Molumby
#31
(11-08-2025, 11:54 PM)Jacko Wrote: And yet what happened with that shot? A pretty clear opening?

His enthusiasm is infectious, but it wasn't a vintage performance when he came on beyond geeing up the rest of the lads a bit.

Albion fans love a bang average trier, always have (Gards, Carthorse, AJ, Christ I've started this list and realise I could go on and on and on a bit more!), it used to infuriate me, but now I just get slightly irked. Wink

Molumby is the modern day Sean Flynn. A tenacious little hothead who ran around the pitch, flying into tackles and loved winding up the opposition. He was limited but added grit and energy to a shit side. Molumby is a much better player but similar attributes.......just minus the self imposed press ups when a pass goes astray!  Big Grin
Reply
#32
(11-09-2025, 01:32 PM)Hughie Reed 31 Wrote:
(11-09-2025, 08:41 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: I thought Grant had a decent game yesterday, tbf?

There you go again
Based on what?

Based on watching the match! 

I'd have rated him a 6/10. Nothing spectacular or special, but plenty of endeavour. Provided good cover for Gilchrist, he definitely makes us more solid defensively with his work rate. He didn't really give the ball away, from memory. He did what he had to do. He certainly didn't have a bad game by any means.
Reply
#33
(11-09-2025, 01:53 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(11-09-2025, 01:32 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Someone help me understand...

On one hand we have Mowatt who scores more, creates more, wins the ball back more, is a better passer and is better in the press but needs replacing and is holding us back. Whereas on the other hand we have Molumby who *checks notes* runs around a lot, shouts, has the positional discipline of a golden retriever and who's ill-discipline cost us our biggest game of last season yet should be the first name on the teamsheet?

Now not all of our problems are Molumby-related, he'd be a great squad option, the sort to bring on for the final few minutes to see out a game and get in peoples faces. In our midfield he isn't good enough at either aspect of the game to regularly command a place in the team, a team that wants to be in the POs anyway. Mowatt is simply better by every metric and would benefit massively from having someone with Molumby's ability to move around the pitch, but also be able to pass a bit too, Isaac Price anyone?

The stats vs eyes debate on here is always fun, but it's nice that every now and again a thread like this comes along to remind us all that a vast majority of people haven't got a clue what they're looking at.

Unfair to compare Yacob with Mulumby.

Yacob was a 6 who was playing in a team that was capable of finishing in the top half of the premier league.

Molumby is an 8 who will usually play in teams that don’t finish in the top half of the Championship. 

Fixed it for you.
Reply
#34
(11-09-2025, 01:32 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Someone help me understand...

On one hand we have Mowatt who scores more, creates more, wins the ball back more, is a better passer and is better in the press but needs replacing and is holding us back. Whereas on the other hand we have Molumby who *checks notes* runs around a lot, shouts, has the positional discipline of a golden retriever and who's ill-discipline cost us our biggest game of last season yet should be the first name on the teamsheet?

Now not all of our problems are Molumby-related, he'd be a great squad option, the sort to bring on for the final few minutes to see out a game and get in peoples faces. In our midfield he isn't good enough at either aspect of the game to regularly command a place in the team, a team that wants to be in the POs anyway. Mowatt is simply better by every metric and would benefit massively from having someone with Molumby's ability to move around the pitch, but also be able to pass a bit too, Isaac Price anyone?

The stats vs eyes debate on here is always fun, but it's nice that every now and again a thread like this comes along to remind us all that a vast majority of people haven't got a clue what they're looking at.

Disagree completely. Guess that means I don’t know what I’m looking at.

And guess that means my eyes deceived me when our most appalling performances were when Molumby was injured.

Stats are helpful but there’s a shit load in football that can’t be measured by stats. We are better when a Molumby plays IMO.
Reply
#35
(11-09-2025, 02:23 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(11-09-2025, 01:32 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Someone help me understand...

On one hand we have Mowatt who scores more, creates more, wins the ball back more, is a better passer and is better in the press but needs replacing and is holding us back. Whereas on the other hand we have Molumby who *checks notes* runs around a lot, shouts, has the positional discipline of a golden retriever and who's ill-discipline cost us our biggest game of last season yet should be the first name on the teamsheet?

