Charlie Kirk
(09-12-2025, 06:22 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(09-12-2025, 05:33 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(09-12-2025, 05:21 PM)baggy1 Wrote: State of this thread in places is a microcosm of why this event has happened and will continue to happen. Antifa / Fascist / Monster Raving  or any other loony is just that, a loon. Blaming the 'other' side because it is like supporting football teams or this decades Blur / Oasis battle is fucking mental. A bloke who's views i didn't particularly agree with had his neck blown open when he was performing. He was probably spouting crap and trying to radicalise but that isn't a reason to kill him. Until both 'sides' see that then we are in a dark place and that applies from the bottom to the top.

A bloke died, it will probably escalate the situation in the States, there isn't any reason on here to build him up or knock him down or choose sides. Some of you need to take a step back, have a beer and look forward to the game and take a look at yourself.

For the guys earlier in the thread who are a bit Alanis about the meaning of the word irony. Here's some.

Did someone ask you to stop being a cunt yesterday. You should take that advice.

You know what an ad hominem fallacy means in a discussion?

Well that.
Reply
(09-12-2025, 07:54 PM)Jacko Wrote: You know what an ad hominem fallacy means in a discussion?

Well that.

Alanis, irony etc etc
Reply
Can’t beat a 27-pager for bringing out some true colours.

When all is said and done, the guy seemed like a confederate dinosaur, guilty of promoting and benefitting from what many would see as the wrong side of a sorry culture war. He didn’t need to die, though, and having done so he’s been martyred for beliefs that will only segregate further and perpetuate further divisive debate. It is all a very sorry chronicle, the end of which I don’t see anytime soon.
Reply
(09-12-2025, 06:19 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: In 26 pages (yes, change my settings) I’ve not seen anyone celebrating his death, so will the “rights” please stop being duplicitous with their posts.

What a number are saying is the old “you live by the sword, die by the sword”. He promoted hate, glorified gun use and thought children dying in mass shootings was acceptable and a price worth paying. And anyone having empathy for the deceased was wrong.

If you can’t smile at the irony of being shot having expressed and promoted those views then you need to get a sense of humour. All most have done is limit their empathy and point out the irony alongside the way the right wing media and politicians have jumped on this.

Where has all this condemnation been recently when other politicians and activists have been attacked or killed? There hasn’t been any as they were “the other side”.

Nail. On. Head.
Reply
(09-12-2025, 09:23 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(09-12-2025, 06:19 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: In 26 pages (yes, change my settings) I’ve not seen anyone celebrating his death, so will the “rights” please stop being duplicitous with their posts.

What a number are saying is the old “you live by the sword,  die by the sword”.  He promoted hate, glorified gun use and thought children dying in mass shootings was acceptable and a price worth paying.  And anyone having empathy for the deceased was wrong.

If you can’t smile at the irony of being shot having expressed and promoted those views then you need to get a sense of humour.  All most have done is limit their empathy and point out the irony alongside the way the right wing media and politicians have jumped on this. 

Where has all this condemnation been recently when other politicians and activists have been attacked or killed? There hasn’t been any as they were “the other side”.

Nail. On. Head.

Correct
Reply
(09-12-2025, 09:23 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(09-12-2025, 06:19 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: In 26 pages (yes, change my settings) I’ve not seen anyone celebrating his death, so will the “rights” please stop being duplicitous with their posts.

What a number are saying is the old “you live by the sword,  die by the sword”.  He promoted hate, glorified gun use and thought children dying in mass shootings was acceptable and a price worth paying.  And anyone having empathy for the deceased was wrong.

If you can’t smile at the irony of being shot having expressed and promoted those views then you need to get a sense of humour.  All most have done is limit their empathy and point out the irony alongside the way the right wing media and politicians have jumped on this. 

Where has all this condemnation been recently when other politicians and activists have been attacked or killed? There hasn’t been any as they were “the other side”.

Nail. On. Head.

Do you think that opinions like having a “sense of humour” and a smile about a murder of someone you disagree with politically might just be adding to the division, just like Kirk added to division, and as such you may also be part of the problem?

Obviously the extreme version of this is people literally celebrating his murder on social media. I’m not at all saying these posts are on the same level as that. But I do think it all adds to the division. And I actually think the amount of this on social media in the last 2 days has in fact damaged the left’s cause in America, and harnessed a bit of support for the right. I could be wrong of course, and it’ll probably make no difference once it dies down.

I firmly believe in anyone’s right to mock or laugh at what they want btw. I just think it damages the cause of whichever “side” does it.

I find all this fascinating for some reason. I can see a lot of anger on both sides these days, especially on social media. And both sides accuse the other of promoting hate, misinformation, both twist things and take things out of context, etc etc. Many on the right and left as bad as one another.

Except thankfully, despite social media making the world seem like that, I actually think most people would find smiling at the ironies of someone’s death based on their political views extremely distasteful, whatever side of politics they’re on. I think most keep it to a human level despite political disagreement. Maybe I have too much faith in human nature, but I honestly think that kind of behaviour, from either left or right, does in fact push people in the opposite direction if anything. And I definitely think it adds to the division.
Reply
The FBI director Kash Patel finished his statement at yesterday’s press conference referring to Kirk as “brother” & “we have the watch” & “till we meet again in Valhalla” he had to be consoled as he was in tears after this diatribe!!..For fucks sake this is the FBI director!!!..the US is seriously a fucked up place!!..
Reply
Agree Pind. Utterly crackers.

Some sensible stuff in there backside. Unfortunately though, it’s a logic that also gets used to border on shutting down just calling stuff out for what it is, in some quarters.

Kirk encouraged forms of oppression, particularly of women. His shooting is also a form of oppression. Both are best seen for what they are - wrong.

The Fred also has yet more time (in parts) of free speech for all unless it’s the speech I don’t want to hear. The world is riddled with that at the moment.
Raw Sausage
Reply
So the guy who did this appears to be a 4Chan obsessed Groyper and not a communist.

I think I spend too much time online to know what a Groyper is.
Reply
(09-13-2025, 06:33 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: So the guy who did this appears to be a 4Chan obsessed Groyper and not a communist.

I think I spend too much time online to know what a Groyper is.

think 4chan is the site I’ve heard Jacko quite a couple of times.

What’s it’s core user base?
Raw Sausage
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)