The Mythical Plan B
#11
(11-24-2025, 10:46 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: I took my nephew to see him live so he's definitely real

(11-24-2025, 10:36 AM)CIM Wrote:
(11-24-2025, 10:34 AM)richbaggie Wrote: A really irritation of mine is how many football fans, not just Albion fans, criticise managers for not having a Plan B. There's no such thing in reality. It's not F1 where teams have specific plans for different scenarios.

Coaches will have their way of playing and make adjustments to formations pre game or mid game. They really won't have a Plan B.

I think a more appropriate phrase would be in game management. This is we appear to currently struggle
This is the truth of it. It was shockingly bad on Saturday. As a club and the way we are headed in the table even if you think he needs time to learn, we haven’t got that time to afford him.
It was total Sunday league management on Saturday which is why I now have major concerns over mason and his team
Reply
#12
(11-24-2025, 11:21 AM)mattaky Wrote: I see many (mostly on Social Media) people saying he should be sacked on the spot for taking MJ off at HT. Truth be told, any tactical changes he was trying to make was completely blown out the water with the sending off.

I dont think we have seen anything from junior, other than the lesta goal to suggest he is ready for the championship. Considering him as a tactual upgrade to MJ after a decent 45 is predictably making fans angry.

The fact that he was considering him as a starter is mind boggling.
Reply
#13
(11-24-2025, 11:03 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(11-24-2025, 10:57 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(11-24-2025, 10:48 AM)Sliced Wrote: Yeah Plan B is just a way of making tactical adjustments when things aren't working.

That definitely exists, I'm sure it's not a case of "Ok right lads, Plan B now", but football is an interactive game. There are coaches capable of knowing when things aren't working and making changes accordingly.

+1

Exactly - Plan B is just an ability to adjust. 

Carlos was a master at making small tweaks in game to neutralise the effectiveness of our opponents. Mason appears to be a master at making ill conceived tweaks that blow points. I’d actually like to see more Plan A from him Big Grin

Agree about Carlos being the master of subtle changes although I distinctly remember the "no plan B" barb often being thrown at him.

Agree and I think it is a lazy claim made when we aren’t winning games, but it is also often fair to point out managers that are seemingly unable to alter a game, or at least ask questions of an opponent.

CC got a fair amount of slack due to his alarming lack of options… if CC had been given Bany, Price, Lankshear, Armstrong and possibly the return of Dike we’d have gone up last year I believe.
Reply
#14
Mason's Plan B notes - if a player is doing well and having influence in a positive way, sub them off as quick as possible.
Reply
#15
We have the 3rd best 1st half GD record (+5 scored 10 conceded 5) but the 3rd worse 2nd half (-8 scored 6, conceded 14).
Suggests to me we can start games ok and the initial set up is ok.  But strugle to adapt as the game progresses. Watford away was a classic example. The Watford manager tweaked it at HT. Mason failed to react.
Reply
#16
(11-24-2025, 11:06 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: It has become a modern trend for football fans and pundits to overthink the game. I suspect it comes from too many playing computer games and listening to, too many football podcasts...I'm guilty of the latter.

Some of the post match commentary was completely outcome driven presented with the benefit of 20/20 hindsight.

What changed that game happened on the pitch.
The first goal back was the initial changer, a really sloppy bit of defensive play that changed the mood and momentum of the game. Then came the sending off, which as a massive impact on the game.

Anything that Mason did or did not do had far less impact than these on pitch events. 

So for example the decision to swap Illing for Johnston had minimal impact on the game, it was rendered irrelevant by the sending off.

And yes I am an old man shaking his fist at a cloud.

You're using hindsight here yourself though.

At half time, taking MJ off for SIJ, for tactical reasons, makes absolutely no sense whatsoever. None. It's a really worrying decision.

Sure, the sending off changed the game more, but at the time, now we know there was no injury, it was a mind boggling sub.
Reply
#17
(11-24-2025, 03:01 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(11-24-2025, 11:06 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: It has become a modern trend for football fans and pundits to overthink the game. I suspect it comes from too many playing computer games and listening to, too many football podcasts...I'm guilty of the latter.

Some of the post match commentary was completely outcome driven presented with the benefit of 20/20 hindsight.

What changed that game happened on the pitch.
The first goal back was the initial changer, a really sloppy bit of defensive play that changed the mood and momentum of the game. Then came the sending off, which as a massive impact on the game.

Anything that Mason did or did not do had far less impact than these on pitch events. 

So for example the decision to swap Illing for Johnston had minimal impact on the game, it was rendered irrelevant by the sending off.

And yes I am an old man shaking his fist at a cloud.

You're using hindsight here yourself though.

At half time, taking MJ off for SIJ, for tactical reasons, makes absolutely no sense whatsoever. None. It's a really worrying decision.

Sure, the sending off changed the game more, but at the time, now we know there was no injury, it was a mind boggling sub.
Especially considering he never usually makes subs before 60 minutes. Thus meaning he thought that MJ was that bad it couldn’t wait. 
There is no way of looking at it that makes sense.
Reply
#18
I had a chat with my next door neighbour this morning who is a Cov season ticket holder.

He said they couldn't believe their luck when Molumby was not hooked as once he was booked even they knew it was a matter of time before he got booked again. But they though they would have to wind him up a bit first.  Instead he handed it to them on a plate.

He said their left back had his worse game of the season largely down to MJ  and he was stunned when MJ didn't appear for the second half. The  fans were pretty confident that they would win from that point on as we lost all shape and that was with their two best strikers on the bench. 

 They have now scored 43.  We've scored 16.   That says it all.
Reply
#19
(11-24-2025, 02:00 PM)CIM Wrote: We have the 3rd best 1st half GD record (+5 scored 10 conceded 5) but the 3rd worse 2nd half (-8 scored 6, conceded 14).
Suggests to me we can start games ok and the initial set up is ok.  But strugle to adapt as the game progresses. Watford away was a classic example. The Watford manager tweaked it at HT. Mason failed to react.

Nice statting...
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#20
And I think I disagree with the adage that football is a simple game that is over complicated - I think fans (and definitely myself amongst others here) overcomplicate with stats to overcompensate for our own experience - but football is a game of marginal gains. Given how important one single goal is, every detail can be controlled and refined, that is where the game rightfully requires complication. The most successful clubs per pound spent are those that complicate the game with set piece coaches, throw in specialists, and use metric upon metric to source players, refine players and improve their outputs.

The speed of the game is immense, and things like body shape, where to position to at the side of opponents, where to set the press, when to trigger and not trigger, which foot to play opponents onto, all of these data points are complications but all breed a competitive advantage on the pitch. Prepping for and altering this in game was what CC did brilliantly, he was light years ahead of so many managers in how he saw, calculated and implemented play, similar to how Roy instilled a tactical discipline that RDM couldn’t dream of.

Mason does not demonstrate an ability to see or do any of this, he is very capable of creating a game plan and implementing it, as shown by how well we approach and generally start games, but he cannot see what’s going on on the pitch and he cannot react to it, which is what sorts a decent training ground coach from a manager.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: