Full backs
#21
We have no wingbacks apart from perhaps SiJ for the left.

So I think we would have to go offensive in wide areas and then play 2 of our plodders in CM.

Griffiths
Bielik Phillips Mepham
Molumby Mowatt
SIJ Price Maja MJ
Heggebo
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#22
(10-23-2025, 08:07 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Griffiths

Campbell Phillips Mepham

Wallace Diakite Price Mowatt Styles

Maja Heggebø

I think that's how I'd line up on Saturday. I can't see it, but it's what I'd do if I was on Football Manager.

Gilchrist doesn't appear to have the chops to play wing back at all. Would rather play SIJ there.

Also this doesn't have our only player with pace and the ability to dribble in it, in Johnston. But I do agree he can't play wing back either.

As you edited Gilchrist to Wallace, I'd agree with Jed being able to play wing back. Not sure it helps out creativity though.
Reply
#23
Why the fuck have I left MJ out? I'd forgotten about him, but not sure where he fits in in a 3-5-2?

I'd replaced Gillchrist with Wallace, btw.
Reply
#24
(10-23-2025, 08:14 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Why the fuck have I left MJ out? I'd forgotten about him, but not sure where he fits in in a 3-5-2?

I'd replaced Gillchrist with Wallace, btw.

Yeah I saw the edit, Wallace at RWB is at least viable and you can rely on a 6/7 out of 10 from him and some consistency. SIJ would be much more maverick.

I do agree, I have no idea where Mikey would fit into a 3-5-2. Maybe you play Mowatt in a central holding role, and have Price and MJ as 10s? But seems too many cooks in the middle of the park.

The imbalance of our squad rearing it's head again.

Griffiths

Campbell Phillips Mepham

Wallace Price Mowatt Styles SIJ

Maja Heggebo(Dike)

I think something like this would actually work. The problem remains that Mikey doesn't fit into this kind of formation. So it isn't viable based on that.
Reply
#25
Any one leaving MJ out of a potential starting line up is a bigger fucking idiot than Mason.
Reply
#26
(10-23-2025, 08:07 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Griffiths

Campbell Phillips Mepham

Wallace Diakite Price Mowatt Styles

Maja Heggebø

I think that's how I'd line up on Saturday. I can't see it, but it's what I'd do if I was on Football Manager.

Not surprised to see your man Wallace in as RWB. Not sure he has the legs for that role anymore. What a shame young Alex Williams got that injury. Illing Jnr played wing back last season so I'd sooner go with his energy as long as he was told to stop the flicks and tricks.

What we really need is a player like that RB at Ipswich......can't remember his name.....
Reply
#27
If Williams was fit he'd surely be starting games. He looks a player.

@AnelkasBeard - surely we should be picking a formation that best suits the sum of our parts, and if that means MJ misses out, then so be it. I really like him, he's had a very good start to the season, but I wouldn't say he's so good you'd build a team around him, or shoehorn him in. Is he? I mean, I could be wrong on that.
Reply
#28
I like a back three, done right it can be devastating. Alas it's the only setup that would put even more pressure on our FB/WBs and at the moment that seems borderline suicidal.

I've said for a month or so I'd be keen to see Gilchrist (looks like it'll be Campbell now) playing as they were at RB, tucking in and making a three when we have the ball and SIJ playing in his natural role (LWB) getting high and wide into the space Johnston creates when he cuts in and drags defenders with him. This is the role Gilchrist would have played last season at Sheffield United with Burrows at LB, and at Chelsea with Cucurella doing the pushing forwards on the left.

This frees up Styles to play in midfield, I think he deserves a chance there and he's performed well for Hungary in that position recently. It will also afford Johnston and Price more space playing centrally.

It's nothing new, Ipswich with Leif Davis have been playing this way for three seasons and it's really effective with the right personnel. The thought of a back four with SIJ in it does make you want to shit the bed a little bit, but I honestly think it gets the best out of the attributes he's got - stay wide, be fast, cross when you can. I don't think he's tactically or technically good enough to play this inside forward role that Mason seems to want.
Reply
#29
Was the Gilchrist change tactical? He wasn't having that bad a game. Maybe it was fitness related, a pre-determined sub, or maybe even a knock he picked up?

I'm not ready to write him off.

I don't see why a 3-5-2 couldn't work. Styles as the LWB is as good an option as any in the league - he's a damn good player.

Maybe Gilchrist would flourish, given a run of games. If not, Wallace would do a job there. Nothing spectacular, but you'd get a solid and dependable 6/10 display.

What's the latest with Williams and his likely return date - not that I'd expect him to be thrown into the starting XI as soon as he's available, that would be madness.
Reply
#30
(10-23-2025, 09:31 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Was the Gilchrist change tactical? He wasn't having that bad a game. Maybe it was fitness related, a pre-determined sub, or maybe even a knock he picked up?

I'm not ready to write him off.

I don't see why a 3-5-2 couldn't work. Styles as the LWB is as good an option as any in the league - he's a damn good player.

Maybe Gilchrist would flourish, given a run of games. If not, Wallace would do a job there. Nothing spectacular, but you'd get a solid and dependable 6/10 display.

What's the latest with Williams and his likely return date - not that I'd expect him to be thrown into the starting XI as soon as he's available, that would be madness.

Looked like a knock to me. He certainly walked off gingerly.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)