NI Fund Surplus
#51
I’ve no issue with the ideological position of wealth taxes, my issue is with the practicality of implementing them. In the UK the measurement of house prices, which would make up the majority of the taxable element, is appalling. I’ve just sold a house in Dudley that was valued at £325k by 2 estate agents, it went for £280k. If you are looking at introducing with a threshold of £1M then you are going to have a logistical nightmare in measuring that number of houses. There are 28M houses in the UK of which 16M are privately owned, are you proposing that we have an army of valuers hit the streets? In your references you give examples of Norway (1.7M houses), Switzerland (c.3M), Spain is similar to the UK but effectively refund it to residents and France have reverted to a property tax.

Then you have the position that people with property over a certain value would simply put them into trust to remove them from their personal measurement.

You seem to be having a go at me for disagreeing with you on this by suggesting that I’m looking at it from a political point of view and me wanting to protect the riches that I have stored away somewhere, I’m not, it simply won’t work. BB has added some more insightful points above.
Reply
#52
You’re right, it is difficult, much better to freeze income tax thresholds
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#53
It’s not just difficult it’s impossible with the current infrastructures in place. I’m more than willing to debate if you can keep the childishness out of it. How would you value property, which would be a major part of the tax?
Reply
#54
I’m still chuckling about the idea that the NI surplus should be used to spunk ever more cash at a time when every actuary will tell you that the pensions and benefits bills are already wholly unsustainable.

And that’s before even considering the idiocy of even more wealth taxes or financial transaction taxes on top of those that already exist.

We are doomed I’m afraid. The cloying sense of entitlement to other people’s money will be the death of Britain.
Reply
#55
(08-10-2025, 03:12 AM)Protheroe Wrote: I’m still chuckling about the idea that the NI surplus should be used to spunk ever more cash at a time when every actuary will tell you that the pensions and benefits bills are already wholly unsustainable.

And that’s before even considering the idiocy of even more wealth taxes or financial transaction taxes on top of those that already exist.

We are doomed I’m afraid. The cloying sense of entitlement to other people’s money will be the death of Britain.

Says man who had the fortune of using roads, school, college, I imagine university, the NHS, visited parks, libraries, museums, galleries maybe even a public toilet. Im sure I’ve missed out many other public services that we collectively pay for because it’s not all about him. 

Meanwhile energy, water, transport etc squeeze people’s living standards to breaking point and not a peep of condemnation. 

If you want to know why our society is so divided, mean spirited and only thinks of itself I give you Proth’s last sentence. You didn’t make money through just your own endeavour, no one did.
Reply
#56
Agree word for word. The irony of people who have their lives founded on what the State has provided them - education, health, cultural capital - but conclude it somehow conspires against them never ceases to amaze me.
Reply
#57
"There's no such thing as society"
Proth's heroine.
Reply
#58
(08-10-2025, 07:11 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Agree word for word. The irony of people who have their lives founded on what the State has provided them - education, health, cultural capital - but conclude it somehow conspires against them never ceases to amaze me.

Arf. The state couldn’t afford it then and certainly can’t afford it now.
Reply
#59
(08-10-2025, 11:37 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(08-10-2025, 07:11 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Agree word for word. The irony of people who have their lives founded on what the State has provided them - education, health, cultural capital - but conclude it somehow conspires against them never ceases to amaze me.

Arf. The state couldn’t afford it then and certainly can’t afford it now.

Ooh someone’s come back from the US full of shit.
Reply
#60
Hagley and the US is a potent combination for delusions of self importance.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)