England v India Test Series!!..
(08-04-2025, 09:36 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(08-04-2025, 08:44 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: I'm not having it that you can't criticise Brook for doing that in that moment. It's the equivalent of being 2-0 up with 20mins remaining, the best sides will manage the game, keep the ball not give the opponent a sniff. What you don't do is go gung-ho and gift them a goal to get them back in the game, it doesn't matter how well you've played until that point. The great Australian sides didn't give you an inch, this England team does it all too often. All we're asking is to read the room sometimes.

Bethell should be no where near the England team until he's gone back to Warks, decided where he wants to bat and scored some runs there. We're picking blokes to bat at three in test cricket and he's never made a century in any format of the game. It's a bonker selection, but fortunately he has age on his side and I'm sure he'll come again.

Crawley and Pope are the two weak links in this side at present. Crawley, oddly, appears to be more valuable to the team. His partnership with Duckett is probably the best in the game at the top of the order, so he's a shoe-in for the coming years I'd imagine. Pope has now had 60 tests, another series where he's averaged mid-30s, in a position that is the most important in your line up. We've had Jordan Cox around the squad, likewise lots of noise about James Rew but I'm not sure either are ready for first drop in test cricket yet. Only other option is to pick a third opener, I've mentioned Tom Haines from Sussex a few times and think he could be an option. Do you go back to a Haseeb Hameed who's scored 1100 runs at 80 this season? Pope's winter returns will be under much scrutiny.

What you're asking for is for Brook to change how he plays, which is very unorthodox. Stepping out of his crease to disrupt the bowlers lengths is one of his stock shots, it gets him a helluva lot of runs. Root does something similar but changes his starting crease position rather move as ball is bowled. 

It gets Brook a lot of runs, but as with most of his dismissals, if the unorthodox doesn't come off, it looks ugly and reckless.

He isn't going to,  and nor should he, try and play a different game to his natural game when on top as we were at that time.

I'm not and I don't want to detract from what was a great innings.

What I am asking of a test cricketer was to look at the situation; we were cruising, he'd taken eight already from the over, 15mins to tea, he just doesn't need to charge a bowler in that instance. Fair enough if he'd faced four dots but he'd taken the runs he needed from the over. In that moment, there was nothing wrong with blocking a few balls. Being so dogmatic is what will prevent this England side from being truly great, if Brook doesn't get out there we'd have won this game before the rain came yesterday.
Reply
I'm kind of with Ted here. I absolutely agree that the way Brook (and the rest) play without fear is what gets them lots of runs and sometimes you have to take the rough with the smooth. However, I don't think it should be beyond a professional Test cricketer to adapt the way they play, even slightly, to accommodate the match situation. I said in a previous post that Duckett playing scoops and high risk shots was correct according the match situation at the start of this innings as it put the Indian bowlers off their length so I'm not just anti-bazball. Similarly with Brook, having played his high risk shots and got his reward, with less than 100 to go and loads of time it should've been within his gift to realise that they could quietly accumulate the game away from India and that still going for big shots was an unnecessary risk.
Reply
So what you are both saying is that when on top and scoring fairly freely batting in his unorthodox way, he should suddenly change the way he bats?
Reply
Duckett was superb, and I don't mind aggressive play in that situation. It's exactly what was needed, and it worked.

However, what I would say is that the ball before his wicket, he went for a scoop and got it all wrong. The next ball he tried it again, and got out. It just looks silly. I understand that if it came off and he went onto to get a bigger total we'd all be saying how brave it was. But in that situation, why couldn't you reset yourself and just play each ball on its merit? Or even see out the next few deliveries, get some confidence and rhythm back, and then go back to being ultra aggressive. It doesn't have to be all or nothing. Test match cricket is a long game, there's plenty of time to play yourself in, attack, go more conservative, attack again. There's no rush. 

If he got out first scoop I wouldn't have an issue, it's how he attempted it the very next ball that frustrated me.

I don't see the issue with praising a players innings, and how they've gone about it, like Duckett, but why you can't also criticise how they got out? The two aren't linked. As has been said, read the room. Think about the match situation.
Reply
Controversial but I'd send Woakes in next.
Reply
(08-04-2025, 09:56 AM)richbaggie Wrote: So what you are both saying is that when on top and scoring fairly freely batting in his unorthodox way, he should suddenly change the way he bats?

Jesus wept. I'm saying that in order to win the match he should engage his brain and realise he didn't need to hit every ball for six.

He's also not that unorthodox, his best shots were conventional ones. I said in my first post on it that if they keep floating up half-volleys he should keep whacking them, I wouldn't even have minded if he'd have nicked off doing that. But there was no need whatsoever to do what he did. 

Don't give the opposition a sniff, that should be the way he bats. Don't know how many times it needs saying but the best sides in all sports don't do things like that. You'd hope in private, given that we've been a bit more sensible this summer, that someone would say that perhaps it wasn't his best idea.
Reply
(08-04-2025, 10:01 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(08-04-2025, 09:56 AM)richbaggie Wrote: So what you are both saying is that when on top and scoring fairly freely batting in his unorthodox way, he should suddenly change the way he bats?

Jesus wept. I'm saying that in order to win the match he should engage his brain and realise he didn't need to hit every ball for six.

He's also not that unorthodox, his best shots were conventional ones. I said in my first post on it that if they keep floating up half-volleys he should keep whacking them, I wouldn't even have minded if he'd have nicked off doing that. But there was no need whatsoever to do what he did. 

Don't give the opposition a sniff, that should be the way he bats. Don't know how many times it needs saying but the best sides in all sports don't do things like that. You'd hope in private, given that we've been a bit more sensible this summer, that someone would say that perhaps it wasn't his best idea.

Brook isnt unorthodox? 
Crikey.
Reply
(08-04-2025, 09:56 AM)richbaggie Wrote: So what you are both saying is that when on top and scoring fairly freely batting in his unorthodox way, he should suddenly change the way he bats?

Yes. You've couched that as if it's something both controversial and difficult to do but I really don't think it is. Yes we were on top and yes he was scoring but the risk of a wicket is also commensurately higher. When the situation changes ie the need for quick runs diminished and keeping a wicket becomes more important then you change it up. A Test cricketer should have more than one gear.
Reply
(08-04-2025, 10:04 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(08-04-2025, 10:01 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(08-04-2025, 09:56 AM)richbaggie Wrote: So what you are both saying is that when on top and scoring fairly freely batting in his unorthodox way, he should suddenly change the way he bats?

Jesus wept. I'm saying that in order to win the match he should engage his brain and realise he didn't need to hit every ball for six.

He's also not that unorthodox, his best shots were conventional ones. I said in my first post on it that if they keep floating up half-volleys he should keep whacking them, I wouldn't even have minded if he'd have nicked off doing that. But there was no need whatsoever to do what he did. 

Don't give the opposition a sniff, that should be the way he bats. Don't know how many times it needs saying but the best sides in all sports don't do things like that. You'd hope in private, given that we've been a bit more sensible this summer, that someone would say that perhaps it wasn't his best idea.

Brook isnt unorthodox? 
Crikey.

His best shots yesterday that brought him the most runs were cover drives and pulls. Can't get more conventional than that.
Reply
That's one of the worst pieces of batting I've ever seen.
"IMO of course..."
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)