Posts: 10,546
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
(08-13-2025, 06:37 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Fair point regarding getting game time into GK's!
I've no qualms with the signing. I understand there's probably a gem out there waiting to be uncovered, but the back up GK is always going to be a bit shaky. That's why they're a back up, and not a starter.
It's not realistic to have two GK's as good as each other, is it?
No, but it is at least realistic to have two goalkeepers who look like they've actually played in goal before.
Posts: 27,984
Threads: 1,168
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
64
(08-13-2025, 07:53 AM)oldun Wrote: (08-13-2025, 06:37 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Fair point regarding getting game time into GK's!
I've no qualms with the signing. I understand there's probably a gem out there waiting to be uncovered, but the back up GK is always going to be a bit shaky. That's why they're a back up, and not a starter.
It's not realistic to have two GK's as good as each other, is it?
Chelsea tried Shilton and Bonnetti I think?
Arsenal tried it a couple of years ago with Raya and Ramsdale on rotation, doesn’t work as neither keeper gets a run of games to build consistency and the defence gets unsettled not having a constant presence behind them.
Posts: 9,649
Threads: 411
Joined: Aug 2024
Reputation:
33
08-13-2025, 08:48 AM
(This post was last modified: 08-13-2025, 08:49 AM by Josh1873.)
(08-13-2025, 08:03 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: (08-13-2025, 06:37 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Fair point regarding getting game time into GK's!
I've no qualms with the signing. I understand there's probably a gem out there waiting to be uncovered, but the back up GK is always going to be a bit shaky. That's why they're a back up, and not a starter.
It's not realistic to have two GK's as good as each other, is it?
No, but it is at least realistic to have two goalkeepers who look like they've actually played in goal before.
Well, I guess so. But the point is that a reserve GK is always going to be liable to making a costly error. Lack of game time, and the fact they're probably not great, otherwise they wouldn't be happy sitting on the bench, contribute to that.
I do think Wildsmith has reached a point where we can't do any worse. Haven't we got an academy lad that's highly rated? Perhaps he should have the reserve gig, but then you risk throwing him into a high pressured situation and he either sinks or swims. It's not ideal.
However, at this point, neither is Wildsmith. That doesn't mean that at the time of his signing, he wasn't a bad choice for reserve. It's easy to say it's a poor signing in hindsight after he's made a number of mistakes. I don't recall anyone being over critical at his signing at the time it was made.
Posts: 466
Threads: 1
Joined: Feb 2023
Reputation:
2
Living in Derby they rated Wildsmith and thought he was a good keeper, they were disappointed when he left. Maybe the fact he hadn’t been a first choice keeper was too much pressure for him and he reverted back when he had the chance here.
Posts: 3,808
Threads: 49
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
3
(08-13-2025, 07:24 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: (08-13-2025, 07:17 AM)Stillclem4england Wrote: (08-13-2025, 06:50 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I'd be interested to see data on Wildsmith's promotion season with Derby.
Did they have an exceptional defence, so he had to face very few shots.
From what I have seen of him here, his general keeping is sound and I think his record with us is still less than 1 goal conceded per game.
But he does seem to have a weakness with hard shots fired towards him at head height and above. He cannot cope with anything in the air full stop. Totally unable to deal with crosses.
Something he has in common with Jesus. And Dracula.
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
(08-13-2025, 07:53 AM)oldun Wrote: (08-13-2025, 06:37 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Fair point regarding getting game time into GK's!
I've no qualms with the signing. I understand there's probably a gem out there waiting to be uncovered, but the back up GK is always going to be a bit shaky. That's why they're a back up, and not a starter.
It's not realistic to have two GK's as good as each other, is it?
Chelsea tried Shilton and Bonnetti I think? Bit much, playing 2 keepers.
Posts: 7,472
Threads: 373
Joined: Sep 2024
Reputation:
33
Posts: 1,718
Threads: 212
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
3
(08-13-2025, 10:48 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: (08-13-2025, 07:53 AM)oldun Wrote: (08-13-2025, 06:37 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Fair point regarding getting game time into GK's!
I've no qualms with the signing. I understand there's probably a gem out there waiting to be uncovered, but the back up GK is always going to be a bit shaky. That's why they're a back up, and not a starter.
It's not realistic to have two GK's as good as each other, is it?
Chelsea tried Shilton and Bonnetti I think? Bit much, playing 2 keepers.
There's a thought
Posts: 8,006
Threads: 188
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
37
(08-13-2025, 10:48 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: (08-13-2025, 07:53 AM)oldun Wrote: (08-13-2025, 06:37 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Fair point regarding getting game time into GK's!
I've no qualms with the signing. I understand there's probably a gem out there waiting to be uncovered, but the back up GK is always going to be a bit shaky. That's why they're a back up, and not a starter.
It's not realistic to have two GK's as good as each other, is it?
Chelsea tried Shilton and Bonnetti I think? Bit much, playing 2 keepers. If we had Wildsmith AND Button, I still wouldn't back us for a clean sheet!
Be funny though if they had to squeeze into 1 strip with ButtSmith on the back.
Posts: 7,988
Threads: 145
Joined: Feb 2024
Reputation:
15
08-13-2025, 12:48 PM
(This post was last modified: 08-13-2025, 12:49 PM by MrBater.)
The data doesn't seem to be looked at for how many games they've played. Then again he was L1 golden glove when we bought him, and I think he'd played almost the full season?
I'd like to know what data was used for Cole and Frabotta's signings...
Also in the League Cup it's almost a given that the second keeper plays unless it's the latter stages, even then some get all the way through.
|