Derby Water Buffalo Cup Fred
(08-12-2025, 09:31 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(08-12-2025, 09:27 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(08-12-2025, 09:17 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Out of interest for those complaining about subs?

You're the manager, this is an unimportant game, winning, player data shows key players showing fatigue with a league game Saturday, who do you bring on to replace them from our bench, since medical will go nuts if you don't, and if you lose Saturday due to players being tired, the board will go mad.

(Copied from the other Fred)

There was plenty that could have been done, but he just went like for like, but altered the balance to a more defensive line up. 

He could have protected his players that played the weekend and still added an extra defender. 

Price, Fellows, and Heggebo - off. 
Maja, Grant and Phillips - On

Wildsmith
Williams Taylor Phillips Campbell Styles
Diakite Mowatt
MJ Maja Grant

Tasked the front three to stay narrow but high. That makes us more solid whilst still giving us options up the pitch. 

What we ended up with was. 

Wildsmith
Williams Taylor Campbell Styles
Jed Diakite Molumby Mowatt Grant
Maja

No more solid but with much less threat.

Have the team practiced in that 5-2-3?

Was there any early indication we needed to, Maja nearly scored after coming on for example.

We tired, subs weakened us because the players were weaker generally, they felt they had a chance since they managed to still only be one goal down, and even then, they needed a fluke from a free kick helped by a disaster of a goalkeeper to score.

Taylor made a silly tackle, won't be first or last time, seen many defenders give that foul away, Evans, Gmac etc included, keeper should save it.

He seemed comfortable doing it on Saturday. But a 5-4-1 which again wasn't balanced. 

If they haven't practiced a different shape, for periods of games where we are leading but need to still offer an offensive threat. I really would be concerned. I very much doubt that's the case though. 

But my reply was what I would have done. As was asked in this case.

P.s. still don't agree on the keeper. It's a postage stamp jobby.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
Is it what you'd have done at the time or with hindsight? Something we're all very guilty of.

Oh, my group chat with coaches, all saying Wildsmith would be getting a bollocking for that goal, absolutely should save it every time.
Reply
(08-12-2025, 09:32 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(08-12-2025, 09:27 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: There is some nonsense being written on here to needlessly criticise the manager (waves at Lurker). We lost simply because they scored from one chance they created due to a rash challenge (he did get the ball as well as man tbf) and a keeper who’s never being good enough. It has nothing to do with the subs, for example Maja could have scored five mins after coming on. If you want to flip the argument if it has any merit whatsoever the first eleven should have scored more goals given our dominance but failed to.

Annoying as the result is, we played well and there were numerous positives to take from the game. These types of results happen.

I just say it how I see it. Always do. 

Not saying he's a duff manager. Or should get hung drawn and quartered. 

But in 2 games, he's made similar subs, at similar times, under similar circumstances and I think it's made us have to defend for more minutes than we necessarily should have. He needs to show abit more tactical nous than just like for like, but more defensive players when trying to see a game out.

I think you’re talking bollocks (saying it as I see it) this had fug all to do with subs, it was a daft challenge and poor keeping and a very good strike. They had one shot on goal all match but just after we scored they could have equalised with all your favourite attacking players on. 

In short needless, flawed argument that looks like you’re criticising the manager for pretty much no reason. If you had done similar criticism when CC regularly made numerous subs that invariably weakened us each match then I would have more sympathy for your argument. This just seems churlish.
Reply
(08-12-2025, 09:37 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Is it what you'd have done at the time or with hindsight? Something we're all very guilty of.

Oh, my group chat with coaches, all saying Wildsmith would be getting a bollocking for that goal, absolutely should save it every time.

Absolutely... when defending the first thing you need to do if sort out who is going to offer you a chance to hurt the opposition on transition if you're changing the balance of the team to see a game out. 

You don't have to do more attacking. But the required balance and skillset of the players on the pitch have to align. They didn't tonight, not did they on Saturday. 

