All this bashing playing it out from the back
#1
JWhat else do we do?

Gayle, JRod and Murphy won’t win anything in the air.

Livermore, Harper and Johansen all seem incapable of linking the play...

Our only option is a long ball along the flanks but it’s easily defended against and we just surrender possession again.

We are a very good team when we have space to attack, opposition teams know that and give us nothing at home. 

Playing out from the back is fine provided we have the right midfield combo in front of the back line. Barry/Field, Harper/Livermore and Johansen will be fine.

The three goals we’ve conceded have come when we’ve had Brunt and Field, Barry and Field and Livermore and Johansen in the deeper roles... it’s not rocket science. 

You have a midfielder that sits and a midfielder that runs.
Reply
#2
The complaint is more about pissing around with it at the back I think rather than playing it out from the back. We need both our defenders and central midfielders to be more positive. Dawson/Tosin need to play it out to the middle three, who then need to try and look forwards rather than giving it back to the centre backs. Fuck knows why they feel the need to tap it back and forth to each other.

Johansen and Harper have shown they can link the play fine. In Johansen we finally have a midfielder that isn't Morrison who's capable of bringing the ball forwards, despite him being massively unfit. And even if someone thinks Harper and Johansen are capable of linking up, we have Barry; we don't need three midfielders playing the exact same role. I don't think we'll have the issue of no Barry much after today. Centre backs out to Barry or Johansen and then build from there, looking forwards. As I've said before if we tippy tapped around in attacking areas like we do in defence we'd actually be pretty effective.
Reply
#3
(02-12-2019, 11:06 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: JWhat else do we do?

Gayle, JRod and Murphy won’t win anything in the air.

Livermore, Harper and Johansen all seem incapable of linking the play...

Our only option is a long ball along the flanks but it’s easily defended against and we just surrender possession again.

We are a very good team when we have space to attack, opposition teams know that and give us nothing at home. 

Playing out from the back is fine provided we have the right midfield combo in front of the back line. Barry/Field, Harper/Livermore and Johansen will be fine.

The three goals we’ve conceded have come when we’ve had Brunt and Field, Barry and Field and Livermore and Johansen in the deeper roles... it’s not rocket science. 

You have a midfielder that sits and a midfielder that runs.

We will always concede goals whoever plays in those positions because we invite pressure on ourselves and Championship / bottom half Prem players are likely to make mistakes. The tactic is used to pull opposition players out of position / bring them out of their defensive shape. It doesn’t work without Barnes or Phillips and a plan b (I heard a lots about them last year) is needed.
Reply
#4
(02-12-2019, 11:11 PM)Sliced Wrote: The complaint is more about pissing around with it at the back I think rather than playing it out from the back. We need both our defenders and central midfielders to be more positive. Dawson/Tosin need to play it out to the middle three, who then need to try and look forwards rather than giving it back to the centre backs. Fuck knows why they feel the need to tap it back and forth to each other.

Johansen and Harper have shown they can link the play fine. In Johansen we finally have a midfielder that isn't Morrison who's capable of bringing the ball forwards, despite him being massively unfit. And even if you don't think Harper and Johansen are capable of linking up, we have Barry; we don't need three midfielders playing the exact same role. Centre backs out to Barry or Johansen and then build from there, looking forwards. As I've said before if we tippy tapped around in attacking areas like we do in defence we'd actually be pretty effective.

Disagree that Harper and Johansen are comfortable linking the play at present. Johansen will get better as his fitness improves, but Harper is still a bit erratic, and his turn of pace and strength are far more developed than his reading of the game and movement. 

We need our midfield to hold onto possession and draw space for us to attack, but unfortunately when we do this we usually only have JRod or HRK in said space as Gayle's pace and movement is usually what gives the midfield the forward pass, and neither of those two will punish the opposition regularly enough.

We're still far too easy to defend against at home, as is being shown by our lack of goals recently; and Brentford aside, the lack of chances we've fashioned. We need to get someone centrally in that link man role permanently.
Reply
#5
(02-12-2019, 11:20 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(02-12-2019, 11:11 PM)Sliced Wrote: The complaint is more about pissing around with it at the back I think rather than playing it out from the back. We need both our defenders and central midfielders to be more positive. Dawson/Tosin need to play it out to the middle three, who then need to try and look forwards rather than giving it back to the centre backs. Fuck knows why they feel the need to tap it back and forth to each other.

