Corberan with this squad. Question?
#21
We’d have 6-7 more points with CC - we wouldn’t be running away with things but I think we’d be comfortably sat in the playoffs eeking out enough points to stay in the mix.

We would defend better, we’d not have blown so many points in the last minutes, and we’d at least look fit and like we know what we were doing.

I do think he’d have probably taken us up last year based on how crap the playoff run in was.
Reply
#22
(11-22-2025, 05:14 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: CC has a lot of staunch supporters on this dump so question is:

Where would this squad be with him?

I’d say top 10 still looking at top 6, and I was not a super fan.

If you agree, then surely we need to be looking for another like him rather than giving “time” to this novice before it’s too late.

Or is it all on the squad and they are a lost cause regardless of who’s in charge?

Genuine discussion point not clickbait. I think, if defending Mason, it’s fair to ask what a better coach could achieve and CC is a fair comparison, not a Klopp or Mourhino.

I’m pretty sure Corberan wanted out and his agent touted him for our job. Now he’s managing in Spain’s top flight. It’s not a fair comparison imo. He’d be after a Prem job now in England
Reply
#23
We were better organised under CC, but we still slid relentlessly down the table after a strong start, until a couple of better results to tantalise us just before Corberan walked. Don't forget he had a fully functional Josh Maja starting every single league match last season. He was overly cautious and very slow to make changes, both in terms of starting line-ups and substitutions. Would we be better placed now? Maybe, but only because of his continuity with the squad. Do I think play-offs would be guaranteed with Carlos in charge? No, really not. I don't think he's as good as our rose-tinted recollections would have us believe.
Reply
#24
Many reasons why a long term project under CC would fare better than Mason, the fact that Nestor had other ideas is a huge worry.
Reply
#25
(11-22-2025, 11:02 PM)sickParrot Wrote: Many reasons why a long term project under CC would fare better than Mason, the fact that Nestor had other ideas is a huge worry.

I’m not sure CC is a long term project manager - he has the same intensity that has haunted Bielsa in that after 2-3 years everyone is exhausted and he needs a new project. I also think CC likes players he can trust and isn’t a manager interested in incremental progress, he wants to get the absolute maximum out of what he has in the short term, so if I wanted to change the style of a club, develop a style of play through the various levels and integrate youth players he wouldn’t be my first choice, but if I wanted to drain every ounce out of a squad and push for a quick promotion, he absolutely would be.

That being said, I’d still have CC over Mason for the former owing to the fact Mason is useless. Hell, I’d take CC over Ryan Mason in a being Ryan Mason contest as Ryan would probably be too afraid to enter.
Reply
#26
We would be 6th or 7th with CC. 

Another question would be where JM and Abella would have us. It sure as fugg wouldn’t be 17th
Reply
#27
(11-23-2025, 10:59 AM)MancBaggie Wrote: We would be 6th or 7th with CC. 

Another question would be where JM and Abella would have us. It sure as fugg wouldn’t be 17th

Not so sure about JM, but I think Abella would do a decent job.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)