Now not all of our problems are Molumby-related, he'd be a great squad option, the sort to bring on for the final few minutes to see out a game and get in peoples faces. In our midfield he isn't good enough at either aspect of the game to regularly command a place in the team, a team that wants to be in the POs anyway. Mowatt is simply better by every metric and would benefit massively from having someone with Molumby's ability to move around the pitch, but also be able to pass a bit too, Isaac Price anyone?

The stats vs eyes debate on here is always fun, but it's nice that every now and again a thread like this comes along to remind us all that a vast majority of people haven't got a clue what they're looking at.

Disagree completely. Guess that means I don’t know what I’m looking at.

And guess that means my eyes deceived me when our most appalling performances were when Molumby was injured.

Stats are helpful but there’s a shit load in football that can’t be measured by stats. We ste better when a Molumby plays IMO.

He's certainly a curious one. I'm not sure how you can disagree with the actual metrics that Mowatt passes, scores, creates, tackles and presses more effectively than Molumby, unless you think that's a load of useless shit? In which case, how on earth do you decide if someone is any good, or are you that whimsical?

I said in my post that I don't think he's the root cause of all of our problems, but when we have a good central midfilder (Mowatt) constantly derided and criticised, yet Molumby is held up like he's some hero because he runs around a lot then you have to question what people are on about. 

We probably are a better team with him in it because he's better than Diakite, although I'm hopeful Collyer can become more regular in the second half of the season. It is no coincidence that of all the seasons Molumby has been here permanently, the one where we finished the highest is the one where he played the least.
Reply
#36
(11-09-2025, 02:34 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(11-09-2025, 02:23 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(11-09-2025, 01:32 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Someone help me understand...

On one hand we have Mowatt who scores more, creates more, wins the ball back more, is a better passer and is better in the press but needs replacing and is holding us back. Whereas on the other hand we have Molumby who *checks notes* runs around a lot, shouts, has the positional discipline of a golden retriever and who's ill-discipline cost us our biggest game of last season yet should be the first name on the teamsheet?

Now not all of our problems are Molumby-related, he'd be a great squad option, the sort to bring on for the final few minutes to see out a game and get in peoples faces. In our midfield he isn't good enough at either aspect of the game to regularly command a place in the team, a team that wants to be in the POs anyway. Mowatt is simply better by every metric and would benefit massively from having someone with Molumby's ability to move around the pitch, but also be able to pass a bit too, Isaac Price anyone?

The stats vs eyes debate on here is always fun, but it's nice that every now and again a thread like this comes along to remind us all that a vast majority of people haven't got a clue what they're looking at.

Disagree completely. Guess that means I don’t know what I’m looking at.

And guess that means my eyes deceived me when our most appalling performances were when Molumby was injured.

Stats are helpful but there’s a shit load in football that can’t be measured by stats. We ste better when a Molumby plays IMO.

He's certainly a curious one. I'm not sure how you can disagree with the actual metrics that Mowatt passes, scores, creates, tackles and presses more effectively than Molumby, unless you think that's a load of useless shit? In which case, how on earth do you decide if someone is any good, or are you that whimsical?

I said in my post that I don't think he's the root cause of all of our problems, but when we have a good central midfilder (Mowatt) constantly derided and criticised, yet Molumby is held up like he's some hero because he runs around a lot then you have to question what people are on about. 

We probably are a better team with him in it because he's better than Diakite, although I'm hopeful Collyer can become more regular in the second half of the season. It is no coincidence that of all the seasons Molumby has been here permanently, the one where we finished the highest is the one where he played the least.

Because not every pass is worth the same. Creating involves dynamic play interchanged with other players and can’t simply be measured as a percentage. There’s loads more examples of why a metric may not be the be all and end all. Positional play is a huge one. Stats have become a religion to some, and do not tell us everything IMO.

The most important metric is we get more points when he plays this season, and we’re clearly better when he plays. My eyes tell me that, and many agree.