I am not overly concerned and really want Mason to do well, as I like how he talks and the experience he has at a young age. I just want to see better in game decisions.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
Maja had a golden chance saved last 10 minutes, Jed blazed over from the edge of the box at a 3 on 2. It was not the subs that cost us, it was the only shot Derby had (and based on what I saw from the Brummie and the reaction on here Wildsmith shit the bed) and 3 shit penalties. We deserved to win that.
Reply
(08-12-2025, 09:42 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Maja had a golden chance saved last 10 minutes, Jed blazed over from the edge of the box at a 3 on 2. It was not the subs that cost us, it was the only shot Derby had (and based on what I saw from the Brummie and the reaction on here Wildsmith shit the bed) and 3 shit penalties. We deserved to win that.

Exactly… but let’s make it the manager ‘in game management’.
Reply
(08-12-2025, 09:33 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(08-12-2025, 09:31 PM)Jack Halford Wrote: On the subs, Johnston didn’t play Saturday and had plenty of running left in him.

Mulumby looked to be playing as a ten so I’d have swapped for Diakite and Whitwell or Deeming for Price.

I’d have brought Phillips on as well just for his organisation.

Wallace should have stayed on the bench.

Taylor makes one mistake and couldn’t tell if he played the ball.

Frustrating as we exit at round one again.

Tonight was so Albion though.
 
We don't know that, the coaches have that data, Johnston isn't the most athletic and stamina has been an issue for him throughout his career.

Was never an issue for our old poster Big John Holmes
Reply
Not another Wildsmith error, surely? I've just got back from the Yeltz, so haven't actually seen any of the cup game.

I'm not disappointed we're out, however, it's frustrating that we put a strong team out and still lost.
Reply
(08-12-2025, 09:33 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(08-12-2025, 09:31 PM)Jack Halford Wrote: On the subs, Johnston didn’t play Saturday and had plenty of running left in him.

Mulumby looked to be playing as a ten so I’d have swapped for Diakite and Whitwell or Deeming for Price.

I’d have brought Phillips on as well just for his organisation.

Wallace should have stayed on the bench.

Taylor makes one mistake and couldn’t tell if he played the ball.

Frustrating as we exit at round one again.

Tonight was so Albion though.
 
We don't know that, the coaches have that data, Johnston isn't the most athletic and stamina has been an issue for him throughout his career.

Also if you’re thinking of using him on Saturday then why keep him on any longer than necessary?
Reply
(08-12-2025, 09:37 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(08-12-2025, 09:32 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(08-12-2025, 09:27 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: There is some nonsense being written on here to needlessly criticise the manager (waves at Lurker). We lost simply because they scored from one chance they created due to a rash challenge (he did get the ball as well as man tbf) and a keeper who’s never being good enough. It has nothing to do with the subs, for example Maja could have scored five mins after coming on. If you want to flip the argument if it has any merit whatsoever the first eleven should have scored more goals given our dominance but failed to.

Annoying as the result is, we played well and there were numerous positives to take from the game. These types of results happen.

I just say it how I see it. Always do. 

Not saying he's a duff manager. Or should get hung drawn and quartered. 

But in 2 games, he's made similar subs, at similar times, under similar circumstances and I think it's made us have to defend for more minutes than we necessarily should have. He needs to show abit more tactical nous than just like for like, but more defensive players when trying to see a game out.

I think you’re talking bollocks (saying it as I see it) this had fug all to do with subs, it was a daft challenge and poor keeping and a very good strike. They had one shot on goal all match but just after we scored they could have equalised with all your favourite attacking players on. 

In short needless, flawed argument that looks like you’re criticising the manager for pretty much no reason. If you had done similar criticism when CC regularly made numerous subs that invariably weakened us each match then I would have more sympathy for your argument. This just seems churlish.

That's rich coming from you Dekka, but let me humour you anyway. 

Firstly if you you want to read back over any of my match thoughts during CC's reign there were plenty of times I called out poor decisions. 

But more to the point, you are perfectly happy with the decisions because you are, by your own admission a fan of pragmatic football and you probably see defensive subs when trying to defend as the right thing. That's fine. But I don't. I always think you need a balance to a team, a balance that we have often struggled to find, but the last 2 games have followed the same pattern. A pattern I don't subscribe to, but won't overly concerned myself with until, like I said on my thoughts Fred at the weekend, we have 10 or so games to really see what his game management tendancies are. 

You seem hell bent on making it seem I don't rate the manager. Where all I am doing is saying what I see in the game. Peculiar, pal.
"IMO of course..."
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)