buy into a project when there are positive reasons to believe. If the football is good, if we see young players coming in, if we see results, there will be patience. When the football is crap, when the same players are persisted with, when results are bad and worsening, when performances are bad and worsening, people lose patience.

It’s a two way street, fans will be supportive when there’s something to support. Right now, what should we be supporting? I have better things to do with my free time than emotionally invest in blind faith that a manager who shows no signs of improvement in the last 4 months will suddenly start to tonight…

(11-26-2025, 01:57 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-26-2025, 01:17 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: I hope most of you are wrong, as that'll mean a successful Albion, but I wouldn't be so petty as to drag old posts up! You're entitled to an opinion.

I get the criticisms, I really do, what I struggle to get my head around, and this is probably on me, is the fact a lot of fans aren't showing any patience.

I will let you into a secret, fans talk a great game about patience, building slowly over several transfer windows and giving players and coaches time… this goes out the window as soon as the novelty wears off and a manager loses a few games or a player is out of form. In short it’s a load of old oss shit! It always was and always will be.

I disagree Derek… you use lack of patience to berate any fan that disagrees with you… there was no patience for Val or Mowbray. Fans generally will be patient if they feel a club is delivering, if they see a reason to be optimistic. I believe fans will buy into a project when there are positive reasons to believe. If the football is good, if we see young players coming in, if we see results, there will be patience. When the football is crap, when the same players are persisted with, when results are bad and worsening, when performances are bad and worsening, people lose patience.

It’s a two way street, fans will be supportive when there’s something to support. Right now, what should we be supporting? I have better things to do with my free time than emotionally invest in blind faith that a manager who shows no signs of improvement in the last 4 months will suddenly start to tonight…
Reply
#82
I do agree with Derek that fans don't have patience for a project.

You say fans will if all those criteria are met, I very, very much doubt it, good football is subjective, but giving youngsters a go, Val tried to and planned to more, no patience there.

CC wasn't losing, but there were a loud minority wanting him out, fans want results, that is literally all that matters, all else is just fluff that leads into results. Win more than lose or draw nothing matters, fans will back and stay behind the manager. Lose a few in a row, style of play, youth, talking about projects, will mean absolutely nothing.
Reply
#83
(11-26-2025, 03:45 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I do agree with Derek that fans don't have patience for a project.

You say fans will if all those criteria are met, I very, very much doubt it, good football is subjective, but giving youngsters a go, Val tried to and planned to more, no patience there.

CC wasn't losing, but there were a loud minority wanting him out,  fans want results, that is literally all that matters, all else is just fluff that leads into results. Win more than lose or draw nothing matters, fans will back and stay behind the manager. Lose a few in a row, style of play, youth, talking about projects, will mean absolutely nothing.

But Val was winning games and fans wanted him out, Megson’s sides were booed off after 1-0 wins in our promotion season… for the most part, we were mid table in the PL under Pulis and people wanted him out.

With the exception of Bilic for 6 months, we have been crap to watch and lacked excitement on the pitch since Clark… I think any manager that plays football that gets fans off their asses will get support.
Reply
#84
Until they lose too many games, and exciting football as fans describe is quite rare now thanks to the current trend for players to keep possession at all costs.
Reply
#85
And again subjective. I loved watching us under CC, it was an excellent display of shape, organisation, coaching, planned game management, small tweaks to react to the opposition to make us the hardest team to play against. Loved every second of it.
Reply
#86
(11-26-2025, 03:52 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(11-26-2025, 03:45 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I do agree with Derek that fans don't have patience for a project.

You say fans will if all those criteria are met, I very, very much doubt it, good football is subjective, but giving youngsters a go, Val tried to and planned to more, no patience there.

CC wasn't losing, but there were a loud minority wanting him out,  fans want results, that is literally all that matters, all else is just fluff that leads into results. Win more than lose or draw nothing matters, fans will back and stay behind the manager. Lose a few in a row, style of play, youth, talking about projects, will mean absolutely nothing.

But Val was winning games and fans wanted him out, Megson’s sides were booed off after 1-0 wins in our promotion season… for the most part, we were mid table in the PL under Pulis and people wanted him out.

With the exception of Bilic for 6 months, we have been crap to watch and lacked excitement on the pitch since Clark… I think any manager that plays football that gets fans off their asses will get support.

You do realise that Val only actually WON 12 games (out of 31, 10 losses)with us don't you? He actually managed only about 3% better win ratio than Mason has so far, but in 14 more games, so Mason's will probably drop like a stone! So hardly winning games and we wanted him out.

I really do not remember anyone booing Megson's team in that season, not once., certainly not at home.
Reply
#87
(11-26-2025, 03:56 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: And again subjective. I loved watching us under CC, it was an excellent display of shape, organisation, coaching, planned game management, small tweaks to react to the opposition to make us the hardest team to play against. Loved every second of it.

But I don’t recall many people really seriously calling for CC’s head. I think there was frustration about the running of the club that may have spilled over, often because CC was the only public face of the ownership, but generally he maintained more support than pretty much any manager we had.

