Posts: 11,922
Threads: 798
Joined: Oct 2022
Reputation:
50
I strongly recommend people take a look at the ITV documentary (released yesterday) "Lucy Letby: Beyond Reasonable Doubt" - the team do an incredible job, using international experts, to critique the evidence used to convict Letby. Beyond Reasonable Doubt, indeed...
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Posts: 7,444
Threads: 372
Joined: Sep 2024
Reputation:
33
(08-04-2025, 09:58 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: I strongly recommend people take a look at the ITV documentary (released yesterday) "Lucy Letby: Beyond Reasonable Doubt" - the team do an incredible job, using international experts, to critique the evidence used to convict Letby. Beyond Reasonable Doubt, indeed...
Read a review of that this morning. Will give it a watch.
I still find her reaction (or lack of) when she was arrested as hard to overlook. As well as the weird monitoring of the families of the deceased on Facebook
Posts: 8,079
Threads: 201
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
55
08-04-2025, 10:19 AM
(This post was last modified: 08-04-2025, 01:01 PM by HawkingsHalfpint.)
(08-21-2023, 06:49 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: I just hope she comes out now and admits what she did instead of pleading innocence. I doubt it though. On another note;
The trust itself has many questions to answer and I would really want to see some being held to account.
So do I, if she is indeed guilty. I think all anyone wants (and indeed deserves) is answers and closure, not least the poor parents. This must be doing nothing but prolonging their agony at every turn.
But, from the armchair perspective at least, something about the whole case has never truly stacked up 100%. I’m no expert in the matter at all, and would be happy to be proven wrong, but seem to recall that the evidence against (beyond of course the deaths) didn’t really stretch to much beyond a shift-pattern spreadsheet that can be subjectively interpreted, and expert testimony from a guy who wrote the paper proving the consequences of her actions (a ‘witness’ hardly likely to disagree with his own thesis). Even the incriminating diary can be interpreted in more than one way. So whilst yes - the ‘well, she doesn’t look like a murderer’ trope is absolutely no defence, we still have no motive at all; furthermore doubt in the conviction has indeed been cast (mainly from other experts in the US if I recall). So one does have to wonder if her trial wouldn’t have been such an easy hit had she firstly (and not foolishly, perhaps due to confusion, bewilderment or whatever stupid reason) appointed better defence council and advice, and had it not been quite so convenient for what was a very poorly-run trust needing a scapegoat for this. That, and of course, a good old dollop of trial-by-media. It was all a bit clean and easy.
I’m not saying she didn’t do it. It is just that - following a lot of cost, drama, headlines and I’m sure unbearable pain for the families of the victims - we still have more questions than answers. Part of me also wondered why she didn’t admit it and blame poor training and support, but she didn’t even do that. Perhaps it is one of those unfortunate cases where we will never know, and have to make do with the walks like a duck conviction we have. When all is said and done, she had a chance to prove her innocence, and did so poorly.
Posts: 11,922
Threads: 798
Joined: Oct 2022
Reputation:
50
(08-04-2025, 10:01 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: (08-04-2025, 09:58 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: I strongly recommend people take a look at the ITV documentary (released yesterday) "Lucy Letby: Beyond Reasonable Doubt" - the team do an incredible job, using international experts, to critique the evidence used to convict Letby. Beyond Reasonable Doubt, indeed...
Read a review of that this morning. Will give it a watch.
I still find her reaction (or lack of) when she was arrested as hard to overlook. As well as the weird monitoring of the families of the deceased on Facebook
That, plus Hawks' longer post, above, sums up my views on it. Something is definitely not right with her and she almost certainly shouldn't be in nursing (see also videos of her out dancing and laughing whilst on bail). But the data, clinical evidence, clinical expertise, statistical analysis methods etc just make the conviction too wobbly for my liking. It surely warrants a retrial (not that I know about such legal processes).
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Posts: 70
Threads: 4
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
0
I doubt that she appointed her own defence counsel, and even if she did could not have known in advance that they would turn out to be so ill equipped (shite) in mounting one for her.
The failure to challenge a big-billy-bollocks 'expert' witness, thereby presenting no alternative view to a conclusion he had already decided was evident, demands a retrial by itself.
Posts: 11,922
Threads: 798
Joined: Oct 2022
Reputation:
50
(08-12-2025, 02:32 PM)bayliss Wrote: I doubt that she appointed her own defence counsel, and even if she did could not have known in advance that they would turn out to be so ill equipped (shite) in mounting one for her.
The failure to challenge a big-billy-bollocks 'expert' witness, thereby presenting no alternative view to a conclusion he had already decided was evident, demands a retrial by itself.
Is Roysh. It's got to be pretty hard for someone in that position to be able to determine whether their Barrister is any good.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Posts: 3,594
Threads: 27
Joined: Apr 2019
Reputation:
14
08-12-2025, 03:09 PM
(This post was last modified: 08-12-2025, 03:12 PM by Brentbaggie.)
(08-12-2025, 02:32 PM)bayliss Wrote: I doubt that she appointed her own defence counsel, and even if she did could not have known in advance that they would turn out to be so ill equipped (shite) in mounting one for her.
The failure to challenge a big-billy-bollocks 'expert' witness, thereby presenting no alternative view to a conclusion he had already decided was evident, demands a retrial by itself.
To fail to call expert medical testimony for the Defence, which existed in the shape of Dr Mike Hall, a neonatologist, who attended the whole trial - was to say the least, somewhat strange. That the Prosecution expert witness, Dr Dewi Evans, also a Neonatology expert, changed his mind about the cause of some of the deaths both during and after the trial, is, putting it mildly, some grounds for feeling all was not quite so straightforward as presented.
The idea that anyone can judge a person's guilt by their behaviour is laughable. "There's no art to find the mind's construction in a face" as the great man put it. Killers have seemed sullen, silent, sincere, profound and cleared, only for later evidence to prove them guilty. By the same token innocent men and women have laughed, danced, sung and behaved in a manner quite inappropriate for people accused of the most heinous crimes. Behavioural traits are no guide to innocence or guilt. Evidence is.
I have no idea whether Letby is innocent or guilty. What is clear is that the neonatal ward was a mess. Letby may well have taken advantage of its lax management and organisation to injure and kill babies. It may also be the case that some people were happy for someone to take the blame for what may have been serial failings on the unit. It may simply have been that she did kill a baby/babies and as the programme made clear, if she killed one child it is enough for her conviction to stand. On the other hand she may not.
I think a retrial is in order. It is a horrendous prospect for the families concerned but if there is any possibility that Letby's conviction is "unsafe" it would seem unconscionable to let her remain in prison simply in order to ameliorate the suffering of others.
Posts: 19,719
Threads: 2,734
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
49
Posts: 751
Threads: 8
Joined: Nov 2025
Reputation:
1
Wonder what the context of that is.
Posts: 11,922
Threads: 798
Joined: Oct 2022
Reputation:
50
(04-23-2026, 01:40 PM)AlsoKeithCurlesToePoke Wrote: Wonder what the context of that is.
Absolute speculation on my behalf but I suspect they've been caught out lying to cover up their (alleged) corporate/grand negligence manslaughter they were arrested for back in summer 2025.
Whether that, in itself, indicates a conspiracy against Letby is a stretch even further...
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
|