NI Fund Surplus
#61
(08-10-2025, 11:37 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(08-10-2025, 07:11 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Agree word for word. The irony of people who have their lives founded on what the State has provided them - education, health, cultural capital - but conclude it somehow conspires against them never ceases to amaze me.

Arf. The state couldn’t afford it then and certainly can’t afford it now.

God forbid we ever educate the proles, provide art for the masses or look after those less fortunate.......what sort of Hell would that be?
Reply
#62
(08-10-2025, 01:46 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(08-10-2025, 11:37 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(08-10-2025, 07:11 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Agree word for word. The irony of people who have their lives founded on what the State has provided them - education, health, cultural capital - but conclude it somehow conspires against them never ceases to amaze me.

Arf. The state couldn’t afford it then and certainly can’t afford it now.

God forbid we ever educate the proles, provide art for the masses or look after those less fortunate.......what sort of Hell would that be?

You'd have Proths Aots. Heaven help us.
Reply
#63
I doubt Proth could afford trips to Boston without all the free-at-access services that underpin our society. The lack of humility in recognising how vital they are for individual opportunity and growth is depressing
Reply
#64
Always rely on you all to lean to the extreme. Of course a healthy liberal state should use taxpayers money to fund education, health, welfare, sanitation etc. However unless far more people start contributing at all, and far fewer are incentivised to contribute more (rather than fucking off to Dubai) then yes, we are doomed. That’s not an opinion, it’s a statement of fact.

Reeves knows this. Starmer knows this. Unfortunately most of the PLP did not come into politics to deal with reality. And to be fair, neither did most politicians. This lot are toast after little more than a year.
Reply
#65
And if you want a functioning society without bankrupting the state then replace the vile student loans system by applying a 2.5% Graduate Tax to all earning graduates (including pensioners), incentivise private health insurance rather than taxing it, LVT (obviously), bin the triple lock, institute a single rate of 30% tax relief for pension contributions, institute an insurance system for social care or a one off fee from the existing elderly. Otherwise care costs are taken from wholly unearned increases in housing wealth.

It’s really difficult to break the truth to Boomers & Gen Xers that, by and large, they’ve extracted far more from the system than they’ve ever paid in. To keep what you all feel entitled to will require growth of 3% a year, every year. You can’t have it unless you’re prepared to pay for it.
Reply
#66
(08-10-2025, 10:45 PM)Protheroe Wrote: And if you want a functioning society without bankrupting the state then replace the vile student loans system by applying a 2.5% Graduate Tax to all earning graduates (including pensioners), incentivise private health insurance rather than taxing it, LVT (obviously), bin the triple lock, institute a single rate of 30% tax relief for pension contributions, institute an insurance system for social care or a one off fee from the existing elderly. Otherwise care costs are taken from wholly unearned increases in housing wealth.

It’s really difficult to break the truth to Boomers & Gen Xers that, by and large, they’ve extracted far more from the system than they’ve ever paid in. To keep what you all feel entitled to will require growth of 3% a year, every year. You can’t have it unless you’re prepared to pay for it.

I agree with most of that. Not sure about the Graduate Tax across the board but agree it needs evolving to something not far off that.
Reply
#67
(08-09-2025, 08:13 AM)baggy1 Wrote: I’ve no issue with the ideological position of wealth taxes, my issue is with the practicality of implementing them. In the UK the measurement of house prices, which would make up the majority of the taxable element, is appalling. I’ve just sold a house in Dudley that was valued at £325k by 2 estate agents, it went for £280k. If you are looking at introducing with a threshold of £1M then you are going to have a logistical nightmare in measuring that number of houses. There are 28M houses in the UK of which 16M are privately owned, are you proposing that we have an army of valuers hit the streets? In your references you give examples of Norway (1.7M houses), Switzerland (c.3M), Spain is similar to the UK but effectively refund it to residents and France have reverted to a property tax.

Then you have the position that people with property over a certain value would simply put them into trust to remove them from their personal measurement.

You seem to be having a go at me for disagreeing with you on this by suggesting that I’m looking at it from a political point of view and me wanting to protect the riches that I have stored away somewhere, I’m not, it simply won’t work. BB has added some more insightful points above.

I don't think you are trying to protect your riches, I think you're trying to defend the most unimaginative, scared-of-its-own-shadow government that happens to have a huge majority and 4 years left in government.  You're doing so by hiding behind:  1. It's too difficult 2. it wasn't in the (breached) manifesto 3. Other laws (like Trusts or Non Doms) being in place to get around it.

