Burnham
#21
I posted on here in 2008 that we’d all have to learn to be a little bit poorer for a while. As it is the State stepped in, mortgaged my (then unborn) childrens’ future and then repeated that feat during Covid & the Energy Price spike.

My thinking is completely joined up. Unfortunately the UK has grown used to a level of public support that is entirely unsustainable and will place a phenomenal burden everyone under 40 in the coming decades. You don’t appear to believe that’s a problem, or it’s a problem that can be solved by ever higher taxation of anyone but people like you - which is your Kryptonite.

No one better represents our deluded electorate than you.
Reply
#22
(09-25-2025, 07:09 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I posted on here in 2008 that we’d all have to learn to be a little bit poorer for a while. As it is the State stepped in, mortgaged my (then unborn) childrens’ future and then repeated that feat during Covid & the Energy Price spike.

My thinking is completely joined up. Unfortunately the UK has grown used to a level of public support that is entirely unsustainable and will place a phenomenal burden everyone under 40 in the coming decades. You don’t appear to believe that’s a problem, or it’s a problem that can be solved by ever higher taxation of anyone but people like you - which is your Kryptonite.

No one better represents our deluded electorate than you.

You haven’t addressed a single thing, just cutting public services doesn’t make those challenges it looks to help/support/address go away it just exasperates them and leads to parties like Reform to thrive. Let’s be honest you’ve been a useful idiot for Farage for years, helping inadvertently ruin dear Margarets party along the way. Oh and I pay my taxes dear x
Reply
#23
"Still winning" was Proths boast for a good 10 years on here. He was fully behind all of the shit that was going on for most of that period.

Not case of changing your mind but of cognitive dissonance, or amnesia.
Reply
#24
(09-25-2025, 07:28 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(09-25-2025, 07:09 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I posted on here in 2008 that we’d all have to learn to be a little bit poorer for a while. As it is the State stepped in, mortgaged my (then unborn) childrens’ future and then repeated that feat during Covid & the Energy Price spike.

My thinking is completely joined up. Unfortunately the UK has grown used to a level of public support that is entirely unsustainable and will place a phenomenal burden everyone under 40 in the coming decades. You don’t appear to believe that’s a problem, or it’s a problem that can be solved by ever higher taxation of anyone but people like you - which is your Kryptonite.

No one better represents our deluded electorate than you.

You haven’t addressed a single thing, just cutting public services doesn’t make those challenges it looks to help/support/address go away it just exasperates them and leads to parties like Reform to thrive. Let’s be honest you’ve been a useful idiot for Farage for years, helping inadvertently ruin dear Margarets party along the way. Oh and I pay my taxes dear x

I’ve addressed the only issue that matters; what people like you want is not affordable. I promise you, you will not raise substantially more tax without fundamental reform. You are, as ever, looking in the wrong direction. Our debt is unsustainable, the effects of embedded inflation will make future spending even less affordable, we have over £1 trillion in unfunded public sector pensions, we have 3 times as many civil servants earning in excess of £100K than we had just 5 years ago.

Individuals and corporations are more dependent on the state than they’ve ever been and it appears there’s no end to it. Even today Starmer has announced the spunking of £tens of millions on a deluded return to the high street of the 1960s, this week they’re about to drop the two child benefit cap at the entirely unfunded cost of £3billion per year. Don’t even get me started on the rapid growth in PIP claimants.

And to be fair, the only people to have ruined the Tory Party have been those in power who subscribe to the same delusions you do, and in many ways still do.
Reply
#25
(09-25-2025, 09:58 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-25-2025, 07:28 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(09-25-2025, 07:09 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I posted on here in 2008 that we’d all have to learn to be a little bit poorer for a while. As it is the State stepped in, mortgaged my (then unborn) childrens’ future and then repeated that feat during Covid & the Energy Price spike.

My thinking is completely joined up. Unfortunately the UK has grown used to a level of public support that is entirely unsustainable and will place a phenomenal burden everyone under 40 in the coming decades. You don’t appear to believe that’s a problem, or it’s a problem that can be solved by ever higher taxation of anyone but people like you - which is your Kryptonite.

No one better represents our deluded electorate than you.

You haven’t addressed a single thing, just cutting public services doesn’t make those challenges it looks to help/support/address go away it just exasperates them and leads to parties like Reform to thrive. Let’s be honest you’ve been a useful idiot for Farage for years, helping inadvertently ruin dear Margarets party along the way. Oh and I pay my taxes dear x

I’ve addressed the only issue that matters; what people like you want is not affordable. I promise you, you will not raise substantially more tax without fundamental reform. You are, as ever, looking in the wrong direction. Our debt is unsustainable, the effects of embedded inflation will make future spending even less affordable, we have over £1 trillion in unfunded public sector pensions, we have 3 times as many civil servants earning in excess of £100K than we had just 5 years ago.

