Great bands that you just don't get.
#61
I am always wary of these types of threads. It always boils down to personal taste. If you don't like a band, despite their success, you will invariably not understand why they have had the success they've had.
Reply
#62
U2
Hoxtons brass band
Reply
#63
(10-16-2025, 04:58 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: The Beatles. I like a fair few of their songs, but I don't understand the love affair with them from people of my generation. They're OK, I certainly don't think they're rubbish or ought like that, but I don't see the fuss!

Tin hat on, because I understand the dickheadery of someone that openly likes One Direction saying they don't understand the Beatles hype!

Remember when we made the play-offs under Big Dave/Shan?

Not too long ago?

Well The Beatles recording career lasted the same time span.. 7yrs.

How they completely changed the music landscape in that time is mental.
Reply
#64
(10-17-2025, 09:04 AM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(10-16-2025, 08:42 PM)Tom Joad 25 Wrote:
(10-16-2025, 07:56 PM)fuzzbox Wrote: What about bands you would by a best of, but would strain to listen through the actual albums to get to them?

So many....

Led zep, hendrix, Bob Marley,Dylan, Pink Floyd, Prince, spring to mind

There's also albums I loved back in the day, but now do nothing for me. Happy Mondays 'Bummed' springs to mind. It's really not very good.

This is the modern thing though, picking out tracks while possibly missing an unpolished gem. When you put on a vinyl album you listened to the whole thing (well half of it!) and even the lesser tracks would grow on you. Of the artists you mention, Blood On The Tracks is one of the most complete albums ever. Natty Dread meanwhile, got me through an entire summer and was an introduction to more rootsy stuff, in fact right now its going on to tomorrow's playlist.  Wink

I shall listen again to both immediately and report back forthwith! (Thinking about it, I did play confrontation and exodus a lot when I was younger so I'll start with Marley.) 

What about bands whose first album was great and they got steadily worse to the point of embarrassing? Muse, UB40 and more controversially (but not to the level of embarrassing - just descended to 'good') - Radiohead.

UPDATE FOR TOMMY J (always liked the name btw - one of the reasons I gave the albums another listen!): Listened to both really liked both. My problem might of been that I mostly listened to early Dylan and conversely, late Marley. WHat was striking about both, was that the production was clear; they hadn't been 'remastered' or in other words, someone hadn't just pressed the 'loudness' button at the studios and repackaged it...

Poor shout that, absolutely no way Pablo Honey is their best album.

Worth a thread on it's own mind (the topic, not Pablo Honey).
Reply
#65
As it's such a subjective thread there's lots of caveats etc and music has a strange relationship with everyone.

For instance, as someone who has seen Queen at the height of their powers, I totally get why so many people hate them. For me I've a connection with them as my neighbour was a big fan and it reminds me of my youth.

Hype and longevity does something too, which is what has happened with Coldplay and U2.

I loved early years U2, but once they conquered America never felt the same. As for Coldplay I think A Rush of Blood to the Head is a great Album and had their first 3 CDs, but once they starting teaming up with the likes of Rihanna realised they had sold their soul entirely.

There's music for people who don't like music and stuff like Beyonce, Rihanna, Bruno Marrs etc is the prime example. It's for Heart FM mums ironing before the school run.

Music conversations on here are the best you can be such a snob, but warning for all, don't say anything about Olivio Rodriguez. Her fans on here are vicious- worse than the Swifties they are.
Reply
#66
(10-17-2025, 10:10 AM)richbaggie Wrote: I am always wary of these types of threads. It always boils down to personal taste. If you don't like a band, despite their success, you will invariably not understand why they have had the success they've had.

This.

Talk about the stuff you do like, not the stuff you dislike.
Reply
#67
(10-17-2025, 10:26 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: As it's such a subjective thread there's lots of caveats etc and music has a strange relationship with everyone.

For instance, as someone who has seen Queen at the height of their powers, I totally get why so many people hate them. For me I've a connection with them as my neighbour was a big fan and it reminds me of my youth.

Hype and longevity does something too, which is what has happened with Coldplay and U2.

I loved early years U2, but once they conquered America never felt the same. As for Coldplay I think A Rush of Blood to the Head is a great Album and had their first 3 CDs, but once they starting teaming up with the likes of Rihanna realised they had sold their soul entirely.