You would not employ an army of house valuers.  You would rely upon self assessment and AI application of a checks and balance approach to house valuation (Zoopla and Rightmove already have (flawed) valuation systems).  Year 1 - you employ a team to review the houses which appear to be the most undervalued and you publicise EVERY single case that goes to court, making sure you only go to court over the "dead certs" to ensure credibility.  Year 2 - you measure the public response to prosecutions and see the impact the 'fear' creates whilst maintaining the AI and small/medium sized team approach used in Year 1, focusing on the most 'undervalued' houses.  Keep doing that until you achieve a level of tax evasion similar to self assessment and Corporation Tax.

You see, with a bit of guile and a bit of ambition, ANYONE with the political will can create a popular policy whilst raising tax revenue.  You will point to other legislation which prevents this from happening.  My answer to that is simple:  What's the point in being in government if you don't control legislation?
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#68
(08-11-2025, 08:31 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:
(08-09-2025, 08:13 AM)baggy1 Wrote: I’ve no issue with the ideological position of wealth taxes, my issue is with the practicality of implementing them. In the UK the measurement of house prices, which would make up the majority of the taxable element, is appalling. I’ve just sold a house in Dudley that was valued at £325k by 2 estate agents, it went for £280k. If you are looking at introducing with a threshold of £1M then you are going to have a logistical nightmare in measuring that number of houses. There are 28M houses in the UK of which 16M are privately owned, are you proposing that we have an army of valuers hit the streets? In your references you give examples of Norway (1.7M houses), Switzerland (c.3M), Spain is similar to the UK but effectively refund it to residents and France have reverted to a property tax.

Then you have the position that people with property over a certain value would simply put them into trust to remove them from their personal measurement.

You seem to be having a go at me for disagreeing with you on this by suggesting that I’m looking at it from a political point of view and me wanting to protect the riches that I have stored away somewhere, I’m not, it simply won’t work. BB has added some more insightful points above.

I don't think you are trying to protect your riches, I think you're trying to defend the most unimaginative, scared-of-its-own-shadow government that happens to have a huge majority and 4 years left in government.  You're doing so by hiding behind:  1. It's too difficult 2. it wasn't in the (breached) manifesto 3. Other laws (like Trusts or Non Doms) being in place to get around it.

You would not employ an army of house valuers.  You would rely upon self assessment and AI application of a checks and balance approach to house valuation (Zoopla and Rightmove already have (flawed) valuation systems).  Year 1 - you employ a team to review the houses which appear to be the most undervalued and you publicise EVERY single case that goes to court, making sure you only go to court over the "dead certs" to ensure credibility.  Year 2 - you measure the public response to prosecutions and see the impact the 'fear' creates whilst maintaining the AI and small/medium sized team approach used in Year 1, focusing on the most 'undervalued' houses.  Keep doing that until you achieve a level of tax evasion similar to self assessment and Corporation Tax.

You see, with a bit of guile and a bit of ambition, ANYONE with the political will can create a popular policy whilst raising tax revenue.  You will point to other legislation which prevents this from happening.  My answer to that is simple:  What's the point in being in government if you don't control legislation?

What annoys me about B1s and others who do fall into the Centrist Day bracket is they make excuse after excuse that this is too difficult, that’s too expensive, that will harm trust in the government, it’ll upset the ‘wealth creators’ etc, and yet they defend evermore surveillance of those who receive welfare, more means testing, more checks and hardline use of the law on people like unpaid carers, huge IT budgets to delve into people’s bank accounts to find fraud at a minuscule rate compared to those avoiding tax at a much higher level. That’s all perfectly fine, justified, and doable but to rock the boat of the very well off is just too much of a risk and they should be left alone to do as they please, and pretend that they are all scrupulously fair when it comes to tax and the law. 

This is a long winded way to say the are bullies, punching down on the weakest and never up. Making excuses as to why it’s too complicated and expensive for one section of society to be effected by the laws they make whilst hammering another.
Reply
#69
Explaining why we’ve got a government representing what we have ended up with based on the preferences of the voting public (and acting accordingly) is different to what some of us may ideologically prefer if the reality was different. I can’t waste energy raging that we’ve got what we elected
Reply
#70
(08-11-2025, 10:20 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Explaining why we’ve got a government representing what we have ended up with based on the preferences of the voting public (and acting accordingly) is different to what some of us may ideologically prefer if the reality was different. I can’t waste energy raging that we’ve got what we elected

The electorate did not vote for more of the same shite as we have seen for the last 15yrs. Gutless, bullying of the poor, squeezing the middle class and excusing the very rich and connected for fear of them taking their ball home with them. But, but, but it’s too hard Sunak was right we just have yo carry on with his policies…
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: