Mason and Nestor
#11
If Mason is absolved of responsibility for signings, then 100% Nestor should be very worried.
It’s Mason coaching them though, and too many are regressing the more time they spend under his influence.
Reply
#12
Its a shambles right now.

Nestor has spunked 10m on..

Bielik 2m - hardly been seen, now has a cold so couldnt play tonight
Bany 3.5m - Hardly seen, totally injury prone, and has contributed 1 goal in about 30 games since he signed
Heggebo 4.75m - has 1 goal in 11 and frankly we may kept Devante Cole

All of the good work of the owner buying us and saving us is going to be forgetten very quickly because he seemingly allows his mate to run the football side of the club
Reply
#13
Heggebo and Bielik look like two huge wastes of money right now.
Reply
#14
(10-22-2025, 09:32 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: If Mason is absolved of responsibility for signings, then 100% Nestor should be very worried.
It’s Mason coaching them though, and too many are regressing the more time they spend under his influence.

Nestor is totally at fault for the transfers, he only really gets credit for the £8m for Heggem, and that was probably some convoluted FFP fix. He gets no credit for Fellows and then not replacing him.

In effect he's generated just £8m ISH from the transfers...

Yes, we needed to do something, but I think he should have done better. Heggebo is not looking worth even half of what we paid, unless it's down to Mason's 'tactics'
Reply
#15
All very kneejerk
Reply
#16
(10-22-2025, 09:36 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Heggebo and Bielik look like two huge wastes of money right now.

Correct. However for different reasons though. 

Heggebo is showing he’s not the level, Bielik isn’t getting the opportunity to show what level he is. With the way we’re currently defending, he should be in the team.
Reply
#17
Playing devils advocate, how quickly did fans think it would take to build a young squad capable of exciting but crucially winning football? We have barely stabilised the club and now fans want us to still be more than just a makeweight in the league. Moneyball is not an exact science as we are discovering. More pertinently I think Nestor have an also finding this out too.
Reply
#18
Blimey - I mentioned this in a post many months ago but got shot down: who is Andrew Nestor? What are his qualifications to be director of football at a vaguely decent football club; how come he has been absolved from disastrous mistakes such as appointing Mowbray; where was the genuine logic in appointing someone with no managerial experience but lots of tattoos ?- and I said his bro love with Ryan was worrying - Down with the kids Andrew with his baggy preppy shirt and hoody clad Ryan. And now we have some mates of his joining the board with no allegiance to the club while Mark Miles who did so much to
save us exits stage right.
I love the Albion and am really grateful as to what the new owners have done but maybe Shilen needs to be a little more involved in who he decides to give power to.
Reply
#19
What the fuck do tattoos and a hoodie have anything to do with anything?

But as said, certainly questions over Nestor at the moment.
Reply
#20
(10-22-2025, 09:44 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Playing devils advocate, how quickly did fans think it would take to build a young squad capable of exciting but crucially winning football? We have barely stabilised the club and now fans want us to still be more than just a makeweight in the league. Moneyball is not an exact science as we are discovering. More pertinently I think Nestor have an also finding this out too.

Moneyball is a term from 15+ years ago. The game has moved on with so much data about, it’s whether you data is any good and whether you are any good at using it. That’s what worried me about Nestor - talking about it like it was an advantage we had - clearly we don’t have any advantage, it probably showed how far behind we were and we are playing catch up.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: