Just back, Ratings.
#11
(10-18-2025, 05:34 PM)greetsgreenbaggie Wrote: Griffo-8 earned us 3 points with the save at the end.
Camps-2 poor at best, he's just not very good is he? Doesn't even look like a footballer.
Phillips-6 did OK
Mepo-6 as above
Syler-6 only 1 bollock drop
Collywobbles-6 no better than JM
Mows-8 great shift
Ming J-4 almost as shit as Bobbins
MJ-9 great performance, alwasy looked like he'd make something happen
Price-7 for the goal alone, otherwise poor
Maja-3 woeful, as best

Jasetheace-6 huffed and puffed, better off starting
Tails-6 not much to do
Dia-6 as above
Grant-ditto
Heggo-8 showed Maja what he should be doing!

I can only assume that you use s random number generator and watch the game with a blindfold when I read your weekly marks. In the 25 years of reading this board, I can't recall a poster who gets post match stuff more wrong than you it. Fair play on consistency though.

(10-18-2025, 05:37 PM)CIM Wrote: Griffiths 8
Campbell 7 (much better than recently)
Styles 8
Phillips 7
Mepham 6
Mowatt 9
Collyer 7
Price 7
Johnston 8
SIJ 7
Maja 7

Subs all all 7 bar an 8 for Heggebo

Bar the 7 for Maja, who i thought was really poor, they look spot on.
Reply
#12
Griffiths 8 2 good saves at important times
Campbell 6 not a right back but stuck at it today
Styles 7 back to form
Phillips 7 took a booking for the team
Mepham 5 his worst game for us
Mowatt 8.5 makes us tick MOM
Collyer 6 steady
Price 7 great finish for his goal could and should have had another
Johnston 8 another great finish really on it for 60 minutes
SIJ 6 a bit and out for me should have scored with the header
Maja 6 lacks match fitness but can see his quality

Subs  
Molumby 6 looked a bit piss off about being dropped
Heggebo 7 loves a battle this kid
Diakite 7 did what we needed at the end
Taylor 6 did ok
Grant 6 as above

I thought we played some great stuff today but lacked the killer instinct
And ended up hanging on a bit
But all in all a good game and 3 points in the bag.
Reply
#13
(10-18-2025, 06:47 PM)richbaggie Wrote:
(10-18-2025, 05:34 PM)greetsgreenbaggie Wrote: Griffo-8 earned us 3 points with the save at the end.
Camps-2 poor at best, he's just not very good is he? Doesn't even look like a footballer.
Phillips-6 did OK
Mepo-6 as above
Syler-6 only 1 bollock drop
Collywobbles-6 no better than JM
Mows-8 great shift
Ming J-4 almost as shit as Bobbins
MJ-9 great performance, alwasy looked like he'd make something happen
Price-7 for the goal alone, otherwise poor
Maja-3 woeful, as best

Jasetheace-6 huffed and puffed, better off starting
Tails-6 not much to do
Dia-6 as above
Grant-ditto
Heggo-8 showed Maja what he should be doing!

I can only assume that you use s random number generator and watch the game with a blindfold when I read your weekly marks. In the 25 years of reading this board, I can't recall a poster who gets post match stuff more wrong than you it. Fair play on consistency though.

(10-18-2025, 05:37 PM)CIM Wrote: Griffiths 8
Campbell 7 (much better than recently)
Styles 8
Phillips 7
Mepham 6
Mowatt 9
Collyer 7
Price 7
Johnston 8
SIJ 7
Maja 7

Subs all all 7 bar an 8 for Heggebo

Bar the 7 for Maja, who i thought was really poor, they look spot on.

Footballs all about opinions pal, I’d respect yours if ever you posted any, regardless of whether I agree or not. 

If you think Campbell or Maja were worth more than my ratings, we were watching different games. 

I’m still waiting for people to back up their 7 for Maja!!!!!!
Reply
#14
Griffiths 8

Campbell 6
Phillips 7
Mepham 8*
Styles 6*

Collyer 7
Mowatt 9

SIJ 7
Price 7.5
Johnstone 8

Maja 6.5**

Heggebø 7
Molumby 6
Taylor 6
Grant 6
Diakite 6

* I thought Mepham was outstanding, won so many headers and was great on the ball, I need to see the goal again though, because from my vantage Styles unnecessarily got in his way (tackled him) which caused the error. I also missed whoever played the hospital pass into Mowatt that led to the one on one. So happy to revise down if it was Mepham and I am mistaken about the goal.

** I thought Maja found some really good positions in between the lines especially in the first half. He did tire in the second though.
Reply
#15
My first game in the flesh today - some really surprising ratings from a few here!

Griffiths - 8 - assured, some excellent saves and did well with mixed distribution. Only error was carrying a save out for a corner when should have left it. Coming of age recently!

Campbell - 6.5 - he’s not Furlong, and clearly not comfortable at RB but does the basics well, which is all you can ask. We need an RB in January desperately.
Phillips - 7 - usual self, solid, won plenty of headers.
Mepham - 6.5 - he was excellent for 88 mins but had 2 moments of madness that really should have been punished. One of those days.
Styles - 7.5 - thought he was very good again. Let one bounce over him, and got caught out once, but otherwise another very good showing.

Collyer - 7.5 - Wins the ball well, but crucially plays it forward and and precisely - gutted when he went off as I felt we lost the midfield. Ropey first 10 but after that I thought he was very good.
Mowatt - 8 - tidy, precise, never seems to lose the ball, emerged from so many duels with it, and key to our moves starting - him and Collyer can really work IMO.

SI-J - 4 - had a shocker for me. He’s skilful, and this makes him easy on the eye but he has no brain. So, so frustrating seeing him take too many touches, not play the obvious pass, get caught 10yds off his man. Needs to be in the team as he’s the only player with some pace, but fuck me he’s a liability.
Price - 8 - lovely goal and a real menace - great to see him back in his groove, shame he didn’t bury the opener - was denied by an admittedly excellent save.
Johnston - 9* MOTM - a joy to watch when he’s in this form, terrorised them all game and a wonderful goal.

Maja - 5 - looked half fit, heavy touch, should have come off at HT, becoming a bit of concern how rusty he looks despite having no shortage of training time now.

Heggebø - 7 - did more in 15 than Maja managed - was clear after 25 mins we needed him today.
Molumby - 7 - this is his role, come into a game at 2-0 to disrupt and battle - liked his casual false 9 cameo for a while, but he just uses the ball so poorly.
Grant - 6 - what we needed to add some discipline after SIJ
Diakite - 5 - the wrong sub but necessary with Price’s injury - left us well on the back foot with him, Mowatt and Molumby in the middle
Taylor - 6 - couple interceptions.

Overall a fun game to watch, enjoyed it and a very decent 3 points. Was impressed with PNE, they were very well organised and their changes caused us issues. Should have had a penalty at 0-0!
Reply
#16
Looked like Collyer was lucky to not give away a pen in the first half. I'd have been fuming if it was the other way around
Reply
#17
(10-18-2025, 08:52 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: My first game in the flesh today - some really surprising ratings from a few here!

Griffiths - 8 - assured, some excellent saves and did well with mixed distribution. Only error was carrying a save out for a corner when should have left it. Coming of age recently!

Campbell - 6.5 - he’s not Furlong, and clearly not comfortable at RB but does the basics well, which is all you can ask. We need an RB in January desperately.
Phillips - 7 - usual self, solid, won plenty of headers.
Mepham - 6.5 - he was excellent for 88 mins but had 2 moments of madness that really should have been punished. One of those days.
Styles - 7.5 - thought he was very good again. Let one bounce over him, and got caught out once, but otherwise another very good showing.

Collyer - 7.5 - Wins the ball well, but crucially plays it forward and and precisely - gutted when he went off as I felt we lost the midfield. Ropey first 10 but after that I thought he was very good.
Mowatt - 8 - tidy, precise, never seems to lose the ball, emerged from so many duels with it, and key to our moves starting - him and Collyer can really work IMO.

SI-J - 4 - had a shocker for me. He’s skilful, and this makes him easy on the eye but he has no brain. So, so frustrating seeing him take too many touches, not play the obvious pass, get caught 10yds off his man. Needs to be in the team as he’s the only player with some pace, but fuck me he’s a liability.
Price - 8 - lovely goal and a real menace - great to see him back in his groove, shame he didn’t bury the opener - was denied by an admittedly excellent save.
Johnston - 9* MOTM - a joy to watch when he’s in this form, terrorised them all game and a wonderful goal.

Maja - 5 - looked half fit, heavy touch, should have come off at HT, becoming a bit of concern how rusty he looks despite having no shortage of training time now.

Heggebø - 7 - did more in 15 than Maja managed - was clear after 25 mins we needed him today.
Molumby - 7 - this is his role, come into a game at 2-0 to disrupt and battle - liked his casual false 9 cameo for a while, but he just uses the ball so poorly.
Grant - 6 - what we needed to add some discipline after SIJ
Diakite - 5 - the wrong sub but necessary with Price’s injury - left us well on the back foot with him, Mowatt and Molumby in the middle
Taylor - 6 - couple interceptions.

Overall a fun game to watch, enjoyed it and a very decent 3 points. Was impressed with PNE, they were very well organised and their changes caused us issues. Should have had a penalty at 0-0!

Good ratings. But you saying Griffiths carried the ball out for a corner when it was already going to be a corner it came of I think Styles but definitely a corner.

(10-18-2025, 08:53 PM)Sliced Wrote: Looked like Collyer was lucky to not give away a pen in the first half. I'd have been fuming if it was the other way around

Check out the close up of the penalty incident Collyer won the ball.
Reply
#18
The corner definitely came off Styles, though I'd argue Griffiths should have been able to keep it in play, a harsh criticism nevertheless.
Reply
#19
Yeah I've just watched it back, I was wrong, great challenge
Reply
#20
(10-18-2025, 09:26 PM)Jacko Wrote: The corner definitely came off Styles, though I'd argue Griffiths should have been able to keep it in play, a harsh criticism nevertheless.

I still have him an 8!

From my view I didn’t realise it hit Styles, it looked like he caught it and stepped back with it, but I may well have been wrong!
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)