I think he does way more than run round a lot, I think that’s a lazy description which undervalues his standard. I don’t think he’s held up as a hero because he runs round a lot. I think a lot of fans see his effectiveness more than you do, and simply think he’s one of our better players. I think a lot also value his attitude and realise this also rubs off on the way we play. All about opinions ay. I’m not surprised our most appalling performances were when he was injured.
Reply
#37
(11-09-2025, 02:49 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: Because not every pass is worth the same. Creating involves dynamic play interchanged with other players and can’t simply be measured as a percentage. There’s loads more examples of why a metric may not be the be all and end all. Positional play is a huge one. Stats have become a religion to some, and do not tell us everything IMO.

The most important metric is we get more points when he plays this season, and we’re clearly better when he plays. My eyes tell me that, and many agree.

I think he does way more than run round a lot, I think that’s a lazy description which undervalues his standard. I don’t think he’s held up as a hero because he runs round a lot. I think a lot of fans see his effectiveness more than you do, and simply think he’s one of our better players. I think a lot also value his attitude and realise this also rubs off on the way we play. All about opinions ay. I’m not surprised our most appalling performances were when he was injured.

With that in mind then, lets look at it a different way. One of the biggest and most consistent problems we've had as a team in the past few years is breaking sides down at home when they come and sit deep.

In a midfield consisting of Mowatt and Molumby, where do Molumby's strengths help us in this situation? We can prove that he doesn't pass as well as Mowatt, gives the ball away more than Mowatt, doesn't score as often as Mowatt - all of this by using statistics which are really easy to measure. Then with my eyes I can see that in terms of trying to create overloads in certain areas of the pitch, he isn't disciplined enough positionally, he gets in the way A LOT, he doesn't dribble well and he doesn't take players on 1v1 and beat them very often. In his favour, he does grab the occasional scrappy goal.

You can't watch our team, a team with one useful midfielder (in fact, only one player in this league last season who played as a central midfielder had more g/a than Mowatt) and Molumby and think that what we need is more of that. Matt Grimes was mentioned in another thread, a player who does what Mowatt does for us. The difference, he's playing alongside a runner who moves the ball progressively and chips in with goals (more than four a year), that'll be Victor Torp the only player with a greater g/a than Mowatt from the middle of midfield last season.

I'll say again, I have no issue with Molumby as part of our squad but the reverence of him is bizarre when it's so clear he doesn't contribute nearly enough and get off lightly because he 'cares'. We can't keep saying "we play better with him in the team", it's a bit like being happy with pissing yourself because at least you didn't shit your pants.
Reply
#38
I think the days of having a Perreira/Kounas type to open up teams are gone for us. We’re too far down the pecking order (no parachute money) to get that kind of quality.

So yes, Molumby is not going to do that.

But I can keep saying we’re better when he’s in the team. Because that is literally the most important thing. I’ve got nothing against Mowatt, but I think Molumby gives us more. Despite what the data and stats say. Having said that, unless Collyer shows more, I think M&M are probably our best pairing. If Collyer plays, I’d pick him next to Molumby, not Mowatt.

I think we’ve missed him hugely when he was injured, we were nearly asleep for those games. I’d say one paced but we were virtually static. Will we suddenly become brilliant now he’s back? Or course not. But you pick your best team and IMO he’s in it. Easily.

In terms of teams who sit back and we can’t break them down, I think we need to improve set pieces and make sure we keep clean sheets to pinch more of these games 1-0. That’s where we’re at now.
Reply
#39
I'm not talking about a Pereira or Koumas type.

He doesn't add goals, assists, tackles, effectiveness in the press but he adds more than one of the more productive midfielders in the division. Price does everything Molumby does and is a far better footballer. My one criticism of Mason is his reluctance to try him and Mowatt together, especially in games like yesterday and as Bany returns to fitness.
Reply
#40
(11-09-2025, 03:32 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: I'm not talking about a Pereira or Koumas type.

He doesn't add goals, assists, tackles, effectiveness in the press but he adds more than one of the more productive midfielders in the division.

I think we're done here.

All that data that says he shouldn’t be in the team… yet we’re worse when he’s not.

I think Mason will bring him back in to play most games. And I think the next manager will too.

The hope pinned on Bany is just that… Hope.

Price has huge quality but far too infrequently. He’s a 10 IMO, I agree with Mason there.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: