BTA
#51
This has to be the biggest arf going, Shirley?
Reply
#52
5 pages of agreement on everything except whether BTA was a 5, a 6 or a 7/10. We all liked him for sure. One thing that hasn't been mentioned is his role in the side. At Albion we seldom had a fit no.9 so he had to play the lone ranger up front. Coventry have a plethora of options. Also he is a Championship regular now, not the new kid from Salford, with the improved fitness training and all the dietary accompaniments. 
I don't think our grim situation at the time ever was going to allow us to keep him so I'm not certain that was an option.  Also, the comparison upthread with Goodman is spot on.
Reply
#53
(10-22-2025, 01:37 PM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(10-22-2025, 01:00 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-22-2025, 12:30 PM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(10-22-2025, 11:05 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-22-2025, 10:46 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Yeah Dekka, that specific type of player that likes scoring goals, don't know why more managers don't think of this.

Don’t be facetious, if it was that simple Mowbray would be a good manager.

DH,

I'm getting confused, you post an image implying it's a wind-up, yet you're still defending your position? Not arguing for arguing sake by any chance?
 As for dike, it's obviously hindsight despite what you say. He had an excellent goalscoring record and no injury record. I can't remember a single person being anything other than delighted when he signed. That includes you.

I'm still hopeful Dike turns out good and at this point, just as he's getting into the first team squad, I wouldn't swap him for BTA.

I may turn out to be wrong, but why wait all these months to ditch him now? Maybe six months ago...

Then you recall wrongly, I was sceptical about putting all our remaining money into one Dike size basket. I had numerous conversations on here about this with Birdie and others. The money should have been spent on a number of positions imo. 

My original post was very sarcastic, that doesn’t mean I don’t rate BTA a lot more than many on here do. I also disagree that we did well despite BTA, that’s nonsense imo.

DH, Because I'm very bored on and desperately trying to avoid work. I did a quick search on your posts via the archive engine

Before we knew for sure we could sign dike and it was just a rumour, you did once say to birdman we didn't need another striker and we should invest in other areas because - wait for it - we had just signed Hugill and he was what we needed. You then proceeded to mock everyone for being underwhelmed with the Hugill signing just because we all thought he wasn't sexy enough. You never mentioned it again after you'd been proven hopeless wrong about Hugill, nor when we finally signed Dike - ! Funny that.

Typical politician. Massaging the truth so vigorously it's bent.

Shoe. If you really want a giggle, dig up Dekka's post about how great the football was under Steve Bruce. For a bloke who claims to watch so much football with his eyes, he doesn't half get a lot of things wrong.
Reply
#54
TBF, the football was good under Bruce.

If you were the opposition.
Reply
#55
(10-22-2025, 01:08 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Why didn't you talk about BTA last season when he scored 4 goals all season? If you're so sure it was a mistake?

I did, I have always defended his inclusion.

(10-22-2025, 01:37 PM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(10-22-2025, 01:00 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-22-2025, 12:30 PM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(10-22-2025, 11:05 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-22-2025, 10:46 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Yeah Dekka, that specific type of player that likes scoring goals, don't know why more managers don't think of this.

Don’t be facetious, if it was that simple Mowbray would be a good manager.

DH,

I'm getting confused, you post an image implying it's a wind-up, yet you're still defending your position? Not arguing for arguing sake by any chance?
 As for dike, it's obviously hindsight despite what you say. He had an excellent goalscoring record and no injury record. I can't remember a single person being anything other than delighted when he signed. That includes you.

I'm still hopeful Dike turns out good and at this point, just as he's getting into the first team squad, I wouldn't swap him for BTA.

I may turn out to be wrong, but why wait all these months to ditch him now? Maybe six months ago...

Then you recall wrongly, I was sceptical about putting all our remaining money into one Dike size basket. I had numerous conversations on here about this with Birdie and others. The money should have been spent on a number of positions imo. 

My original post was very sarcastic, that doesn’t mean I don’t rate BTA a lot more than many on here do. I also disagree that we did well despite BTA, that’s nonsense imo.

DH, Because I'm very bored on and desperately trying to avoid work. I did a quick search on your posts via the archive engine

Before we knew for sure we could sign dike and it was just a rumour, you did once say to birdman we didn't need another striker and we should invest in other areas because - wait for it - we had just signed Hugill and he was what we needed. You then proceeded to mock everyone for being underwhelmed with the Hugill signing just because we all thought he wasn't sexy enough. You never mentioned it again after you'd been proven hopeless wrong about Hugill, nor when we finally signed Dike!

Funny that.

Typical politician. Massaging the truth so vigorously it's bent.

Post the thread… because we’ve had this situation before between us.

(10-22-2025, 01:46 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(10-22-2025, 01:37 PM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(10-22-2025, 01:00 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-22-2025, 12:30 PM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(10-22-2025, 11:05 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Don’t be facetious, if it was that simple Mowbray would be a good manager.