Individuals and corporations are more dependent on the state than they’ve ever been and it appears there’s no end to it. Even today Starmer has announced the spunking of £tens of millions on a deluded return to the high street of the 1960s, this week they’re about to drop the two child benefit cap at the entirely unfunded cost of £3billion per year. Don’t even get me started on the rapid growth in PIP claimants.

And to be fair, the only people to have ruined the Tory Party have been those in power who subscribe to the same delusions you do, and in many ways still do.

Again you fail to address the problem with your cut public services obsession, what happens to the people who need help? Does their mental health suddenly get better? Does a person in a wheelchair rise from their chair because they realise the Bond market wants its money back? Do the victims of antisocial and criminal behaviour just accept their fate for the good of the economy? Do people suddenly have the time, skills and unbounded stamina to earn thousands more each year so their children get an education, have loved ones cared for, pay for private health care?

You either fail to grasp the consequences of not having public services that function or you couldn’t give a poop about society (how very patriotic of you), just saying tough deal with it, doesn’t deal with it, it just creates, huge social unrest that would cost billions to fix or society will regress to Victorian standards of inequality. Maybe that’s your dream, little Tiny Tim and his family on the verge of a rebranded workhouse if they can’t pay through their nose for private health, education and social care. You could give them a wave goodbye and shout work harder next time as you went past in your Alpha Romeo.

I appreciate from Brexit, through to the near collapse of your old, worn out, knackered Tory party you had nothing to do with the failures. If only Brexit was done your way, if only the party had listened to Libertarians like you, things would have been better…
Reply
#26
This argument perfectly sums up why we're fucked - one side doesn't recognise the damage done by the past policies and feels we should push on further with them, and the other side doesn't recognise that we're fucked and can't pursue the policies that should have been implemented 15 years ago but still advocates for doing them. You're both having a bald man and comb argument that was started 15 years ago and you can't let go.
Reply
#27
(09-25-2025, 07:09 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I posted on here in 2008 that we’d all have to learn to be a little bit poorer for a while. As it is the State stepped in, mortgaged my (then unborn) childrens’ future and then repeated that feat during Covid & the Energy Price spike.

My thinking is completely joined up. Unfortunately the UK has grown used to a level of public support that is entirely unsustainable and will place a phenomenal burden everyone under 40 in the coming decades. You don’t appear to believe that’s a problem, or it’s a problem that can be solved by ever higher taxation of anyone but people like you - which is your Kryptonite.

No one better represents our deluded electorate than you.

Increasingly I think you have a point here, or at least an opinion  that needs to be explored.

Certainly Govts have been increasingly addicted to more and more spending, achieving less and less. Even Govts who publicly stated that they were in favour of less Govt spending, have increased it.

I doubt I would agree with Proth on why this has happened, who benefits and what needs to be done next.

But he is right to raise this as an issue.
Reply
#28
No one is arguing for more and more spending unchecked but the idea we can cut tens of billions of pounds from public services and those problems, challenges call them what you will, will all go away is not a logical argument.

The question if you think it is, is what type of society do you want to live in? How far do you want to plunge your fellow UK citizens into poverty, ill health and isolation? The private sector has seen people pay some of the highest bills for transport and energy in Europe, if more of that for health, social care etc is what you want then recognise that debt will simply be transferred to individuals rather than the state because many people can barely afford food, water and electric and transport as it is. Then what? What’s the plan? Huge social and financial inequality and all the expensive and explosive problems that will cause! Who sorts that out?

B1, your commitment to Starmer and co is duly noted, you get your centrist gold star for the day.
Reply
#29
No commitment to anyone Dekka, no matter how snide the comments become. 15 years ago your point was right and there was scope, and a real need, to implement them. The cuts and the increased debts since that time, the exact opposite of what was aimed for and therefore by definition a failed policy, have left us with unsustainable debt interest and make your requests impossible to implement without causing another Truss like crash, and more problems from that.

Whether you like it or not it is time to try and steady the ship and although that doesn’t give you any sunlit uplands that you want it will set us back in the right direction.
Reply
#30
I've said before we have a simple choice as a country. High spend and high tax like Scandinavia, or low spend and low tax and get low-level of public services/benefits.

People seem to want all the public services and benefits without paying for them. Labour should have put this simple choice before the voters in their manifesto. Instead they have put themselves in an escape room of their own making.

And I don't believe the grown ups who say Labour wouldnt have been an elected without declaring a 5 year lock in on tax increases. That's for the birds.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)