What Mason should learn from tonight
#31
(08-12-2025, 10:16 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(08-12-2025, 10:14 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Didn't see any of the match. All I've learned tonight is that Lurk is going to bore the pants off us all season long by telling us what Mason has done wrong. If we win the Champ it will be by too small a margin for Lurk.

I would read my thread from the weekend where I praised much of the work we did. The same as tonight, some patterns of play looked really good, we looked well drilled, set up and coached. 

I just happen to think that his subs in both his games have been wrong. But just so I know, are we meant to pass comment on the bad bits and the good bits, or just the good?

It's the air of authority with which you deliver your judgements, mate. It's wearing thin. "He shouldn't make pub league subs" isn't the kind of punditry that informs anyone of anything. Do you not think we could see half a dozen games or so before getting too deeply into forensic examination of Ryan Mason's credibility?
Reply
#32
What we learned today;

We still have a problem finding a balanced midfield - what ever the pairing we are relying on Mowatt to do both jobs. We need him to dictate tempo and get us playing from deep, but we also need him to drive forward, try and pick passes and offer a goal threat. Even with 60%+ possession in the first 65 mins we couldn't break lines enough to create good clear cut chances.

Campbell will be fine. Offered real penetration with both his passing and ball carrying at times. Perhaps needs to work on being more dominant defensively but he gave me Temu Vini Kompany vibes. Lots of potential to work with.

Taylor isn't good enough and needs to play regular football for a number of years to get there. Too flat footed, poor body shape when defending and painfully slow so can't make up for it. Got caught out three times with balls over Williams head that he didn't read and didn't have the pace to recover. Luckily they weren't punished.

We need 1 or two, ball carrying/in behind, attacking threats. We have let go of Grady and not replaced him and we were already short in that area last year.

We have a good player on our hands in Heggebo, who seems to be striking up a good relationship with Price.

We need to get players closer to our widemen when we get the ball out to them, this has been an issue for a while. And I think stems from the lack of offensive off the ball running from our fullbacks. They either need to get within 10/15 yards on inside to support with quick one twos. Or they need to go on the overlap. Ours seems to do neither, enough.

The team looks really well drilled off the ball, nice and compact, narrow and aggressive. But far too static when we get in possession. Lots to work on..

(08-12-2025, 10:41 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(08-12-2025, 10:16 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(08-12-2025, 10:14 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Didn't see any of the match. All I've learned tonight is that Lurk is going to bore the pants off us all season long by telling us what Mason has done wrong. If we win the Champ it will be by too small a margin for Lurk.

I would read my thread from the weekend where I praised much of the work we did. The same as tonight, some patterns of play looked really good, we looked well drilled, set up and coached. 

I just happen to think that his subs in both his games have been wrong. But just so I know, are we meant to pass comment on the bad bits and the good bits, or just the good?

It's the air of authority with which you deliver your judgements, mate. It's wearing thin. "He shouldn't make pub league subs" isn't the kind of punditry that informs anyone of anything. Do you not think we could see half a dozen games or so before getting too deeply into forensic examination of Ryan Mason's credibility?

"...but won't overly concern myself with until, like I said on my thoughts Fred at the weekend, we have 10 or so games to really see what his game management tendancies are."

That's from a reply to Dekka on another fred, Chesh. I compete agree there's not much cause for concern at this point and after Mowbray it's vastly improved. 

Not sure what you mean by an air of authority? If you mean I think I know what I am talking about, then yes, I do. But in my defence I always try and back it up with logic and facts, rather than hyperbole and emotion after a game.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#33
Strange that you ignored Chesh’s criticisms of your analyses only to absolutely nail them with the above post.
Reply
#34
(08-12-2025, 10:58 PM)Brentbaggie Wrote: Strange that you ignored Chesh’s criticisms of your analyses only to absolutely nail them with the above post.

TBF I have replied to Chesh above, BB.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#35
I'm blaming Mason, he has had weeks to review games from last season and should be fully aware of which players are not up to it. Wildsmith and Wallace IMO fall directly into the are no longer worthy of a place in the team. And if you then go ahead and select them, you know what to expect.
Either way it all comes down to the manager. The idea he needs to learn is beyond me, only those who don't do the background work make stupid decisions and pay the price.
Reply
#36
I'd like to think Mason has self belief in his managerial ability and believes he can get more out of players than previous management. I'm sure he would have viewed hours of footage from last season to get a feel for players, their strengths and weaknesses, and how they generally go about playing, but I'm also sure he wants to see how they fit into his style and judge them from what he sees in person rather than video footage from a different system under a different manager.