Johansen and Harper have shown they can link the play fine. In Johansen we finally have a midfielder that isn't Morrison who's capable of bringing the ball forwards, despite him being massively unfit. And even if you don't think Harper and Johansen are capable of linking up, we have Barry; we don't need three midfielders playing the exact same role. Centre backs out to Barry or Johansen and then build from there, looking forwards. As I've said before if we tippy tapped around in attacking areas like we do in defence we'd actually be pretty effective.

Disagree that Harper and Johansen are comfortable linking the play at present. Johansen will get better as his fitness improves, but Harper is still a bit erratic, and his turn of pace and strength are far more developed than his reading of the game and movement. 

We need our midfield to hold onto possession and draw space for us to attack, but unfortunately when we do this we usually only have JRod or HRK in said space as Gayle's pace and movement is usually what gives the midfield the forward pass, and neither of those two will punish the opposition regularly enough.

We're still far too easy to defend against at home, as is being shown by our lack of goals recently; and Brentford aside, the lack of chances we've fashioned. We need to get someone centrally in that link man role permanently.

Lack of goals at home our problem?

2 tonight, 2 against Boro, 2 against Norwich. Surely it’s the other end where the problems are.
Reply
#6
(02-12-2019, 11:22 PM)Dumbo Wrote:
(02-12-2019, 11:20 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(02-12-2019, 11:11 PM)Sliced Wrote: The complaint is more about pissing around with it at the back I think rather than playing it out from the back. We need both our defenders and central midfielders to be more positive. Dawson/Tosin need to play it out to the middle three, who then need to try and look forwards rather than giving it back to the centre backs. Fuck knows why they feel the need to tap it back and forth to each other.

Johansen and Harper have shown they can link the play fine. In Johansen we finally have a midfielder that isn't Morrison who's capable of bringing the ball forwards, despite him being massively unfit. And even if you don't think Harper and Johansen are capable of linking up, we have Barry; we don't need three midfielders playing the exact same role. Centre backs out to Barry or Johansen and then build from there, looking forwards. As I've said before if we tippy tapped around in attacking areas like we do in defence we'd actually be pretty effective.

Disagree that Harper and Johansen are comfortable linking the play at present. Johansen will get better as his fitness improves, but Harper is still a bit erratic, and his turn of pace and strength are far more developed than his reading of the game and movement. 

We need our midfield to hold onto possession and draw space for us to attack, but unfortunately when we do this we usually only have JRod or HRK in said space as Gayle's pace and movement is usually what gives the midfield the forward pass, and neither of those two will punish the opposition regularly enough.

We're still far too easy to defend against at home, as is being shown by our lack of goals recently; and Brentford aside, the lack of chances we've fashioned. We need to get someone centrally in that link man role permanently.

Lack of goals at home our problem?

2 tonight, 2 against Boro, 2 against Norwich. Surely it’s the other end where the problems are.

*1 against Norwich.

1 against Brentford, 1 against Wednesday, 1 against 10-man Blackburn without a goalie. Tonight we barely worked the keeper, but thanks to some parks defending and a dubious penalty we got a point.
Reply
#7
Our strikers are decent passers of the ball, Gayle in particular, I think they could drop a bit deeper to encourage this link up play. Knocking it out wide for crosses is tedious.

Having said that, we are not dropping points at home because of the attack. 2 soft goals at home today from defensive errors or lapses, 3 against Boro.

Whatever formation we play, that's not going to change if we persist with this tippy tappying at the back
Reply
#8
(02-12-2019, 11:25 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(02-12-2019, 11:22 PM)Dumbo Wrote:
(02-12-2019, 11:20 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(02-12-2019, 11:11 PM)Sliced Wrote: The complaint is more about pissing around with it at the back I think rather than playing it out from the back. We need both our defenders and central midfielders to be more positive. Dawson/Tosin need to play it out to the middle three, who then need to try and look forwards rather than giving it back to the centre backs. Fuck knows why they feel the need to tap it back and forth to each other.