There's music for people who don't like music and stuff like Beyonce, Rihanna, Bruno Marrs etc is the prime example. It's for Heart FM mums ironing before the school run.

Music conversations on here are the best you can be such a snob, but warning for all, don't say anything about Olivio Rodriguez. Her fans on here are vicious- worse than the Swifties they are.

I think you mean Olivia Rodrigo!
Reply
#68
(10-17-2025, 10:28 AM)Man from delmonte Wrote:
(10-17-2025, 10:26 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: As it's such a subjective thread there's lots of caveats etc and music has a strange relationship with everyone.

For instance, as someone who has seen Queen at the height of their powers, I totally get why so many people hate them. For me I've a connection with them as my neighbour was a big fan and it reminds me of my youth.

Hype and longevity does something too, which is what has happened with Coldplay and U2.

I loved early years U2, but once they conquered America never felt the same. As for Coldplay I think A Rush of Blood to the Head is a great Album and had their first 3 CDs, but once they starting teaming up with the likes of Rihanna realised they had sold their soul entirely.

There's music for people who don't like music and stuff like Beyonce, Rihanna, Bruno Marrs etc is the prime example. It's for Heart FM mums ironing before the school run.

Music conversations on here are the best you can be such a snob, but warning for all, don't say anything about Olivio Rodriguez. Her fans on here are vicious- worse than the Swifties they are.

I think you mean Olivia Rodrigo!

No, I'm on about jay's Mrs.  Wink
Reply
#69
(10-17-2025, 10:23 AM)yeoman lai Wrote:
(10-16-2025, 04:58 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: The Beatles. I like a fair few of their songs, but I don't understand the love affair with them from people of my generation. They're OK, I certainly don't think they're rubbish or ought like that, but I don't see the fuss!

Tin hat on, because I understand the dickheadery of someone that openly likes One Direction saying they don't understand the Beatles hype!

Remember when we made the play-offs under Big Dave/Shan?

Not too long ago?

Well The Beatles recording career lasted the same time span.. 7yrs.

How they completely changed the music landscape in that time is mental.


I came in here to make a similar point. I own several Beatles CDs (none of their earlier more pop orientated ones). I'd say none of them would get in my top 20 faves as they tend to have brilliant songs and mediocre ones, none achieve a consistently high standard (IMO). But 2 things I learnt from listening to them:
1. They were astonishingly prolific - 13 albums in 7 years and a back catalogue of bangers that no other band can match
2. They evolved and pushed back boundaries (not necessarily originators), influencing generations of artists. 
Their status is well deserved.


+1 to whoever said Pink Floyd. I found Dark Side Of The Moon dull, dull, dull.
Reply
#70
(10-17-2025, 10:52 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote:
(10-17-2025, 10:23 AM)yeoman lai Wrote:
(10-16-2025, 04:58 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: The Beatles. I like a fair few of their songs, but I don't understand the love affair with them from people of my generation. They're OK, I certainly don't think they're rubbish or ought like that, but I don't see the fuss!

Tin hat on, because I understand the dickheadery of someone that openly likes One Direction saying they don't understand the Beatles hype!

Remember when we made the play-offs under Big Dave/Shan?

Not too long ago?

Well The Beatles recording career lasted the same time span.. 7yrs.

How they completely changed the music landscape in that time is mental.


I came in here to make a similar point. I own several Beatles CDs (none of their earlier more pop orientated ones). I'd say none of them would get in my top 20 faves as they tend to have brilliant songs and mediocre ones, none achieve a consistently high standard (IMO). But 2 things I learnt from listening to them:
1. They were astonishingly prolific - 13 albums in 7 years and a back catalogue of bangers that no other band can match
2. They evolved and pushed back boundaries (not necessarily originators), influencing generations of artists. 
Their status is well deserved.


+1 to whoever said Pink Floyd. I found Dark Side Of The Moon dull, dull, dull.
Personally, really like Floyd, always thought that Dark Side was a great album, set new standards of sound quality, but, like a lot of Floyd, it`s an acquired taste, a `concept`etc. Thought `Meddle`was just as good. Liked the early stuff with Syd Barrett as well.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)