Bruce got a lot of slack post Val despite the results being worse because of the belief his side was having a right go…

(11-26-2025, 04:01 PM)MrBater Wrote:
(11-26-2025, 03:52 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(11-26-2025, 03:45 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I do agree with Derek that fans don't have patience for a project.

You say fans will if all those criteria are met, I very, very much doubt it, good football is subjective, but giving youngsters a go, Val tried to and planned to more, no patience there.

CC wasn't losing, but there were a loud minority wanting him out,  fans want results, that is literally all that matters, all else is just fluff that leads into results. Win more than lose or draw nothing matters, fans will back and stay behind the manager. Lose a few in a row, style of play, youth, talking about projects, will mean absolutely nothing.

But Val was winning games and fans wanted him out, Megson’s sides were booed off after 1-0 wins in our promotion season… for the most part, we were mid table in the PL under Pulis and people wanted him out.

With the exception of Bilic for 6 months, we have been crap to watch and lacked excitement on the pitch since Clark… I think any manager that plays football that gets fans off their asses will get support.

You do realise that Val only actually WON 12 games (out of 31, 10 losses)with us don't you? He actually managed only about 3% better win ratio than Mason has so far, but in 15 more games, so Mason's will probably drop like a stone! So hardly winning games and we wanted him out.

I really do not remember anyone booing Megson's team in that season, not once., certainly not at home.

Norwich, 1-0 home win, Koumas goal… roundly booed.
Reply
#88
(11-26-2025, 04:01 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(11-26-2025, 03:56 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: And again subjective. I loved watching us under CC, it was an excellent display of shape, organisation, coaching, planned game management, small tweaks to react to the opposition to make us the hardest team to play against. Loved every second of it.

But I don’t recall many people really seriously calling for CC’s head. I think there was frustration about the running of the club that may have spilled over, often because CC was the only public face of the ownership, but generally he maintained more support than pretty much any manager we had.

Bruce got a lot of slack post Val despite the results being worse because of the belief his side was having a right go…

(11-26-2025, 04:01 PM)MrBater Wrote:
(11-26-2025, 03:52 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(11-26-2025, 03:45 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I do agree with Derek that fans don't have patience for a project.

You say fans will if all those criteria are met, I very, very much doubt it, good football is subjective, but giving youngsters a go, Val tried to and planned to more, no patience there.

CC wasn't losing, but there were a loud minority wanting him out,  fans want results, that is literally all that matters, all else is just fluff that leads into results. Win more than lose or draw nothing matters, fans will back and stay behind the manager. Lose a few in a row, style of play, youth, talking about projects, will mean absolutely nothing.

But Val was winning games and fans wanted him out, Megson’s sides were booed off after 1-0 wins in our promotion season… for the most part, we were mid table in the PL under Pulis and people wanted him out.

With the exception of Bilic for 6 months, we have been crap to watch and lacked excitement on the pitch since Clark… I think any manager that plays football that gets fans off their asses will get support.

You do realise that Val only actually WON 12 games (out of 31, 10 losses)with us don't you? He actually managed only about 3% better win ratio than Mason has so far, but in 15 more games, so Mason's will probably drop like a stone! So hardly winning games and we wanted him out.

I really do not remember anyone booing Megson's team in that season, not once., certainly not at home.

Norwich, 1-0 home win, Koumas goal… roundly booed.

Yep, one of those times I was embarrassed as a fan by our fanbase.
Reply
#89
(11-26-2025, 04:01 PM)MrBater Wrote: You do realise that Val only actually WON 12 games (out of 31, 10 losses)with us don't you? He actually managed only about 3% better win ratio than Mason has so far, but in 14 more games, so Mason's will probably drop like a stone! So hardly winning games and we wanted him out.

I really do not remember anyone booing Megson's team in that season, not once., certainly not at home.

In fairness to Val, we do have to remember he had Jordan Hugill as his only striker - had Hugill been able to hit a cow's arse with a banjo, we'd have won more games.

and 2 of those defeats were cup games - we were on 45 points from 29 games when he was sacked...1.55 vs 1.3 currently - that's 71 vs 59 over a season so...
Reply
#90
(11-26-2025, 04:28 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(11-26-2025, 04:01 PM)MrBater Wrote: You do realise that Val only actually WON 12 games (out of 31, 10 losses)with us don't you? He actually managed only about 3% better win ratio than Mason has so far, but in 14 more games, so Mason's will probably drop like a stone! So hardly winning games and we wanted him out.

I really do not remember anyone booing Megson's team in that season, not once., certainly not at home.

In fairness to Val, we do have to remember he had Jordan Hugill as his only striker - had Hugill been able to hit a cow's arse with a banjo, we'd have won more games.

and 2 of those defeats were cup games - we were on 45 points from 29 games when he was sacked...1.55 vs 1.3 currently - that's 71 vs 59 over a season so...

Shove that up ya backpipe and smoke it MrBater!
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)