Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
(09-03-2025, 04:10 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: I can't remember saying I did prioritise it. I was purely shining a light on the ongoing complexity behind the implementation of genetic based testing in sport and how it does effect outliers and the sporting organisations who work their cob off to provide as much access to sport to all people as possible. I think your inability to approach the issue in a rational, reasonable and balanced way means you could never be part of a solution.
Nothing self appointed about my work on the white ribbon campaign, in fact, politically I disagree with much of the founders beliefs. I was selected by my colleagues most of whom are women because they view me as an ally.
Your desire to paint me as the enemy is peculiar to be honest. But you continue to do you.
I just happen to disagree with you and also to be immensely cynical of men who claim to be allies to women when it is clear where their actual priorities lie.
In response to this, you: A Man, have now declared that I should mind my own business. There is absolutely nothing whatsoever I have said which not rational or reasonable, or balanced. But sadly, I am very familiar with all those terms being used against women. If you had called me hysterical as well, then it would have been a full house.
Posts: 7,726
Threads: 172
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation:
23
Bloody irrational women wanting their sports to be free of males... Come on Squid try being a bit more reasonable.
Posts: 9,639
Threads: 519
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
09-03-2025, 04:54 PM
(This post was last modified: 09-03-2025, 05:02 PM by Lurker#3.)
(09-03-2025, 04:28 PM)Squid Wrote: (09-03-2025, 04:10 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: I can't remember saying I did prioritise it. I was purely shining a light on the ongoing complexity behind the implementation of genetic based testing in sport and how it does effect outliers and the sporting organisations who work their cob off to provide as much access to sport to all people as possible. I think your inability to approach the issue in a rational, reasonable and balanced way means you could never be part of a solution.
Nothing self appointed about my work on the white ribbon campaign, in fact, politically I disagree with much of the founders beliefs. I was selected by my colleagues most of whom are women because they view me as an ally.
Your desire to paint me as the enemy is peculiar to be honest. But you continue to do you.
I just happen to disagree with you and also to be immensely cynical of men who claim to be allies to women when it is clear where their actual priorities lie.
In response to this, you: A Man, have now declared that I should mind my own business. There is absolutely nothing whatsoever I have said which not rational or reasonable, or balanced. But sadly, I am very familiar with all those terms being used against women. If you had called me hysterical as well, then it would have been a full house.
I have not at any point suggested you should mind your own business. Also from my first reply you have merely attacked my position rather than constructively discuss it with me. So how could we have engaged in diplomatic way?
Also you never once asked my priorities, because you were too busy trying to shut my views down and painting me out to be something I clearly am not. But if you want to put me in that box, as I say, you do you.
If you read my contributions on the politics thread in relation to women only spaces. You will see my position is very much pro women. As an uncle to nieces, brother to a sister and son to mom. I want them all to be safe, in all walks of life.
I don't appreciate your strange attacks to be honest, I actually thought much better of you than that.
(09-03-2025, 04:31 PM)Jacko Wrote: Bloody irrational women wanting their sports to be free of males... Come on Squid try being a bit more reasonable.
Which male has completed in female sport, Jacko? Or you just on the wind up?
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 13,262
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
You mention 5-ARD squid, for which someone seemingly born female produces more testosterone and has an athletic advantage but there's also Swyers syndrome, for which someone female at birth has a Y chromosome but not higher testosterone and there's no link to athletic performance. Those people are now no longer allowed to compete in the female category despite no advantage and having lived female since birth. I don't really have a strong opinion on that either way when there's no competitive advantage.
So biological males shouldn't compete in the sports of biological females, but to pretend there's no edge cases is disingenuous and naive.
It's pretty clear that Imane Khelif has female genitalia, grew up as a woman in a culture where intersex isn't discussed as a concept, and despite all this you had million of people treating her the same as a man putting on a dress and deciding to smash the sport, which is not the same thing. I found it all a bit disgusting.
This is the last post I'll make on this. If she's not going to take the test then she won't compete. Simple. That's how to make a black and white out of a grey situation.
Posts: 7,726
Threads: 172
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation:
23
(09-03-2025, 04:54 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: (09-03-2025, 04:28 PM)Squid Wrote: (09-03-2025, 04:10 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: I can't remember saying I did prioritise it. I was purely shining a light on the ongoing complexity behind the implementation of genetic based testing in sport and how it does effect outliers and the sporting organisations who work their cob off to provide as much access to sport to all people as possible. I think your inability to approach the issue in a rational, reasonable and balanced way means you could never be part of a solution.
Nothing self appointed about my work on the white ribbon campaign, in fact, politically I disagree with much of the founders beliefs. I was selected by my colleagues most of whom are women because they view me as an ally.
Your desire to paint me as the enemy is peculiar to be honest. But you continue to do you.
I just happen to disagree with you and also to be immensely cynical of men who claim to be allies to women when it is clear where their actual priorities lie.