DH,

I'm getting confused, you post an image implying it's a wind-up, yet you're still defending your position? Not arguing for arguing sake by any chance?
 As for dike, it's obviously hindsight despite what you say. He had an excellent goalscoring record and no injury record. I can't remember a single person being anything other than delighted when he signed. That includes you.

I'm still hopeful Dike turns out good and at this point, just as he's getting into the first team squad, I wouldn't swap him for BTA.

I may turn out to be wrong, but why wait all these months to ditch him now? Maybe six months ago...

Then you recall wrongly, I was sceptical about putting all our remaining money into one Dike size basket. I had numerous conversations on here about this with Birdie and others. The money should have been spent on a number of positions imo. 

My original post was very sarcastic, that doesn’t mean I don’t rate BTA a lot more than many on here do. I also disagree that we did well despite BTA, that’s nonsense imo.

DH, Because I'm very bored on and desperately trying to avoid work. I did a quick search on your posts via the archive engine

Before we knew for sure we could sign dike and it was just a rumour, you did once say to birdman we didn't need another striker and we should invest in other areas because - wait for it - we had just signed Hugill and he was what we needed. You then proceeded to mock everyone for being underwhelmed with the Hugill signing just because we all thought he wasn't sexy enough. You never mentioned it again after you'd been proven hopeless wrong about Hugill, nor when we finally signed Dike - ! Funny that.

Typical politician. Massaging the truth so vigorously it's bent.

Shoe. If you really want a giggle, dig up Dekka's post about how great the football was under Steve Bruce. For a bloke who claims to watch so much football with his eyes, he doesn't half get a lot of things wrong.

Difference is I admitted that was the biggest judgment call I’ve got wrong about football  and said it numerous times on here. If only others had the good grace…

Here’s the original thread…

Here’s the original thread… lots of us will recognise our comments at the time

It’s the annual let’s go ott negativity with a potential signing thread. It happens every year. The place resembles a US series that’s on its 7th or 8th season and just regurgitating old plot lines.

Which is exactly the type of player we need, with regards to how we play. Waaaasaahhhhhhhh he’s not sexy or a goal poacher though!

How many goals have we scored this season? How many chances have we created? I’m not sure why we need another forward. Central midfielder yes, defensive cover yes. The rest is just icing in the cake. The squad is as strong as most of our promotion campaigns.

Oh and this is Birdie’s reply…

Indeed.

I think  Val is hoping a few youngsters impress tonight too. We've been pretty good at giving young players a go, but never really kicking on from there, we've seen with O'Shea how throwing a player, never particularly impressive before in the deep end can help. Some will sink of course, but some swim so to speak.

We've got to get through to January. Then if needed we can top up again.

A later reply by me…

We have no idea where we are financially as a club, so it seems a bit presumptuous to make claims of going up on a shoestring. Our owners made it crystal clear that they were going to run the club within its means. They haven’t moved from this way of operating and frankly unless we have owners with very deep pockets who are prepared to gamble to go up spending millions beyond the clubs turnover, then our squad may be is as good as it’s going to get. One look at the state of other clubs demonstrates the dangers of overspending or stagnating in this division.

We’ve sold a decent player but one I don’t think would have been right for the way our manager plays and the fact he went to a no mark club in the desert tells me, he wasn’t particularly up for a fight. It would have been better to receive more money for him but trying to cling onto him would have gone against our ethos of everyone pulling together. 10m isn’t going to go very far even in a flat market, some need to be realistic about our budget. They also have to ask the question how we are ever going to integrate young players into the first team if we are going to clog up the squad with older U.K. based or foreign players. Carrying big a squad in the Championship is unrealistic for us and I’m not sure it’s even desirable.
Reply
#56
Apology accepted. 

Just so we're absolutely clear, despite you saying there are 'numerous conversations on here'* there's also no posts after signing Dike that you thought it was a bad idea.


*Just a few posts up, I wouldn't want you to waste your time Smile
Reply
#57
(10-22-2025, 02:35 PM)fuzzbox Wrote: Apology accepted. 

Just so we're absolutely clear, there's also no post after signing Dike that you thought it was a bad idea.

I think you’ll find there is, but you carry on.
Reply
#58
(10-22-2025, 02:39 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-22-2025, 02:35 PM)fuzzbox Wrote: Apology accepted. 

Just so we're absolutely clear, there's also no post after signing Dike that you thought it was a bad idea.

I think you’ll find there is, but you carry on.

You've just spent half an hour tracking that post down which backs up what I said, but now you don't want to do a search which could quite easily prove me wrong? Very odd. I wonder why...


Could you send me a link to that image of a trawler with the fishes please? You're right this is fun and in no way childish!
Reply
#59
This is getting more and more "FF" as the thread goes on...
Reply
#60
That Hugill thread is great to be fair:

"Most fans have no idea of the calibre of any players and how they'll do yet they want to whinge and whine. Not every player is going to be multi millions and even then it can go wrong.

More of a fanfare for Brown Ideye than Gareth McAuley. Learn by history you whining pissy bedwetting types."

Turns out Hugill was less effective than both!
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)