Johansen and Harper have shown they can link the play fine. In Johansen we finally have a midfielder that isn't Morrison who's capable of bringing the ball forwards, despite him being massively unfit. And even if you don't think Harper and Johansen are capable of linking up, we have Barry; we don't need three midfielders playing the exact same role. Centre backs out to Barry or Johansen and then build from there, looking forwards. As I've said before if we tippy tapped around in attacking areas like we do in defence we'd actually be pretty effective.

Disagree that Harper and Johansen are comfortable linking the play at present. Johansen will get better as his fitness improves, but Harper is still a bit erratic, and his turn of pace and strength are far more developed than his reading of the game and movement. 

We need our midfield to hold onto possession and draw space for us to attack, but unfortunately when we do this we usually only have JRod or HRK in said space as Gayle's pace and movement is usually what gives the midfield the forward pass, and neither of those two will punish the opposition regularly enough.

We're still far too easy to defend against at home, as is being shown by our lack of goals recently; and Brentford aside, the lack of chances we've fashioned. We need to get someone centrally in that link man role permanently.

Lack of goals at home our problem?

2 tonight, 2 against Boro, 2 against Norwich. Surely it’s the other end where the problems are.

*1 against Norwich.

1 against Brentford, 1 against Wednesday, 1 against 10-man Blackburn without a goalie. Tonight we barely worked the keeper, but thanks to some parks defending and a dubious penalty we got a point.

Do goals scored off the back of poor defending not count? Do penalties not count?

We’ve scored over 60 goals. We’ve scored 40 goals at home, the most in the division. You’re not going to convince me that scoring goals is our problem.
Reply
#9
If goals scored off the back of poor defending don't count then I just wanna say congratulations to Sam Johnstone on his 31st clean sheet of the season
Reply
#10
(02-12-2019, 11:29 PM)Dumbo Wrote:
(02-12-2019, 11:25 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(02-12-2019, 11:22 PM)Dumbo Wrote:
(02-12-2019, 11:20 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(02-12-2019, 11:11 PM)Sliced Wrote: The complaint is more about pissing around with it at the back I think rather than playing it out from the back. We need both our defenders and central midfielders to be more positive. Dawson/Tosin need to play it out to the middle three, who then need to try and look forwards rather than giving it back to the centre backs. Fuck knows why they feel the need to tap it back and forth to each other.

Johansen and Harper have shown they can link the play fine. In Johansen we finally have a midfielder that isn't Morrison who's capable of bringing the ball forwards, despite him being massively unfit. And even if you don't think Harper and Johansen are capable of linking up, we have Barry; we don't need three midfielders playing the exact same role. Centre backs out to Barry or Johansen and then build from there, looking forwards. As I've said before if we tippy tapped around in attacking areas like we do in defence we'd actually be pretty effective.

Disagree that Harper and Johansen are comfortable linking the play at present. Johansen will get better as his fitness improves, but Harper is still a bit erratic, and his turn of pace and strength are far more developed than his reading of the game and movement. 

We need our midfield to hold onto possession and draw space for us to attack, but unfortunately when we do this we usually only have JRod or HRK in said space as Gayle's pace and movement is usually what gives the midfield the forward pass, and neither of those two will punish the opposition regularly enough.

We're still far too easy to defend against at home, as is being shown by our lack of goals recently; and Brentford aside, the lack of chances we've fashioned. We need to get someone centrally in that link man role permanently.

Lack of goals at home our problem?

2 tonight, 2 against Boro, 2 against Norwich. Surely it’s the other end where the problems are.

*1 against Norwich.

1 against Brentford, 1 against Wednesday, 1 against 10-man Blackburn without a goalie. Tonight we barely worked the keeper, but thanks to some parks defending and a dubious penalty we got a point.

Do goals scored off the back of poor defending not count? Do penalties not count?

We’ve scored over 60 goals. We’ve scored 40 goals at home, the most in the division. You’re not going to convince me that scoring goals is our problem.

Yes, and most of those came when we were playing a system that suited the players we have.

The system we currently play doesn’t suit us in attack, and sees us put our defence under needless pressure. Whilst we’re conceding goals playing it out, we’ve conceded more through goals following a sloppy turnover of play giving the opposition a run on our goal (either leading to a freekick or a free run on goal) as we saw twice against Boro and once today.

If we fix our link between the midfield and attack, and look like a side that can string an attacking move together we’ll stop conceding so many goals on the counter. Yes we may still have a few scares playing  from the back, but we will score more than we let in at home
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)