Derby Water Buffalo Cup Fred
(08-12-2025, 09:09 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(08-12-2025, 09:08 PM)Peachy Wrote: On holiday and just catching up on the game. Can someone explain their equaliser. Seen mention of a Wildsmith cock up and a silly foul by Taylor and trying to work out what happened! Was that both the same incident?

Yeh same incident. When you see the goal back you'll see it was nowt to do with Wildsmith though, pal. 

It's just easier to blame him.

Agree. I'm not defending Wildsmith.. he's a poor keeper but spacegoating a hobby for some on here.
Reply
(08-12-2025, 09:17 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Out of interest for those complaining about subs?

You're the manager, this is an unimportant game, winning, player data shows key players showing fatigue with a league game Saturday, who do you bring on to replace them from our bench, since medical will go nuts if you don't, and if you lose Saturday due to players being tired, the board will go mad.

I had no issue with the team nor the subs. I think we played well. 20 shots v 6 tells the story. It's football - and it's fuggin' Derby.
Reply
(08-12-2025, 09:15 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(08-12-2025, 09:09 PM)wbamitch Wrote:
(08-12-2025, 09:03 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(08-12-2025, 08:47 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(08-12-2025, 08:45 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Fwiw. That's not on Wildsmith. Its shit defending from Caleb Taylor who for most the night has been too slow to get across to balls played behind Williams. Looked fine when not under pressure, but doesn't position himself well enough to get around his lack of pace.

The lads ain't good enough sadly. Might do a GMac, but that will be a good decade away. Needs to move on and play every game at a lower level.

What are you on about, no one scores direct freekicks from there. No one.

I agree. It was a 1/500 strike. That was perfectly curled into the postage stamp of the net when the keeper would never expect anybody to pull off that execution and be focussing on a crossed delivery. 

The issue was the crap defending that led to the free kick. Oh and the substitutions removing all our attacking threat again which allowed Derby to pile on and not really worry about what was coming back.

Re the subs, Molumby for Price is a defensive sub perhaps but all the others were like for like, no? Maja, Grant and Wallace are all forwards

Grant and Wallace are both more grafters rather than an attacking threat. Maja is a deep lying forward and Molumby is a grafting midfielder. 

So we went from Price, Fellows and MJ, threatening the goal and running in behind as it their natural game. To Jed, Molumby and Grant grafting but offering no attacking threat on transition. 

Heggebo is a forward that presses and stretches the back line. Maja is a player that come towards the play. 

So we went from players who want to run forward to players who want to defend and support on transition. It's about the balance of the team.

That may all be true but I’m not sure what else he could have done tonight, those are the options unfortunately. Cole could have come on but building Maja’s minutes is arguably more important. I don’t really want Grant or Wallace coming on either ideally but that’s a squad issue not something to dig Mason out for. I do agree with you about them being overly defensive on Saturday but it worked thankfully
Reply
(08-12-2025, 09:17 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Out of interest for those complaining about subs?

You're the manager, this is an unimportant game, winning, player data shows key players showing fatigue with a league game Saturday, who do you bring on to replace them from our bench, since medical will go nuts if you don't, and if you lose Saturday due to players being tired, the board will go mad.

(Copied from the other Fred)

There was plenty that could have been done, but he just went like for like, but altered the balance to a more defensive line up. 

He could have protected his players that played the weekend and still added an extra defender. 

Price, Fellows, and Heggebo - off. 
Maja, Grant and Phillips - On

Wildsmith
Williams Taylor Phillips Campbell Styles
Diakite Mowatt
MJ Maja Grant

Tasked the front three to stay narrow but high. That makes us more solid whilst still giving us options up the pitch. 

What we ended up with was. 

Wildsmith
Williams Taylor Campbell Styles
Jed Diakite Molumby Mowatt Grant
Maja

No more solid but with much less threat.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
There is some nonsense being written on here to needlessly criticise the manager (waves at Lurker). We lost simply because they scored from one chance they created due to a rash challenge (he did get the ball as well as man tbf) and a keeper who’s never being good enough. It has nothing to do with the subs, for example Maja could have scored five mins after coming on. If you want to flip the argument if it has any merit whatsoever the first eleven should have scored more goals given our dominance but failed to.

Annoying as the result is, we played well and there were numerous positives to take from the game. These types of results happen.
Reply
(08-12-2025, 09:27 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(08-12-2025, 09:17 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Out of interest for those complaining about subs?

You're the manager, this is an unimportant game, winning, player data shows key players showing fatigue with a league game Saturday, who do you bring on to replace them from our bench, since medical will go nuts if you don't, and if you lose Saturday due to players being tired, the board will go mad.

