Re Wildsmith
#1
Id blame the idiot who thought it a good idea to sign a goalie thats played 168 games in 10 yrs.
Those stats suggest hes never been good enough.
You dont need fkin coaching badges to recognise that.
Reply
#2
I don't believe we signed Wildsmith with the intention of being the long term no.1. So, I'm not sure it's valid to criticise whoever signed him.

I'm don't understand why you need to rest a GK one game into a season, but it's the done thing in this reserve cup, isn't it? I get it for outfield players, but not GK's.

I suppose if Griffiths played last night, picked up a bad injury, and then we're left with Wildsmith for an extended period, Mason would have got criticised.
Reply
#3
(08-13-2025, 05:33 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: I don't believe we signed Wildsmith with the intention of being the long term no.1. So, I'm not sure it's valid to criticise whoever signed him.

I'm don't understand why you need to rest a GK one game into a season, but it's the done thing in this reserve cup, isn't it? I get it for outfield players, but not GK's.

I suppose if Griffiths played last night, picked up a bad injury, and then we're left with Wildsmith for an extended period, Mason would have got criticised.

It’s less about resting and more just giving your backup keeper a chance to get some game time. If something happens to your first choice keeper then at least your backup has had some recent match experience.

Going back to the OP, you aren’t going to find a keeper who has played 400+ games in ten years on our budget as they tend to be good enough to start regularly and don’t want to be backup keepers at West Brom. Wildsmith was signed off the back of a very good season for Derby in League One, which at the time seemed a good deal. Hasn’t worked out that way.
Reply
#4
There have been worse - although not many - but I’m not sure many have cost as many points per game.
Reply
#5
Fair point regarding getting game time into GK's!

I've no qualms with the signing. I understand there's probably a gem out there waiting to be uncovered, but the back up GK is always going to be a bit shaky. That's why they're a back up, and not a starter.

It's not realistic to have two GK's as good as each other, is it?
Reply
#6
I'd be interested to see data on Wildsmith's promotion season with Derby.

Did they have an exceptional defence, so he had to face very few shots.

From what I have seen of him here, his general keeping is sound and I think his record with us is still less than 1 goal conceded per game.

But he does seem to have a weakness with hard shots fired towards him at head height and above.
Reply
#7
(08-13-2025, 06:50 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I'd be interested to see data on Wildsmith's promotion season with Derby.

Did they have an exceptional defence, so he had to face very few shots.

From what I have seen of him here, his general keeping is sound and I think his record with us is still less than 1 goal conceded per game.

But he does seem to have a weakness with hard shots fired towards him at head height and above.
He cannot cope with anything in the air full stop. Totally unable to deal with crosses.
Reply
#8
(08-13-2025, 07:17 AM)Stillclem4england Wrote:
(08-13-2025, 06:50 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I'd be interested to see data on Wildsmith's promotion season with Derby.

Did they have an exceptional defence, so he had to face very few shots.

From what I have seen of him here, his general keeping is sound and I think his record with us is still less than 1 goal conceded per game.

But he does seem to have a weakness with hard shots fired towards him at head height and above.
He cannot cope with anything in the air full stop. Totally unable to deal with crosses.

Something he has in common with Jesus.
Reply
#9
(08-13-2025, 07:17 AM)Stillclem4england Wrote:
(08-13-2025, 06:50 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I'd be interested to see data on Wildsmith's promotion season with Derby.

Did they have an exceptional defence, so he had to face very few shots.

From what I have seen of him here, his general keeping is sound and I think his record with us is still less than 1 goal conceded per game.

But he does seem to have a weakness with hard shots fired towards him at head height and above.
He cannot cope with anything in the air full stop. Totally unable to deal with crosses.

And yet he kept goal for a promotion winning side.

Not sure I agree with you on crosses.
Reply
#10
(08-13-2025, 06:37 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Fair point regarding getting game time into GK's!

I've no qualms with the signing. I understand there's probably a gem out there waiting to be uncovered, but the back up GK is always going to be a bit shaky. That's why they're a back up, and not a starter.

It's not realistic to have two GK's as good as each other, is it?

Chelsea tried Shilton and Bonnetti I think?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)