It's ridiculous to moan at Mason for having a look at the likes of Wildsmith, Wallace, any other 'fringe' player, in a pretty meaningless game.

In terms of Wallace. He didn't have the best season last year, admittedly, but I'm not writing him off on the basis of the first week of the season! Let's let the players get up to speed and into the new season before judging them!
Reply
#37
(08-12-2025, 10:49 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: What we learned today;

We still have a problem finding a balanced midfield - what ever the pairing we are relying on Mowatt to do both jobs. We need him to dictate tempo and get us playing from deep, but we also need him to drive forward, try and pick passes and offer a goal threat. Even with 60%+ possession in the first 65 mins we couldn't break lines enough to create good clear cut chances.

Campbell will be fine. Offered real penetration with both his passing and ball carrying at times. Perhaps needs to work on being more dominant defensively but he gave me Temu Vini Kompany vibes. Lots of potential to work with.

Taylor isn't good enough and needs to play regular football for a number of years to get there. Too flat footed, poor body shape when defending and painfully slow so can't make up for it. Got caught out three times with balls over Williams head that he didn't read and didn't have the pace to recover. Luckily they weren't punished.

We need 1 or two, ball carrying/in behind, attacking threats. We have let go of Grady and not replaced him and we were already short in that area last year.

We have a good player on our hands in Heggebo, who seems to be striking up a good relationship with Price.

We need to get players closer to our widemen when we get the ball out to them, this has been an issue for a while. And I think stems from the lack of offensive off the ball running from our fullbacks. They either need to get within 10/15 yards on inside to support with quick one twos. Or they need to go on the overlap. Ours seems to do neither, enough.

The team looks really well drilled off the ball, nice and compact, narrow and aggressive. But far too static when we get in possession. Lots to work on..

(08-12-2025, 10:41 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(08-12-2025, 10:16 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(08-12-2025, 10:14 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Didn't see any of the match. All I've learned tonight is that Lurk is going to bore the pants off us all season long by telling us what Mason has done wrong. If we win the Champ it will be by too small a margin for Lurk.

I would read my thread from the weekend where I praised much of the work we did. The same as tonight, some patterns of play looked really good, we looked well drilled, set up and coached. 

I just happen to think that his subs in both his games have been wrong. But just so I know, are we meant to pass comment on the bad bits and the good bits, or just the good?

It's the air of authority with which you deliver your judgements, mate. It's wearing thin. "He shouldn't make pub league subs" isn't the kind of punditry that informs anyone of anything. Do you not think we could see half a dozen games or so before getting too deeply into forensic examination of Ryan Mason's credibility?

"...but won't overly concern myself with until, like I said on my thoughts Fred at the weekend, we have 10 or so games to really see what his game management tendancies are."

That's from a reply to Dekka on another fred, Chesh. I compete agree there's not much cause for concern at this point and after Mowbray it's vastly improved. 

Not sure what you mean by an air of authority? If you mean I think I know what I am talking about, then yes, I do. But in my defence I always try and back it up with logic and facts, rather than hyperbole and emotion after a game.

Excellent post Lurker. 

One of the positives for me against Blackburn was how many bodies we had going forward compared to under CC, we had options for a progressive pass, but I completely agree that our biggest problem currently is the lack of someone breaking from the midfield two and how easy it is to shut down our wide options due to a lack of fullback support.

I think we need 3 more first team signings to make a concerted push for the top 6… a LB, MC and a pacy inside forward.
Reply
#38
We still need that midfielder to drive forward from deep, something we've lacked for a while.

I don't get the criticism of Taylor too much tbf, still looked more assured than Ajayi ever did, for 4th choice, that's fine for now.
Reply
#39
I can't help but feel some people are all too eager for Mason to fail and are waiting to stick the knife in at what they perceive as the slightest mistake.

I'm sure that's not the intention, but that's how a number of posters are coming across, and how I'm interpreting their posts. I could be completely way off.
Reply
#40
Tbf Josh, that's just football fans. Never coached a day in their lives, even those that have played generally never understood the tactical side of the game much, but they know exactly what the manager / head coach should have done every time.

It's part of football and always has been, else this place wouldn't exist.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)