Derby - Ratings
#21
Sorry, but I thought Mikey was awful. Lively, jinking runs are fine if you get past your man and have an end product. You wouldn’t buy an half baked cake and give it high marks thinking it was fully made.
Reply
#22
(08-13-2025, 10:18 AM)Lightnin Wrote: Sorry, but I thought Mikey was awful. Lively, jinking runs are fine if you get past your man and have an end product. You wouldn’t buy an half baked cake and give it high marks thinking it was fully made.

He's a frustrating player for sure, can see why Celtic struggled with him.

As said, so often he beats players but achieved nothing, so other than exciting the crowd, it's utterly pointless, his crossing is very hit and miss, his shooting has got worse and so often seems blind to an obvious pass in the box.
Reply
#23
(08-13-2025, 10:18 AM)Lightnin Wrote: Sorry, but I thought Mikey was awful. Lively, jinking runs are fine if you get past your man and have an end product. You wouldn’t buy an half baked cake and give it high marks thinking it was fully made.

Agree, very much flatters to deceive. Some lovely footwork for the cameras and likes last night but ultimately he produced little of note in terms of creation.

(08-13-2025, 10:16 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(08-13-2025, 10:09 AM)richbaggie Wrote: I would have Diakite sitting with Price as the progressive one alongside him and Maja in the 10.

I sort of agree.

My concern is that we've all said Price playing deeper but it's never really been done, maybe he doesn't like playing deeper and wants to play in that 10 role, as our best player, best play him in his favoured role. I'd then suggest buying or loaning a deeper midfield that carries the ball forward and us more inventive with passing.

I wouldn't have Price too deep, I'd give him licence to have the a Bryan Robson box to box role. He's got the engine for it.
Reply
#24
Maybe a 7 for Williams, very promising.

If we lose Hegel, Campbell and Philips should be a solid centre half pair with Diakite also able to play there

And agree with Lightnin about MJ. No end product
Reply
#25
(08-13-2025, 10:34 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Maybe a 7 for Williams, very promising.

If we lose Hegel, Campbell and Philips should be a solid centre half pair with Diakite also able to play there

And agree with Lightnin about MJ. No end product

Campbell and Phillips for me anyway
Reply
#26
Johnston (as with Grady) has the ability to beat players regularly, which is an asset in any league. There were numerous times, especially in the second half where he exchanged quick passes and carried the ball up the pitch. It's been spoken about at length on here that we're not a team that does this well enough or often enough. As for the end product, isn't that the way of the winger? Fellows is an obvious exception but if MJ produced every time he got in a good position, then he wouldn't be playing for us.
Reply
#27
(08-13-2025, 10:38 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Johnston (as with Grady) has the ability to beat players regularly, which is an asset in any league. There were numerous times, especially in the second half where he exchanged quick passes and carried the ball up the pitch. It's been spoken about at length on here that we're not a team that does this well enough or often enough. As for the end product, isn't that the way of the winger? Fellows is an obvious exception but if MJ produced every time he got in a good position, then he wouldn't be playing for us.

Raw sausage
Reply
#28
(08-13-2025, 09:59 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(08-13-2025, 09:49 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(08-13-2025, 09:42 AM)richbaggie Wrote: Don't know how you saw Mowatt 2 points higher than Diakite who I thought was the better of the 2.

Diakite was between a 6/7 for me. Just feel he didn't offer enough in the way of progressive possession being as he was the one playing higher up. 

Just a solid, uneventful display. 

Mowatt, had the second most key passes, second most successful dribbles second most successful crosses, and carried the ball brilliantly on a number of occasions. He also had the most touches and completed passes of any player barring the 2 CBs.

It came across different to me live. Diakite job is to break up play and play it simple, he's not there to create and step forward. He did the breaking up really well and that's going to be a vital role this season. I thought he was very good indeed.

Completely agree, he did what he was in the team for very well. The only time he did he overplay the ball was with the ambitious turn but even then he won the free kick. 

Stats cannot tell you everything and skew perspectives.
Reply
#29
As always, stats are not the be all and end all, they are to be used with an overall view from watching a game to form opinions. Stat fetishists can't seem to understand that, and statphobics don't understand what statistical analysis adds to the game.

Both are useful when used together.
Reply
#30
The low marking of Diakite is strange, close to M-o-M for me.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)