In response to this, you: A Man, have now declared that I should mind my own business. There is absolutely nothing whatsoever I have said which not rational or reasonable, or balanced. But sadly, I am very familiar with all those terms being used against women. If you had called me hysterical as well, then it would have been a full house.
I have not at any point suggested you should mind your own business. Also from my first reply you have merely attacked my position rather than constructively discuss it with me. So how could we have engaged in diplomatic way?
Also you never once asked my priorities, because you were too busy trying to shut my views down and painting me out to be something I clearly am not. But if you want to put me in that box, as I say, you do you.
If you read my contributions on the politics thread in relation to women only spaces. You will see my position is very much pro women. As an uncle to nieces, brother to a sister and son to mom. I want them all to be safe, in all walks of life.
I don't appreciate your strange attacks to be honest, I actually thought much better of you than that.
(09-03-2025, 04:31 PM)Jacko Wrote: Bloody irrational women wanting their sports to be free of males... Come on Squid try being a bit more reasonable.
Which male has completed in female sport, Jacko? Or you just on the wind up?
Khelif. If they weren't they'd just take the test. Most like XY, incorrectly assigned female at birth and carrying the 'make-male' gene.
Posts: 9,639
Threads: 519
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
09-03-2025, 05:34 PM
(This post was last modified: 09-03-2025, 05:38 PM by Lurker#3.)
(09-03-2025, 05:13 PM)Jacko Wrote: Khelif. If they weren't they'd just take the test. Most like XY, incorrectly assigned female at birth and carrying the 'make-male' gene.
Sex broken into three categories; genetic, gonadal, anatomical. An XY means they carry a male chromosome, but it doesn't mean they have male reproductive systems and hormones or the genitals. So if thy are female in 2 of three of the categories where do they lie?
My argument throughout is that I don't think the genetic testing is, in its own, the best way of safeguarding women in women's sport. Especially as the body of research is so weak.
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 7,726
Threads: 172
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation:
23
The rights of a tiny minority should not out strip the rights of all the rest. Can't work like that; put crudely, if your auntie had bollocks she'd be your uncle, even if they're internal.
Posts: 9,639
Threads: 519
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
09-03-2025, 05:49 PM
(This post was last modified: 09-03-2025, 05:52 PM by Lurker#3.)
(09-03-2025, 05:45 PM)Jacko Wrote: The rights of a tiny minority should not out strip the rights of all the rest. Can't work like that; put crudely, if your auntie had bollocks she'd be your uncle, even if they're internal.
The point I am making the the majority of intersex people do not have the opposite genitals or internal organs, at all. Full stop. They may not have functioning female ones either. But they have them.
As mentioned by me and sliced. Conditions like Swyers Syndrome means the women may have a Y chromosome, often not fully functioning, but have completely normal females levels of testosterone, have all the relevant 'bits and bobs' everything.
This isn't about a minorites rights outstripping the majority, which I complete disagree with too. It's about doing the right thing and making sure any policy is as reasonable as possible. Sport remember, is more than just the elite levels. Most of it is grass roots, community level stuff, but what happens at the top feeds down. If not the testing but the stigmatising and othering of groups of people. Acces to sport is absolutely essential to everyone.
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 10,546
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
Big takeaway from all this is the term 'gonadal' which is a great word.
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
(09-03-2025, 05:07 PM)Sliced Wrote: You mention 5-ARD squid, for which someone seemingly born female produces more testosterone and has an athletic advantage but there's also Swyers syndrome, for which someone female at birth has a Y chromosome but not higher testosterone and there's no link to athletic performance. Those people are now no longer allowed to compete in the female category despite no advantage and having lived female since birth. I don't really have a strong opinion on that either way when there's no competitive advantage.
So biological males shouldn't compete in the sports of biological females, but to pretend there's no edge cases is disingenuous and naive.
It's pretty clear that Imane Khelif has female genitalia, grew up as a woman in a culture where intersex isn't discussed as a concept, and despite all this you had million of people treating her the same as a man putting on a dress and deciding to smash the sport, which is not the same thing. I found it all a bit disgusting.
This is the last post I'll make on this. If she's not going to take the test then she won't compete. Simple. That's how to make a black and white out of a grey situation.
Algeria is an upper middle income country, not some backwater. Imane Khelif is an international athlete competing in a sport which is very familiar with controversy with regards to sex testing. Post-puberty, 5-ARD is very obvious, so the idea that Khelif and everyone connected had no idea there was any potential issue prior to the 2024 Olympics is utterly unfeasible. Furthermore, the Caster Semanya case was international news. Then there was the IBA test and subsequent expulsion that Khelif experienced.
So despite knowing that it was very likely indeed that Imane Khelif had male chromosomes, had experienced male puberty and had male physical advantages, Khelif still decided to step in the ring with female athletes and punch them in the head, repeatedly.
I would say, those are truly reprehensible actions and again, I find it saddening (but not surprising) that the woman who had to step in a ring with Khelif and were subsequently denied a fair sporting contest aren't the main focus of your concern.
|