Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
11-09-2025, 08:45 AM
(This post was last modified: 11-09-2025, 08:46 AM by Derek Hardballs.)
… and that is, fans talk a good game about building squads over several seasons, with young ambitious players and giving head coaches an opportunity to build sides over two or three years. The reality is those that advocate this approach the most, are the quickest to want the head coach sacked when they don’t get instant success, and that in our case is being in the play-off positions all season it seems. Despite the fact if they had a manager (sexy foreign name perhaps) they wanted ‘consolidation’ in midtable would be fine.
Every sentence uttered by the head coach is ripped to shreds, every sub is declared awful, every defeat is appalling, every victory is due to how poor the opponents are. I even get the feeling after yesterday’s result some are very disappointed we won just so their wish for a new manager would become a step closer.
Did anyone really think this season regardless of the balance of the squad, or mistakes by a rookie head coach would see us do anything but us bobble along where we are now? Fans either want a ‘project’ or they don’t. They either want to show patience in the rebuilding process or they don’t, they either accept our overspending in the past is causing us to readjust to being one of ten clubs who could finish anywhere from 14th-5th depending upon injuries etc or they don’t.
The reactions on here and at the ground suggest that what fans really want is a team never out the play-off positions, playing exciting football, scoring lots of goals and led by a manager who is charismatic, almost the finished product, and well someone they said we should have appointed/have lost instead.
Posts: 9,655
Threads: 411
Joined: Aug 2024
Reputation:
33
Good post. The attitude of some of supporters wouldn't look out of place at Villa Park.
Posts: 10,546
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
Fair play Dekka, I don't think you're a million miles off it here.
It seems unfair to let Mason take all the flack, as Nestor has handed him a really unbalanced squad, he doesn't have the options to change it up massively, he's still reliant on Wallace and Grant. I've said numerous times I think the ceiling for this squad is 10th if everything goes well and with that in mind, why sack Mason? We may as well let him have the season and learn. As brilliant as Carlos was, his Huddersfield side almost ended up in League 1 after his first season as a HC.
Mason could do better. His subs are largely reactive, we don't seem to have a method of playing or trying to break a team down, yesterday was very much give it to MJ and hope. Jacko mentioned the Hull goal in another thread, I'm thinking back to the Carlos games and some of the goals we scored where there was a clear way of playing that had been worked on. He's had a number of months with the squad now, I'd expect to see some improvements here by now. I also don't see any of our players improving. Phillips and Mepham got worse to the extent the latter was dropped, Grant looks a shadow of the player he did 12 months ago and Maja played yesterday like he was on drugs.
I've not called for his head yet and I think I'd give him the season providing we don't get to Bruce levels of bad. I don't see any viable alternatives who I think get that much more out of what is a horrible, one-dimensional squad. It's clear there is to be a huge turnover at the top end of the pitch in January and over the next summer. It seems fair enough to judge him when he's got a proper squad to play with. If we are compelled to sack him now, Nestor has to follow him. His picks have been Mowbray and Mason underpinned by a strange summer window. If we're looking for a third manager in under 13 months then his position too becomes untenable I think.
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
11-09-2025, 08:54 AM
(This post was last modified: 11-09-2025, 08:55 AM by Squid.)
I think you can be a very average team and still look well-coached. I know this because for years I have seen very average to poor teams come to the Hawthorns, play for a draw and get it.
We haven't looked well-coached of late and fans are right to be unhappy with that.
People saying we have a bad squad, Preston, Charlton and Millwall are higher in the table. Are their squads so superior to ours?
Posts: 2,916
Threads: 33
Joined: Nov 2021
Reputation:
11
It’s never been any different though. Most supporters do it at some point when their opinion is the manager/team/player/owner/CEO etc are shit. But criticise others for doing what they do
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
Or, conversely, some fans want to be deliberately contrarian and revel in taking alomst extreme views of either unwavering support or mindless criticism of a manager.
Like most fans on here, I could accept a year of transition provided we are moving in a positive direction (eg: improving what’s been a god awful style of play for 5 years, utilising young players through our academy, seeing a young coach develop), but that isn’t happening is it?
As a group of fans we’ve been through a crap few years that almost ended with the bankruptcy of our club, and whilst the ongoing survival is a huge cause for celebration, football is ultimately an escape and should be enjoyable. For a multitude of reasons supporting us has not been enjoyable for some time both in terms of on the field success or match day experience. There’s even little hope or optimism before or during games of seeing anything exciting… we’ve all sat through the same games knowing we are unlikely to get back into it, or heading into the last 10 minutes knowing there is no chance of us digging out a late winner.
Mason is not improving this - we aren’t getting better as a team, the match day experience is arguably worse than is was for the most part under CC - and despite the result yesterday it still feels like we are going backwards as a group. Anyone getting carried away that all is rosy after a win should read the first 65 minutes of the match day thread yesterday to realise how positive the performance was!
So Derek, it is absolutely possible to be willing to support a long term project, and be willing to stomach a season of transition provided there is progress being made, a point for the sacrifice of season, not just blind faith that something that really isn’t working will work if given enough time.
Posts: 9,639
Threads: 519
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
11-09-2025, 08:57 AM
(This post was last modified: 11-09-2025, 08:58 AM by Lurker#3.)
If I was watching a group of young players, lead by a young coach. Who were showing a level of enthusiasm, fearlessness, aggression, eagerness etc. Whilst demonstrating they have a clear philosophy, identity and game model. I would be very patient.
What we have is a consistently uninspiring set up, mind numbing tactical changes and a head coach that seems to think things are actually going well.
So in short; yes I do want a 'project'. I want a young set up from top to bottom. But I, unlike you I think, want us to have a coach with a clear philosophy and game model that is stubborn and underpins everything we do. Which would allow the smaller, tactical changes to have more chance of working.
If Mason is happy with how we're approaching games, and genuinely thanks, as he keeps saying, we're creating all these 'good moments', then I am at a complete loss.
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 10,546
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
Caveat my earlier post, and another slight defence of Mason, by saying that this season's squad is weaker than our team of the previous couple of years. Some serious revisionism needs to be done on the boards favourite spacegoats. The likes of Furlong, Grady and Townsend would all improve our current side massively.
Posts: 1,718
Threads: 212
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
3
11-09-2025, 09:05 AM
(This post was last modified: 11-09-2025, 09:09 AM by oldun.)
(11-09-2025, 08:51 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Good post. The attitude of some of supporters wouldn't look out of place at Villa Park.
I'm pleased to say I am in total agreement with this and the op from DH, yesterday was a big relief and still not sure about a couple of our players, but I still think he has to be given a season at least
My doubts are, Diakite, needs to vastly improve his passing
Josh , a good shot stopper but needs to be more dominant in his 6 yard box
Price, I really like but needs to be playing in his best position, but not sure what that is.
Posts: 771
Threads: 86
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
1
I dont see how any of that excuses a piss poor scoring rate...hardly winning 50/50 tackles unable to pass 5 yds when under no pressure and having one shot on target per game (if youre lucky).
Yday was the first time we had come back to win a game from a losing position since the opening day of last season at QPR !..thats a shocking stat. Never mind how many last min goals we let in.Another long standing problem.
Im not a booer or ranter at games but I can see why folk are fed up.
Im not for sacking the manager either.
But admit...im bored stiff at games...have been for ages..and sick of players that seem unable to do the basics well.
I dont think most of our fans ask for a lot as long as they see a team having a go...very often we dont have a go.
|