Legacy
#1
Are we at risk of losing so much of our clubs heritage? There was an aim to have a digital library that Jenkins appeared to kick into touch.
I am thinking that we might lose all the stuff that could be put in a WBA hosted digital museum. For example all the videos of our games (Holmleighs work on you tube). All the work that went on the WeAreAlbion website - still there but not updated for ages. Every match programme was going to be uploaded to the site. Maybe Laurie Rampling could upload his photos. Tony Matthews his stats and WBA books. So many more things could fill this museum...match Reports, Arguses, Grorty Dicks and Fingerposts.

So much history at risk of being lost. Shame we can't get the club to host something.
Reply
#2
I assume the re-employment of Dave Bowler will mean a renewed focus on heritage. Let's hope anyway.

As someone who works in the sector, i fear officials have a rather archaic view of disseminating the proud history of our great club. The recent book is a case in point.

The open house today was great - as was the photographic display - but it could have been so much more. Where were the fans' memories such as the one just written on this dump by Johntoewba? 

Why wasn't their wider contextual interpretation panels to go alongside the wonderful photos? Why no interactive components e.g. QR codes featuring historic VT of the Shrine - or oral testimonies collected from fans?

In my limited dealings with people at the club, they come across as incredibly insular. Not at all open to outside suggestions from heritage experts like myself.

I put some of the suggestions above in a proposal (as requested by Foundation employee), but the Head of Marketing couldn't even be othered to respond - despite frequent prompts. 

I'm now working voluntarily with Everton on a People's Archive project - where fans are being trained to document their first season at Bramley Moore through street photography and oral history. It will be an ongoing project that will eventually lead to a huge digital archive celebrating fan culture and matchday rituals.

I'm enjoying the scheme, but i really should be based at the Hawthorns. Indeed, it would have been if it wasn't for the insularity of some of those working at the club.
Reply
#3
Thanks WWHO

I think Rich knew a little of this. I knew through pub talk and talking with Laurie and others but that must be 20 years ago now. We had all the home match programmes lined up bar one from 1910(I think) that couldn't be found in anyone's possession.

I don't know how it would work but couldn't the club just not host a site, employ a couple of admin to upload and monitor (curate ay it?) and away we go. I'd happily pay a monthly subscription to look at Albion stuff. So would many others. Look at how many people on here enjoy other posters tales of times gone by/ex players/matches they remember etc.

Can someone just approach Miles? Or maybe DB will pick it up again hopefully. I want to send in my x rays of Tony Grealish's knees when he had his medical for us.  Big Grin 

You're doing great work at EFC. Bravo.
Reply
#4
The new owners clearly have great admiration and respect for our marvellous and unique heritage. It was demonstrated today.

With Bowler back the old projects will be re-ignited.

Personally, I'm not concerned about losing focus on history. I was before though.
Reply
#5
(09-03-2025, 06:53 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote: Thanks WWHO

I think Rich knew a little of this. I knew through pub talk and talking with Laurie and others but that must be 20 years ago now. We had all the home match programmes lined up bar one from 1910(I think) that couldn't be found in anyone's possession.

I don't know how it would work but couldn't the club just not host a site, employ a couple of admin to upload and monitor (curate ay it?) and away we go. I'd happily pay a monthly subscription to look at Albion stuff. So would many others. Look at how many people on here enjoy other posters tales of times gone by/ex players/matches they remember etc.

Can someone just approach Miles? Or maybe DB will pick it up again hopefully. I want to send in my x rays of Tony Grealish's knees when he had his medical for us.  Big Grin 

You're doing great work at EFC. Bravo.

You'd be surprised how expensive an online archive/museum can be pal.

Costs include at least one full time Archivist (two, most likely), an administrator, a historian to interpret the items (Dave Bowler could do this), digitisation costs (scanning docs and photographing artefacts) - plus the costs of building, hosting and maintaining the website.

I did a bit of work on the Express & Dingle archive years ago, and the overall start up and ongoing costs were substantial (we're talking hundreds of thousands).

There is funding out there - but providers would need to see that this wasn't a top down vanity project being coordinated by a relatively financially privileged sporting institution.

A way round this would be to run it as a participant-led, community heritage scheme that involves training members of the Foundation to deliver and maintain it.

Problem is, from my experience of the club hierarchy, they're not open to such a scheme. They'd prefer to be gatekeepers. Funders aren't really going to get on board with any such approach.

And cheers - it's a fun project. The Everton fans who are volunteering are being trained by mentors who curated the Goodbye to Goodison exhibition, which was really cool:

https://liverpool-museums.shorthandstori...index.html

My primary motivation is to document working class fan culture before it disappears forever. Like the Albion, Everton provide the perfect platform to do this.


(09-03-2025, 07:35 PM)baggiebloke Wrote: The new owners clearly have great admiration and respect for our marvellous and unique heritage. It was demonstrated today.

With Bowler back the old projects will be re-ignited.

Personally, I'm not concerned about losing focus on history. I was before though.

Yeah, Dave is a good egg. Cares deeply about the club and is a wonderful pensmith.
Reply
#6
I remember speaking to my grandad before he passed away many years ago about his memories of attending Albion games in the 1930's and in particular the Arsenal cup game in 1937 which is still today our highest attendance. I wish I had recorded the conversation. I was mesmerized by his stories of not paying to get in and getting a bunk up over a fence etc. He went into such detail.

Its so important, that where we can, we should be doing everything as a club to capture as much as we can for future generations.
Reply
#7
(09-03-2025, 09:06 PM)Peachy Wrote: I remember speaking to my grandad before he passed away many years ago about his memories of attending Albion games in the 1930's and in particular the Arsenal cup game in 1937 which is still today our highest attendance. I wish I had recorded the conversation. I was mesmerized by his stories of not paying to get in and getting a bunk up over a fence etc. He went into such detail.

Its so important, that where we can, we should be doing everything as a club to capture as much as we can for future generations.

That's a story told a millions times over mate. My primary reason for becoming an oral historian was due to never speaking to my grandparents about their lives. So many memories (and so much wisdom) gone without a trace.

Regarding football, it's vital ordinary fans' experiences are recorded and preserved for future generations. Especially with the way 'terrace' culture is rapidly changing due to the gentrification of football.
Reply
#8
Thanks again WWHO for educating me on this. I'm not surprised about the costs tbh. Though we should have definitely done this when we had all the PL money sloshing about. Chicken feed and something tangible.

I guess another problem, in addition to what you have listed, is that the site would just get bigger and bigger over the years and there would be a cost to that too.

As we don't have half a mill to spend nowadays perhaps the alternative route via the foundation could be reignited? These owners more sympathetic?
Reply
#9
Half a mill upfront and £100k pa should be a piece of piss to crowdfund/get sponsorship for imo.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#10
WWHO - was the communication with the club before the new owners came in? Because if it was the new owners seem to be significantly more receptive to that sort of thing.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)