Nige and “Mass Deportations”
#11
(08-26-2025, 12:12 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(08-26-2025, 11:50 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(08-26-2025, 10:57 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Lazily expressing the art of the impossible has served politicians and us all so well over the last 30 years after all...

If you want to guarantee Reform holding the balance of power at the next election, be my guest. 

Much more difficult for Labour / Tories to address the problem and actually remain politically relevant.

I didn't say it should be lazy.

I thought you of all people would appreciate the approach of stating the problem and the exact implications in terms of cost to wider society. For a start, just to round up, arrest and process that number of migrants you're going to need an entirely new police force that would be comparable in size to the Met.

Perhaps then Starmer should say he could do what Farage has proposed - and then explain how much it will cost everyone else and what other government activity this takes priority over. Afterall, it would soon become apparent that finding all these military bases and aeroplanes certainly isn't going to speed up the wait for a doctors appointment for the average Joe.

What I mean by "Lazy" Ted, is that politicians have sub contracted the (mis)management of this issue to the courts for far too long. Their reflex is to tell the public what can't be done based on the current legal framework, rather than altering the legal framework as Farage has argued today.

This surprises me coming from you. No amount of altering legal frameworks is going to create the financial or material circumstances where creating (or finding) military bases, forming an entirely new police force, about 300 passenger-ready military aircraft or places to send 600k migrants become a reality.

I would have thought that the policies Farage outlined today would have been cannon fodder for one of your "fiscal straightjacket" takedowns.
Reply
#12
(08-26-2025, 12:43 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Why? Reform (supposedly) support PR as it was one of the few actual policies in their manifesto (or "Social Contract) from the last election. There's currently a bill ready for its second reading to bring in STV (a form of PR) brought in by the Lib Dems specifically to ensure the government represents a majority of voters.

I get you like FPTP but the arguments in it's favour have been ridden roughshod over the last 20 years both here and in the US and I'd rather not countenance Reform forming a majority government on a third of the vote giving them 100% of the power to enact their idiocy.

If either of the gargantuan failures of the last 17 years proposed STV I expect Reform would stroll home on the optics alone.

I'd much prefer them to address the actual problems facing the nation, you never know - if they did they might get some credit.

(08-26-2025, 12:49 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: This surprises me coming from you. No amount of altering legal frameworks is going to create the financial or material circumstances where creating (or finding) military bases, forming an entirely new police force, about 300 passenger-ready military aircraft or places to send 600k migrants become a reality.

I would have thought that the policies Farage outlined today would have been cannon fodder for one of your "fiscal straightjacket" takedowns.

It shouldn't surprise anyone that the only way address this problem is to change the law. Because it is.

Beyond that the costs and practical challenges would probably be spectacular. How much more ludicrous would those costs be than the alternative of doing nothing or (arf) "smashing the gangs"? Or the cost of the Triple Lock? Or welfare benefits? 

So far Labour has proved incapable of doing anything remotely difficult apart from increasing our taxes. This could be its defining moment. Such a pity they're led by a Human Rights Lawyer rather than someone like Clement Attlee.
Reply
#13
The problems caused by governments elected without majority support pandering to the political opinions of demographics that make up swing constituencies as that gives a greater return on votes.
Reply
#14
(08-26-2025, 01:37 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(08-26-2025, 12:49 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: This surprises me coming from you. No amount of altering legal frameworks is going to create the financial or material circumstances where creating (or finding) military bases, forming an entirely new police force, about 300 passenger-ready military aircraft or places to send 600k migrants become a reality.

I would have thought that the policies Farage outlined today would have been cannon fodder for one of your "fiscal straightjacket" takedowns.

It shouldn't surprise anyone that the only way address this problem is to change the law. Because it is.

Beyond that the costs and practical challenges would probably be spectacular. How much more ludicrous would those costs be than the alternative of doing nothing or (arf) "smashing the gangs"? Or the cost of the Triple Lock? Or welfare benefits? 

So far Labour has proved incapable of doing anything remotely difficult apart from increasing our taxes. This could be its defining moment. Such a pity they're led by a Human Rights Lawyer rather than someone like Clement Attlee.



They could start by reallocating all the Winter Fuel Allowance funding into building migrant detention centres, see how that goes down.
Reply
#15
(08-26-2025, 01:47 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: The problems caused by governments elected without majority support pandering to the political opinions of demographics that make up swing constituencies as that gives a greater return on votes.

Whereas you want a government that no-one at all voted for and a probable baked-in social democratic bankruptcy within a term or two. We can go round in circles on this forever.
Reply
#16
He needs to put the highlights of the plan on the side of a bus. That'll seal the votes.
Reply
#17
(08-26-2025, 02:04 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(08-26-2025, 01:47 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: The problems caused by governments elected without majority support pandering to the political opinions of demographics that make up swing constituencies as that gives a greater return on votes.

Whereas you want a government that no-one at all voted for and a probable baked-in social democratic bankruptcy within a term or two. We can go round in circles on this forever.

The last government with majority support we had was literally the Tory-Lib Dem coalition, numbnuts. Social democracy has only ever been in government in this country under FPTP without a majority of the vote, even the coalition Liberal-Labour government in the 1920s was the very definition of Gladstonian in its economic policy.

What I want is an electoral system that is actually democratic and isn't so insane that a hard right political party with less than a third of the support can get a bloody majority and enact a platform of economic idiocy and fiscal destruction against the wishes of the majority.

You constantly complain about Reform's idiocy and pandering to rent seekers yet you are literally supporting a voting system that empowers rent seekers and is going to disproportionately act in Reform's favour vs their actual support against the democratic wishes of the voters.
Reply
#18
(08-26-2025, 02:49 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(08-26-2025, 02:04 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(08-26-2025, 01:47 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: The problems caused by governments elected without majority support pandering to the political opinions of demographics that make up swing constituencies as that gives a greater return on votes.

Whereas you want a government that no-one at all voted for and a probable baked-in social democratic bankruptcy within a term or two. We can go round in circles on this forever.

The last government with majority support we had was literally the Tory-Lib Dem coalition, numbnuts. Social democracy has only ever been in government in this country under FPTP without a majority of the vote, even the coalition Liberal-Labour government in the 1920s was the very definition of Gladstonian in its economic policy.

What I want is an electoral system that is actually democratic and isn't so insane that a hard right political party with less than a third of the support can get a bloody majority and enact a platform of economic idiocy and fiscal destruction against the wishes of the majority.

You constantly complain about Reform's idiocy and pandering to rent seekers yet you are literally supporting a voting system that empowers rent seekers and is going to disproportionately act in Reform's favour vs their actual support against the democratic wishes of the voters.

Yes, and I didn't vote for that bloody coalition and neither did you.

I constantly complain about the idiocy of most political parties too. I'd prefer benign dictatorship as I've said before. We'll never vote for what is good for us.
Reply
#19
A majority of the country voted for a centre-right government with the headline policy to cut the deficit through spending cuts, that is exactly what we ended up with.

Compare that with 2019-2024 where there was zero continuity or coherent policy making with a single party controlling the bloody government.
Reply
#20
We ended up with Tuition Fee hikes, tax increases and a slight reduction in the growth of spending overall. That wasn't on the side of a bus.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: