Derby - Ratings
#31
(08-13-2025, 11:30 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: As always, stats are not the be all and end all, they are to be used with an overall view from watching a game to form opinions. Stat fetishists can't seem to understand that, and statphobics don't understand what statistical analysis adds to the game.

Both are useful when used together.

I agree, they can be very useful but only as one element of overall assessment. For example if you use stats to mark someone down because they did not play in a manner you think they should tactically, that’s bringing human bias into the judgement as you’re judging them against your own tactics not those the players is being asked to execute by the manager.
Reply
#32
(08-13-2025, 07:51 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(08-13-2025, 07:45 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Largely agree but you've marked Wildsmith about five marks too high.

I'd have backed myself to he'd their free kick away, let alone have a professional keeper simply catch the fucker.

I've watched it 10 times this morning and am still backing slippery Joe on this this occasion. 

Fwiw. I think he's shit generally. But not blaming him for this one.

Sorry your wrong on Wildsmith Lurker, he should easily save that, positioning all wrong, hardly jumped and moved his hands as ball flew past him. Mr Flapper is a new name for him. 2 just for turning up.
Williams Diakate and Mowatt all 7 they played well.Price is a class above and Hegabo really puts himself about good player .
Reply
#33
yer i think if you ask any pro keeper if they would be expected to get beaten from that angle , 99% of them would say no
Reply
#34
(08-13-2025, 10:15 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(08-13-2025, 10:07 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(08-13-2025, 09:59 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(08-13-2025, 09:49 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(08-13-2025, 09:42 AM)richbaggie Wrote: Don't know how you saw Mowatt 2 points higher than Diakite who I thought was the better of the 2.

Diakite was between a 6/7 for me. Just feel he didn't offer enough in the way of progressive possession being as he was the one playing higher up. 

Just a solid, uneventful display. 

Mowatt, had the second most key passes, second most successful dribbles second most successful crosses, and carried the ball brilliantly on a number of occasions. He also had the most touches and completed passes of any player barring the 2 CBs.

It came across different to me live. Diakite job is to break up play and play it simple, he's not there to create and step forward. He did the breaking up really well and that's going to be a vital role this season. I thought he was very good indeed.

I think between you you've nailed our midfield issue. Molumby and Mowatt or Mowatt and Diakite always seems to me that two players are doing the work of one. Mowatt either has a tendency, or is tasked with dropping between the CBs to dictate play and the numbers prove out that he's good at it. You need your slightly forward of the two 'pivots' to be capable of winning the ball and playing forward with it and I'm not sure we have that with either Diakite or Molumby - who for my money is actually our weakest midfielder, despite his effort. It is also why I think we'll try and bring in a genuine '10' before the window closes to allow Price to play that role, he's one player we have who is capable of a foot in and then driving forwards. 

I still think our best/most likely XI is: Griffiths; Furlong, Phillips, Campbell, Styles; Mowatt, Price; MJ, Maja, Fellows; Heggebo. If we can get hold of a '10' or wide attacking option, with Dike and Bany to return I think that's the basis of a stronger side than last season.

Spot on Ted.

Good side that Ted but we would need a holding midfielder or get over run.Mowatt is the Link not like Molumby or Diakate who can protect the back four.
Reply
#35
(08-13-2025, 12:12 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(08-13-2025, 11:30 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: As always, stats are not the be all and end all, they are to be used with an overall view from watching a game to form opinions. Stat fetishists can't seem to understand that, and statphobics don't understand what statistical analysis adds to the game.

Both are useful when used together.

I agree, they can be very useful but only as one element of overall assessment. For example if you use stats to mark someone down because they did not play in a manner you think they should tactically, that’s bringing human bias into the judgement as you’re judging them against your own tactics not those the players is being asked to execute by the manager.

I agree with both of you, kind of. 

Stats are never the be all and end all of my assessment. They just often reinforce or disprove what I saw when watching in real time including, as Dekka says, my own personal biases. 

What I am not sure about is why the same rules don't seem to apply to player like MJ. Qualitatively he played wonderfully. Lots of skill, nice touches, clever movement and constantly involved. His stats (whilst it was a very skinny stat pack in the cup) also showed that he was constantly involved and clocked up lots of creative contributions. Yet there are many stating he was useless or flattered to deceive. 

Diakite who did some neat things but also made some errors and didn't really clock up any decent numbers gets (almost) unanimously praised? 

Of course the games all about opinions as muggle fans at the end of the day and there's no right or wrong way of consuming the games.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#36
It was a generally good performance against an awful side that the goalkeeper contrived to throw away.

Wildshit 3 - horrendous error for the goal which was the only shot he had to deal with, also flapped a deep cross out for a corner that he could have left. Distribution poor on three occasions.

Williams 7 - good debut, excellent defensively, good passer, tentative going forward and wanted that bit of extra time on the ball you get in age group football.
Taylor 7 - I thought he had a good game, probably should stay on his feet in the 95th minute though.
Campbell 7 - he looks the part, some driving runs, good pace, slightly clumsy but may have been because he was on the left of the two.
Styles 7 - good defensively, has to do better in attacking positions.

Mowatt 8 - ran the game, a vastly underrated player among our own fans.
Diakite 7 - good defensive midfield performance, several key interceptions and tackles. Neat in possession.

Fellows 8 - caused no end of trouble, should have had a penalty in the first half. Snatched at a couple of chances.
Price 8 - our best player again, would have had a 9 but has a tendency to take on the shot with others better placed.
Johnston 7 - had the beating of his fullback all evening, but often made the wrong decision, I'd still have him playing over Grant.

Heggebo 8 - leads the press, gets in good goal scoring positions and got his goal, could have had a couple more if teammates got their heads up.

Wallace 4 - totally ineffective, his legs have gone, can't beat a man. Woeful penalty summed up an awful cameo. Want to see much less of him.
Maja 6 - he looks rusty, which is understandable given what has been another 6 month lay-off. Still some neat touches and only an excellent save prevented him wrapping up the win.
Molumby 6 - no real impact, good penalty.
Grant 5 - dreadful penalty.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)