Corberan with this squad. Question?
#11
Top 6, easily. It is a much weaker Championship, both on the pitch and managerially. We would be more disciplined, so fewer sendings off or late conceded goals.

I still don't think a sizeable chunk of our fanbase understood exactly how good Corberán was. They seemed to think we were just fawning over a foreign coach, as opposed to appreciating a genuine talent.
Reply
#12
The aim of the post is not for another argument about CC. It’s more about, if we think a better coach could do better, then we have to try and find a better coach. CC was just a fair comparison.
Reply
#13
I love and miss Carlos so much
Reply
#14
I wouldn’t say it’s just about not affording to sack him, it’s about what did people expect as much as it is about his own journey and development.

Dekka was right two or three weeks ago, when he said it’s many of the same calling for his head who at one time favoured getting a younger, hungrier guy in and giving him time. It’s a sweeping claim, but it is what we’re doing, but not fast enough for many. Perhaps it’s the right idea, but the wrong guy? A similar appointment, but with perhaps some lower-league success added on may have been better? The problem is that it’s a comparison that is always impossible to draw.

In the plus column, the first 45 today, digging out a result a fortnight ago (when the crowd really was turning), plus what was TBF a strong start to the season. Against… too many dropped points, piss poor changes and player regression. Poor discipline. Not knowing his best side too often. It is quite a list.

It all boils down to how patient people think we can afford to be, as much as true affordability. And that ignores that the more you hire-and-fire the less attractive a role it all begins to become.
Reply
#15
(11-22-2025, 05:56 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: I wouldn’t say it’s just about not affording to sack him, it’s about what did people expect as much as it is about his own journey and development.

Dekka was right two or three weeks ago, when he said it’s many of the same calling for his head who at one time favoured getting a younger, hungrier guy in and giving him time. It’s a sweeping claim, but it is what we’re doing, but not fast enough for many. Perhaps it’s the right idea, but the wrong guy? A similar appointment, but with perhaps some lower-league success added on may have been better? The problem is that it’s a comparison that is always impossible to draw.

In the plus column, the first 45 today, digging out a result a fortnight ago (when the crowd really was turning), plus what was TBF a strong start to the season. Against… too many dropped points, piss poor changes and player regression. Poor discipline. Not knowing his best side too often. It is quite a list.

It all boils down to how patient people think we can afford to be, as much as true affordability. And that ignores that the more you hire-and-fire the less attractive a role it all begins to become.
Worked for Forest. Eventually!!
Reply
#16
(11-22-2025, 06:10 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(11-22-2025, 05:56 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: I wouldn’t say it’s just about not affording to sack him, it’s about what did people expect as much as it is about his own journey and development.

Dekka was right two or three weeks ago, when he said it’s many of the same calling for his head who at one time favoured getting a younger, hungrier guy in and giving him time. It’s a sweeping claim, but it is what we’re doing, but not fast enough for many. Perhaps it’s the right idea, but the wrong guy? A similar appointment, but with perhaps some lower-league success added on may have been better? The problem is that it’s a comparison that is always impossible to draw.

In the plus column, the first 45 today, digging out a result a fortnight ago (when the crowd really was turning), plus what was TBF a strong start to the season. Against… too many dropped points, piss poor changes and player regression. Poor discipline. Not knowing his best side too often. It is quite a list.

It all boils down to how patient people think we can afford to be, as much as true affordability. And that ignores that the more you hire-and-fire the less attractive a role it all begins to become.
Worked for Forest. Eventually!!

Watford still get managers, so I'm not bothered about the hiring and firing argument hindering employment. Likewise, Sheffield Wednesday were owned by someone unfit to run a football club and they still employed decent managers. So I think the "We can't sack him because we'll look trigger happy" argument can be put in the bin.
Reply
#17
He'd probably have drawn most of the losses, leaving us probably in the top ten.
Reply
#18
(11-22-2025, 07:05 PM)Squid Wrote:
(11-22-2025, 06:10 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(11-22-2025, 05:56 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: I wouldn’t say it’s just about not affording to sack him, it’s about what did people expect as much as it is about his own journey and development.

Dekka was right two or three weeks ago, when he said it’s many of the same calling for his head who at one time favoured getting a younger, hungrier guy in and giving him time. It’s a sweeping claim, but it is what we’re doing, but not fast enough for many. Perhaps it’s the right idea, but the wrong guy? A similar appointment, but with perhaps some lower-league success added on may have been better? The problem is that it’s a comparison that is always impossible to draw.

In the plus column, the first 45 today, digging out a result a fortnight ago (when the crowd really was turning), plus what was TBF a strong start to the season. Against… too many dropped points, piss poor changes and player regression. Poor discipline. Not knowing his best side too often. It is quite a list.

It all boils down to how patient people think we can afford to be, as much as true affordability. And that ignores that the more you hire-and-fire the less attractive a role it all begins to become.
Worked for Forest. Eventually!!

Watford still get managers, so I'm not bothered about the hiring and firing argument hindering employment. Likewise, Sheffield Wednesday were owned by someone unfit to run a football club and they still employed decent managers. So I think the "We can't sack him because we'll look trigger happy" argument can be put in the bin.
Exactly. Same as shit managers still get work!
Mason will end up in punditry though. All frills, no knickers!
Reply
#19
In a game with no shortage of contenders, as peers are Watford and Wednesday necessarily good aspirational role models? One is about to run dry of parachute money a mere two points better off than us, and the other are on the brink of extinction. Being trigger happy won’t necessarily make it difficult to fill the role, but to fill it well is a different matter entirely. Notwithstanding that happy and successful managers generally stay put, it stands to reason that the two situations go hand-in-hand.

Anyway, we’re perhaps not at that point yet, and there are probably examples to support both arguments; but to continuously hire and fire didn’t help us very much not so long ago. But all that said, I wouldn’t weep for Mason if he were to go, but neither would I have any faith in the right man coming in. Perhaps we are slowly becoming another one of those clubs.
Reply
#20
(11-22-2025, 05:26 PM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote: Top 6. We concede goals we never used to. We are regularly chasing the play whereas under CC we ran the games. We have a plethora of striking options now as opposed to having to use Jed as CF. Pointless exercise though, we may as well ask where Big Fat Ron would have us.

442 for a start
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)