Caleb Taylor
#31
(08-30-2025, 05:49 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: None of his managers here have seen enough to want to give him a chance.

Nor has he done anything on loan in L1 or L2 that would suggest he'll be able to dislodge any of our current CBs.

If he miraculously comes good then fair play, but when there's zero evidence of it so far and for the price offered, the club were right to cash in.

Yep, good post. 

£2mill for a player that wouldn't have played many, if any, games at all, is good business.
Reply
#32
We've also not considered the standard of any of our actual U21 CBs. If the club rate them higher than Taylor then it's only right to move him on to clear the pathway.
Reply
#33
(08-30-2025, 05:49 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: None of his managers here have seen enough to want to give him a chance.

Nor has he done anything on loan in L1 or L2 that would suggest he'll be able to dislodge any of our current CBs.

If he miraculously comes good then fair play, but when there's zero evidence of it so far and for the price offered, the club were right to cash in.

Why would it be a miracle for him to come good.
And what does come good even mean.
Last season he was first choice for a side that finished top 6 in Div 1, winning more games than they lost. Suggests he might have done good for his team last season.

The idea that he could play competently at the next level up, isn't that much of a leap, certainly not miracle level.

I'm not against the sale, but don't think it means Taylor is a bad player without potential for improvement.
Reply
#34
(08-30-2025, 06:24 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(08-30-2025, 05:49 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: None of his managers here have seen enough to want to give him a chance.

Nor has he done anything on loan in L1 or L2 that would suggest he'll be able to dislodge any of our current CBs.

If he miraculously comes good then fair play, but when there's zero evidence of it so far and for the price offered, the club were right to cash in.

Why would it be a miracle for him to come good.
And what does come good even mean.
Last season he was first choice for a side that finished top 6 in Div 1, winning more games than they lost. Suggests he might have done good for his team last season.

The idea that he could play competently at the next level up, isn't that much of a leap, certainly not miracle level.

I'm not against the sale, but don't think it means Taylor is a bad player without potential for improvement.

Based on the judgement of our last four managers, his career to date and his few performances in our shirt where he's not looked up to it. I'd say it would be a pretty big leap from him to be seen as better than Phillips, Mepham or Campbell in 12 months time. If the price quoted is true, we'd have been mad not to sell.
Reply
#35
I never saw the potential others have seen. I think it's tine for him to have gone and wish him well, as I do all Academy kids, except those that go to the Vile.
Reply
#36
Can't believe we get £2m for him and just 4 times that for Tom.... Makes zero sense, then again football never does, especially transfers.

Never saw him play to be able to say if he's worth it, but it was looking like he'd never play for us anyway, so it's a good deal.
Reply
#37
(08-30-2025, 06:29 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(08-30-2025, 06:24 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(08-30-2025, 05:49 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: None of his managers here have seen enough to want to give him a chance.

Nor has he done anything on loan in L1 or L2 that would suggest he'll be able to dislodge any of our current CBs.

If he miraculously comes good then fair play, but when there's zero evidence of it so far and for the price offered, the club were right to cash in.

Why would it be a miracle for him to come good.
And what does come good even mean.
Last season he was first choice for a side that finished top 6 in Div 1, winning more games than they lost. Suggests he might have done good for his team last season.

The idea that he could play competently at the next level up, isn't that much of a leap, certainly not miracle level.

I'm not against the sale, but don't think it means Taylor is a bad player without potential for improvement.

Based on the judgement of our last four managers, his career to date and his few performances in our shirt where he's not looked up to it. I'd say it would be a pretty big leap from him to be seen as better than Phillips, Mepham or Campbell in 12 months time. If the price quoted is true, we'd have been mad not to sell.

Big leap.

He's just signed for a club in the same league.

Also in 12 months time, Phillips etc Al should be in the prime of their careers. 23 is still relatively young for  a central defender. If he is doing noticeably better than them in 12 months we've probably dropped a bollock in selling him.
Reply
#38
(08-30-2025, 09:56 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(08-30-2025, 06:29 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(08-30-2025, 06:24 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(08-30-2025, 05:49 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: None of his managers here have seen enough to want to give him a chance.

Nor has he done anything on loan in L1 or L2 that would suggest he'll be able to dislodge any of our current CBs.

If he miraculously comes good then fair play, but when there's zero evidence of it so far and for the price offered, the club were right to cash in.

Why would it be a miracle for him to come good.
And what does come good even mean.
Last season he was first choice for a side that finished top 6 in Div 1, winning more games than they lost. Suggests he might have done good for his team last season.

The idea that he could play competently at the next level up, isn't that much of a leap, certainly not miracle level.

I'm not against the sale, but don't think it means Taylor is a bad player without potential for improvement.

Based on the judgement of our last four managers, his career to date and his few performances in our shirt where he's not looked up to it. I'd say it would be a pretty big leap from him to be seen as better than Phillips, Mepham or Campbell in 12 months time. If the price quoted is true, we'd have been mad not to sell.

Big leap.

He's just signed for a club in the same league.

Also in 12 months time, Phillips etc Al should be in the prime of their careers. 23 is still relatively young for  a central defender. If he is doing noticeably better than them in 12 months we've probably dropped a bollock in selling him.

He’s 23, had a good season at Wycombe, and will get better. The leap is a small hop to reach the same level as players in the same league. It will bite us on the arse letting him go in the longer term.
Reply
#39
(08-30-2025, 10:06 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(08-30-2025, 09:56 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(08-30-2025, 06:29 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(08-30-2025, 06:24 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(08-30-2025, 05:49 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: None of his managers here have seen enough to want to give him a chance.

Nor has he done anything on loan in L1 or L2 that would suggest he'll be able to dislodge any of our current CBs.

If he miraculously comes good then fair play, but when there's zero evidence of it so far and for the price offered, the club were right to cash in.

Why would it be a miracle for him to come good.
And what does come good even mean.
Last season he was first choice for a side that finished top 6 in Div 1, winning more games than they lost. Suggests he might have done good for his team last season.

The idea that he could play competently at the next level up, isn't that much of a leap, certainly not miracle level.

I'm not against the sale, but don't think it means Taylor is a bad player without potential for improvement.

Based on the judgement of our last four managers, his career to date and his few performances in our shirt where he's not looked up to it. I'd say it would be a pretty big leap from him to be seen as better than Phillips, Mepham or Campbell in 12 months time. If the price quoted is true, we'd have been mad not to sell.

Big leap.

He's just signed for a club in the same league.

Also in 12 months time, Phillips etc Al should be in the prime of their careers. 23 is still relatively young for  a central defender. If he is doing noticeably better than them in 12 months we've probably dropped a bollock in selling him.

He’s 23, had a good season at Wycombe, and will get better. The leap is a small hop to reach the same level as players in the same league. It will bite us on the arse letting him go in the longer term.

He's 23, not a kid any more. He might be good enough in 4-5 years but we can't wait that long. He's got a lot of developing to do in order to be good enough to play regularly for us based on what I've seen. This isn't to say I don't wish him well. I think Millwall will suit him better than us under Mason.
Reply
#40
Time will tell but I don't have any issue with him going. I've never been convinced when he's played for us but more importantly, a long line of Albion managers have never been convinced too.

Another player, that if he wasn't a home grown talent, people wouldn't bat an eyelid at his departure.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: