Villa FFP
#61
Of course, if you get promoted you can buy your ground back with your new premier league cash influx - ready to re-use once you get relegated.

But we all know with the nature of business and people generally, this won't happen and it will be an asset of the club that is forever lost

So then what will happen?

Some other smart guy, will figure out another idea to get a one-off cash injection by leasebacking some other asset.

Pretty soon, the 'benefactors' will own the ground, image-rights, the next 100 years in gate receipts, the players contracts and just about everything else that could possibly earn money or be sold.
Once that's done, the club has absoluteley no chance of recovering and is completely at the whim of the owner.
Inevitably, every other club owner will run enthusiastically down this path justifying it by saying they have to do it to compete.

It's ironic that financial fair play rules are pushing clubs to ever more reliance on their wealthy owners.
Reply
#62
(06-04-2019, 08:38 AM)fuzzbox Wrote: Of course, if you get promoted you can buy your ground back with your new premier league cash influx - ready to re-use once you get relegated.

But we all know with the nature of business and people generally, this won't happen and it will be an asset of the club that is forever lost

So then what will happen?

Some other smart guy, will figure out another idea to get a one-off cash injection by leasebacking some other asset.

Pretty soon, the 'benefactors' will own the ground, image-rights, the next 100 years in gate receipts, the players contracts and just about everything else that could possibly earn money or be sold.
Once that's done, the club has absoluteley no chance of recovering and is completely at the whim of the owner.
Inevitably, every other club owner will run enthusiastically down this path justifying it by saying they have to do it to compete.

It's ironic that financial fair play rules are pushing clubs to ever more reliance on their wealthy owners.

Any model which leads to football clubs not even owning their own stadia is a mess and a shambles.
Reply
#63
tbh. I think all this talk about FFP is now irrelevant.

Here's what I believe happened. 

Villa were about to go bust. Their chairman couldn't get his money out of China to prop it up or re-invest. He wanted to, but he couldn't. (The same thing happened to our original Chinese buyers.)

They then found a buyer who was willing to take it off his hands. Crucially though, at this point, they hadn't put any serious money or time in and so unlike Birmingham and all the others, they were very happy to walk away if they didn't get assurances. If they did the club would have folded. Personally, I don't think this would have been a bluff and more importantly, neither did the league. This would have been a huge embarrassment, not to mention a tonne of extra work and damage limitation so they understandably capitulated. After all, FFP is supposed to safeguard clubs, not to kill them!  

Now every club knows the leagues real position, so regardless of rules or contracts, everything changes
Reply
#64
Our financials appear to be sound although some amazing gaps continue to show at times. As our romoured £15 m bid for Dack indicating we had access to £15 mil in one way shape or form. This was quickly followed by the sale of Chadli (£10m) that should have shown as £25 mil in the transfer bucket. Yet Xmas came and we had to get a loan from Barclay's secured against put EFL prize money at the end of the season. Realistically the £25 mil transfer bucket vanished and the loan we had to buy players has also vanished and our prize money will have to pay the Barclay's loan. So no money for summer transfers unless we sell first. Also what happened to the £10 mil promotion bonus - lots of numbers, but no clear evidence of where these huge funds are going or gone. Interested to see if I'm the only one who is suspicious?
Reply
#65
You're assuming that the £15m for Dack was all upfront with that post.
Reply
#66
(06-04-2019, 11:22 AM)baggy1 Wrote: You're assuming that the £15m for Dack was all upfront with that post.

Very glad we didn't buy him, his value has dropped hugely since then.
Reply
#67
(06-04-2019, 11:22 AM)baggy1 Wrote: You're assuming that the £15m for Dack was all upfront with that post.

That's not what I said at all, I said someway shape or form. That could be upfront more likely installments. I don't know but it was available.
Reply
#68
This assumes that just because we have money in budget for a year then we have to spend it. The plan seems to have been to spend it on the right players if they were available, instead we strengthened our team with loans and I actually don't have much of a problem with the business we did last season. We kept our best players and strengthened with some good loan players. The quality of player wasn't the reason for us not going up.

I also don't have a problem with us not really knowing how much there is to spend. This is better than laying all our cards on the table for other clubs to capitalise on knowing our financial position.

The problem will come if at the end of the window we have a considerably weaker team than at the end of this season and in my opinion this begins with the manager. Employing Hughton shows an intent to want to get back to the Premier League and this will attract players.

Hiring Appy sends a very different message
Reply
#69
(06-04-2019, 11:39 AM)Sliced Wrote: This assumes that just because we have money in budget for a year then we have to spend it. The plan seems to have been to spend it on the right players if they were available, instead we strengthened our team with loans and I actually don't have much of a problem with the business we did last season. We kept our best players and strengthened with some good loan players. The quality of player wasn't the reason for us not going up.

I also don't have a problem with us not really knowing how much there is to spend. This is better than laying all our cards on the table for other clubs to capitalise on knowing our financial position.

The problem will come if at the end of the window we have a considerably weaker team than at the end of this season and in my opinion this begins with the manager. Employing Hughton shows an intent to want to get back to the Premier League and this will attract players.

Hiring Appy sends a very different message

Well thought out post, although personally I certainly wasn't happy with the loans. IMO we should have captured a few players looking at where we are now and having 6 loans I would have thought we would have tried to sign maybe one or two of them. But that's just me. I don't see us borrowing money from Barclay's if we had money in the bank either?
Reply
#70
(06-04-2019, 09:00 AM)fuzzbox Wrote: tbh. I think all this talk about FFP is now irrelevant.

Here's what I believe happened. 

Villa were about to go bust. Their chairman couldn't get his money out of China to prop it up or re-invest. He wanted to, but he couldn't. (The same thing happened to our original Chinese buyers.)

They then found a buyer who was willing to take it off his hands. Crucially though, at this point, they hadn't put any serious money or time in and so unlike Birmingham and all the others, they were very happy to walk away if they didn't get assurances. If they did the club would have folded. Personally, I don't think this would have been a bluff and more importantly, neither did the league. This would have been a huge embarrassment, not to mention a tonne of extra work and damage limitation so they understandably capitulated. After all, FFP is supposed to safeguard clubs, not to kill them!  

Now every club knows the leagues real position, so regardless of rules or contracts, everything changes

Never really been relevant. Lots of bluster by the suits within the game and posters on here. 

Move on
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: