England v India Test Series!!..
I thought exactly the same AB. Gets out doing the same thing that’s just got him 111. Then people moan.
Reply
(08-04-2025, 07:34 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(08-03-2025, 03:49 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Siraj gets some harsh stick. Great competitor and character. Test cricket is better with him playing in it.

This. Siraj has the exact right level of competitiveness and edge, and doesn't ever stray across the line, like for example Deep did in the first innings.

I'm still amazed people are critising the way Brook got out. He just got 111 playing that way. The entire point of Bazball is to instill into these players that it's okay to play the attacking shots, you won't get told off if you get out to them. This allows them to be mentally free to play aggressively and score runs. Exactly like Brook did and does consistently. He averages 56.5. "Oh but if he played a bit more conservatively, he could score even more" - no, because he wouldn't be playing the aggressive attacking shots as much, and would be far more likely to get out.

Bethell has played next to no cricket because he has been with the England team for the whole series (I believe). So, obviously he's going to look completely rusty. As soon as he wasn't picked in the XI for the first four Tests, he should've been sent back to Warks to get some game time preparing him. So I'm not surprised he struggled.

Whilst the stoppage last night clearly favours England heavily, it was obviously the wrong call. Get the game finished at 7pm-ish, when many more people can watch and the stands were full. Now, England can get the heavy roller on the pitch and probably deaden it a bit to see them over the line before the pitch livens up again.

Good post. It amazes me too about Brooke. Posted similar last week. He's got the 6th highest batting averages in the history of English test cricket so far,  and he's got there playing the exact way he played yesterday. When it works people call him a genius, when he gets out trying to play the same shots, he's called brainless. Same goes for Duckett too.  It all smacks of yes, but what have the Romans ever done for us.

Whilst I enjoy the style of cricket under Stokes and McCullum, they frustrate me with their selection policy. Picking Bethel so late in the summer ( I'd have picked him from the 1st test ahead of Pope and then backed him) has left him totally undercooked when eventually picked. Rehan Ahmed is in ridiculously good form and will go to the Ashes, why not pick him instead? Picking Overton was just bizarre as well.
Reply
(08-04-2025, 08:05 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(08-04-2025, 07:34 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(08-03-2025, 03:49 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Siraj gets some harsh stick. Great competitor and character. Test cricket is better with him playing in it.

This. Siraj has the exact right level of competitiveness and edge, and doesn't ever stray across the line, like for example Deep did in the first innings.

I'm still amazed people are critising the way Brook got out. He just got 111 playing that way. The entire point of Bazball is to instill into these players that it's okay to play the attacking shots, you won't get told off if you get out to them. This allows them to be mentally free to play aggressively and score runs. Exactly like Brook did and does consistently. He averages 56.5. "Oh but if he played a bit more conservatively, he could score even more" - no, because he wouldn't be playing the aggressive attacking shots as much, and would be far more likely to get out.

Bethell has played next to no cricket because he has been with the England team for the whole series (I believe). So, obviously he's going to look completely rusty. As soon as he wasn't picked in the XI for the first four Tests, he should've been sent back to Warks to get some game time preparing him. So I'm not surprised he struggled.

Whilst the stoppage last night clearly favours England heavily, it was obviously the wrong call. Get the game finished at 7pm-ish, when many more people can watch and the stands were full. Now, England can get the heavy roller on the pitch and probably deaden it a bit to see them over the line before the pitch livens up again.

Good post. It amazes me too about Brooke. Posted similar last week. He's got the 6th highest batting averages in the history of English test cricket so far,  and he's got there playing the exact way he played yesterday. When it works people call him a genius, when he gets out trying to play the same shots, he's called brainless. Same goes for Duckett too.  It all smacks of yes, but what have the Romans ever done for us.

Whilst I enjoy the style of cricket under Stokes and McCullum, they frustrate me with their selection policy. Picking Bethel so late in the summer ( I'd have picked him from the 1st test ahead of Pope and then backed him) has left him totally undercooked when eventually picked. Rehan Ahmed is in ridiculously good form and will go to the Ashes, why not pick him instead? Picking Overton was just bizarre as well.

Absolutely valid. I do think Bethell should've been in instead of Pope, Pope's 2nd innings record has been spoken about enough. But he's VC, he ain't getting dropped.

The Overton selection is a complete joke. If you want a bowling all rounder, pick Sam Curran? He's actually got wickets and runs this season. I don't mind so much Rehan not being picked yet as he's still very young, and it may be better for him to continue as he is for the moment.
Reply
Overton looks like a village cricketer who has won a raffle to play.
Reply
I'm not having it that you can't criticise Brook for doing that in that moment. It's the equivalent of being 2-0 up with 20mins remaining, the best sides will manage the game, keep the ball not give the opponent a sniff. What you don't do is go gung-ho and gift them a goal to get them back in the game, it doesn't matter how well you've played until that point. The great Australian sides didn't give you an inch, this England team does it all too often. All we're asking is to read the room sometimes.

Bethell should be no where near the England team until he's gone back to Warks, decided where he wants to bat and scored some runs there. We're picking blokes to bat at three in test cricket and he's never made a century in any format of the game. It's a bonker selection, but fortunately he has age on his side and I'm sure he'll come again.

Crawley and Pope are the two weak links in this side at present. Crawley, oddly, appears to be more valuable to the team. His partnership with Duckett is probably the best in the game at the top of the order, so he's a shoe-in for the coming years I'd imagine. Pope has now had 60 tests, another series where he's averaged mid-30s, in a position that is the most important in your line up. We've had Jordan Cox around the squad, likewise lots of noise about James Rew but I'm not sure either are ready for first drop in test cricket yet. Only other option is to pick a third opener, I've mentioned Tom Haines from Sussex a few times and think he could be an option. Do you go back to a Haseeb Hameed who's scored 1100 runs at 80 this season? Pope's winter returns will be under much scrutiny.
Reply
What I find worrying about Pope is that he gets out to the same shot almost all series. It's been highlighted that he falls over trying to hit the ball when it comes in to him on the stumps and he must've spent time trying to avoid the shot yet he was out in that last innings exactly the same way. I can't see him surviving the Aussie blitz even though the bounce will be much higher. I'm willing to bet anyone they'll target his stumps and the Yorker will get him out more than once. He's their bunny for the tour.
Reply
(08-04-2025, 08:44 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: I'm not having it that you can't criticise Brook for doing that in that moment. It's the equivalent of being 2-0 up with 20mins remaining, the best sides will manage the game, keep the ball not give the opponent a sniff. What you don't do is go gung-ho and gift them a goal to get them back in the game, it doesn't matter how well you've played until that point. The great Australian sides didn't give you an inch, this England team does it all too often. All we're asking is to read the room sometimes.

Bethell should be no where near the England team until he's gone back to Warks, decided where he wants to bat and scored some runs there. We're picking blokes to bat at three in test cricket and he's never made a century in any format of the game. It's a bonker selection, but fortunately he has age on his side and I'm sure he'll come again.

Crawley and Pope are the two weak links in this side at present. Crawley, oddly, appears to be more valuable to the team. His partnership with Duckett is probably the best in the game at the top of the order, so he's a shoe-in for the coming years I'd imagine. Pope has now had 60 tests, another series where he's averaged mid-30s, in a position that is the most important in your line up. We've had Jordan Cox around the squad, likewise lots of noise about James Rew but I'm not sure either are ready for first drop in test cricket yet. Only other option is to pick a third opener, I've mentioned Tom Haines from Sussex a few times and think he could be an option. Do you go back to a Haseeb Hameed who's scored 1100 runs at 80 this season? Pope's winter returns will be under much scrutiny.

What you're asking for is for Brook to change how he plays, which is very unorthodox. Stepping out of his crease to disrupt the bowlers lengths is one of his stock shots, it gets him a helluva lot of runs. Root does something similar but changes his starting crease position rather move as ball is bowled. 

It gets Brook a lot of runs, but as with most of his dismissals, if the unorthodox doesn't come off, it looks ugly and reckless.

He isn't going to,  and nor should he, try and play a different game to his natural game when on top as we were at that time.
Reply
It's Brook, for goodness sake! Big Grin
Reply
(08-04-2025, 09:46 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: It's Brook, for goodness sake! Big Grin

Eh?
Reply
Nicely edited Big Grin
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 4 Guest(s)