(Copied from the other Fred)

There was plenty that could have been done, but he just went like for like, but altered the balance to a more defensive line up. 

He could have protected his players that played the weekend and still added an extra defender. 

Price, Fellows, and Heggebo - off. 
Maja, Grant and Phillips - On

Wildsmith
Williams Taylor Phillips Campbell Styles
Diakite Mowatt
MJ Maja Grant

Tasked the front three to stay narrow but high. That makes us more solid whilst still giving us options up the pitch. 

What we ended up with was. 

Wildsmith
Williams Taylor Campbell Styles
Jed Diakite Molumby Mowatt Grant
Maja

No more solid but with much less threat.

Have the team practiced in that 5-2-3?

Was there any early indication we needed to, Maja nearly scored after coming on for example.

We tired, subs weakened us because the players were weaker generally, they felt they had a chance since they managed to still only be one goal down, and even then, they needed a fluke from a free kick helped by a disaster of a goalkeeper to score.

Taylor made a silly tackle, won't be first or last time, seen many defenders give that foul away, Evans, Gmac etc included, keeper should save it.
Reply
On the subs, Johnston didn’t play Saturday and had plenty of running left in him.

Mulumby looked to be playing as a ten so I’d have swapped for Diakite and Whitwell or Deeming for Price.

I’d have brought Phillips on as well just for his organisation.

Wallace should have stayed on the bench.

Taylor makes one mistake and couldn’t tell if he played the ball.

Frustrating as we exit at round one again.

Tonight was so Albion though.
Reply
(08-12-2025, 09:27 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: There is some nonsense being written on here to needlessly criticise the manager (waves at Lurker). We lost simply because they scored from one chance they created due to a rash challenge (he did get the ball as well as man tbf) and a keeper who’s never being good enough. It has nothing to do with the subs, for example Maja could have scored five mins after coming on. If you want to flip the argument if it has any merit whatsoever the first eleven should have scored more goals given our dominance but failed to.

Annoying as the result is, we played well and there were numerous positives to take from the game. These types of results happen.

I just say it how I see it. Always do. 

Not saying he's a duff manager. Or should get hung drawn and quartered. 

But in 2 games, he's made similar subs, at similar times, under similar circumstances and I think it's made us have to defend for more minutes than we necessarily should have. He needs to show abit more tactical nous than just like for like, but more defensive players when trying to see a game out.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
(08-12-2025, 09:31 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(08-12-2025, 09:27 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(08-12-2025, 09:17 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Out of interest for those complaining about subs?

You're the manager, this is an unimportant game, winning, player data shows key players showing fatigue with a league game Saturday, who do you bring on to replace them from our bench, since medical will go nuts if you don't, and if you lose Saturday due to players being tired, the board will go mad.

(Copied from the other Fred)

There was plenty that could have been done, but he just went like for like, but altered the balance to a more defensive line up. 

He could have protected his players that played the weekend and still added an extra defender. 

Price, Fellows, and Heggebo - off. 
Maja, Grant and Phillips - On

Wildsmith
Williams Taylor Phillips Campbell Styles
Diakite Mowatt
MJ Maja Grant

Tasked the front three to stay narrow but high. That makes us more solid whilst still giving us options up the pitch. 

What we ended up with was. 

Wildsmith
Williams Taylor Campbell Styles
Jed Diakite Molumby Mowatt Grant
Maja

No more solid but with much less threat.

Have the team practiced in that 5-2-3?

Was there any early indication we needed to, Maja nearly scored after coming on for example.

We tired, subs weakened us because the players were weaker generally, they felt they had a chance since they managed to still only be one goal down, and even then, they needed a fluke from a free kick helped by a disaster of a goalkeeper to score.

Taylor made a silly tackle, won't be first or last time, seen many defenders give that foul away, Evans, Gmac etc included, keeper should save it.

Agreed this Lurker seems desperate to find the manager at fault.
Reply
(08-12-2025, 09:31 PM)Jack Halford Wrote: On the subs, Johnston didn’t play Saturday and had plenty of running left in him.

Mulumby looked to be playing as a ten so I’d have swapped for Diakite and Whitwell or Deeming for Price.

I’d have brought Phillips on as well just for his organisation.

Wallace should have stayed on the bench.

Taylor makes one mistake and couldn’t tell if he played the ball.

Frustrating as we exit at round one again.

Tonight was so Albion though.
 
We don't know that, the coaches have that data, Johnston isn't the most athletic and stamina has been an issue for him throughout his career.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)