Make Gaza Great Again
Whilst either side has leadership or a majority of citizens hell bent on the complete removal of the other side it will continue to be a shit storm.

The Jews occupied Judah and Israel millennia before the Arabs. The Romans, like they did in most places expelled the majority who found their way into a Europe. Then over the next millennium Arabs largely moved into the land left by the Romans from neighbouring Arab states, that was the case then for the following millennium by and large.

Frankly, both religious groups have claim to the land, so a civilised 2 state solution is the only way to go. For that to happen both sides leadership have to be removed from power and the international community need to mediate indefinitely. Palestine need to moderated by Egypt/Saudi etc. and Israel needs to be moderated by the USA/UK/EU. This will be much easier the more aligned the moderate Arab states and the West are.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
The above is the ideal solution Lurker. I just can’t see the Israeli mentality letting go of the straight jacket it seems to have an unshakable belief it has the right to impose. What sounds ideal in structural form wouldn’t translate to reality of the daily life on the ground. Sadly, id take what you’ve suggested but enforce two completely separated states, with peace keeping from the above maintaining the borders.

Having worked with so many Palestinian kids that have exiled here down the years they are a truly amazing and beautiful people. What is happening to them is tragic.
Reply
This is where the moderation comes in. Since Israel reinvention in 1948, the Arab world and the west have been disengaged. But the recent improvements in relations between the west and the likes of Saudi/UAE etc gives more hope. Especially now many of those Arab states have publicly called for Hamas to surrender. Which has conveniently coincided with the west putting more pressure on Israel it must be said, so perhaps that joined up moderation has already begun.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
This conflict will continue for years to come. Both sides require it to continue whilst those in the firing line will be the losers.
Reply
(08-03-2025, 12:03 PM)Squid Wrote:
(08-03-2025, 11:54 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: The so called “whataboutery” on the West Bank just demonstrates why Israel can’t be trusted to deal with any situation with integrity and within the law. It is absolutely a valid illustration of how they act with a mentality of being superior and treating others as second class (at best) human beings

To that end, it is entirely relevant. The only positive about the whole thing is Israel has exposed itself tot the whole world, whilst in reality is has behaved like this since its artificial inception, to one extent or another

Including long before Hamas existed.

I've said on here before that this was their game plan all along. Despite it being as plain as the nose on your face, this makes me anti Semitic according to our  resident genocide and child murder defender, Ponti.

Proth seems to have hidden under a rock on this recently.
Reply
(08-03-2025, 01:07 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: This is where the moderation comes in. Since Israel reinvention in 1948, the Arab world and the west have been disengaged. But the recent improvements in relations between the west and the likes of Saudi/UAE etc gives more hope. Especially now many of those Arab states have publicly called for Hamas to surrender. Which has conveniently coincided with the west putting more pressure on Israel it must be said, so perhaps that joined up moderation has already begun.

I think you are rather overestimating how quickly the Palestinian people and the region as a whole will get over the fact that a genocide has taken place over the course of two and a half years.

You also don't seem to understand exactly who is running Israel and how happy they and a big chunk of the Israeli population are that that genocide has taken place. 

And the Israeli government has announced even more settlements in the West Bank. 

The idea that it just needs a bit of hand holding is frankly insulting and your comment is tantamount to genocide denial.
Reply
Squid. Firstly I haven't said that the only thing needed is a bit of hand holding. Secondly I have at no point downplayed the atrocities commited by Israel. In fact on the previous page I openly stated war crimes had been commited and those responsible should be brought to justice, with the full force of international law. I have also said no peace can be brokered whilst the leadership of both parties are in place.

Both sides populations are guilty of a hatred and refusal to accept the other side. Hamas were elected democratically on a mandate which included destroying Israel and returning the entirety of the land to Palestinians. Then a majority of Israelis have voted in the current Israeli regime which is just as hell bent on stealing land and over reacting to the terrorist intentions of Hamas.

Then the heartbreaking thing is the innocent, moderate, peaceful bystanders on both sides have been deeply and probably irreversibly affected by the actions of the governing few.

My point still stands. The war needs to end. It needs to result in Hamas and other proxies of Iran and also probably Qatar to be rendered impotent for a significant period so that the international community can stand between two devastated groups of people and try and broker a lasting peace. All this whilst hopefully the majority of Israelis vote in a more moderate government which would be able to have meaningful and cooperative dialogue with the new Palestinian regime.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
(08-03-2025, 05:17 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Squid. Firstly I haven't said that the only thing needed is a bit of hand holding. Secondly I have at no point downplayed the atrocities commited by Israel. In fact on the previous page I openly stated war crimes had been commited and those responsible should be brought to justice, with the full force of international law. I have also said no peace can be brokered whilst the leadership of both parties are in place.

Both sides populations are guilty of a hatred and refusal to accept the other side. Hamas were elected democratically on a mandate which included destroying Israel and returning the entirety of the land to Palestinians.  Then a majority of Israelis have voted in the current Israeli regime which is just as hell bent on stealing land and over reacting to the terrorist intentions of Hamas.

Then the heartbreaking thing is the innocent, moderate, peaceful bystanders on both sides have been deeply and probably irreversibly affected by the actions of the governing few.

My point still stands. The war needs to end. It needs to result in Hamas and other proxies of Iran and also probably Qatar to be rendered impotent for a significant period so that the international community can stand between two devastated groups of people and try and broker a lasting peace. All this whilst hopefully the majority of Israelis vote in a more moderate government which would be able to have meaningful and cooperative dialogue with the new Palestinian regime.

You keep saying both sides. This completely ignores that one side is vastly better armed than the other and has a vastly higher kill rate. You also seem to view the people of Gaza electing Hamas once as a protest vote nearly 20 years ago as equivalent to the majority of the Israeli population supporting a political system which has been accurately compared to apartheid. As can be seen in the West Bank, where there is no Hamas, there has never been Hamas and the Palestinians still live in oppression and misery.

It's like comparing the violence committed by the ANC to that carried out the South African apartheid regime and claiming both sides are the same. They are clearly not.
Reply
Various polls at the time showed that between 40-70% of Palestinians across both Gaza and The West Bank supported the 7th of October attacks. That's not a small minority, even if you take the low ball number. Of course support for Hamas is now falling in light of them losing the war, but that wasn't always the case. Of course it doesn't mean they deserve to be starved to death.

The reality here is, a formally oppressed peoples, who lost 6,000,000 of their own during the second world war are choosing to support a regime that is seen to be protecting them. It is a trauma response. Especially when you consider that neighbouring nations are shadily funding proxys to attack them at every given opportunity.

But even with that nuance. The deaths of non combatants, and the mass, forced displacement of people is a form of genocide and needs to be called out, regardless of how difficult the war has been for Israel to fight. It's civilians however need to live for a couple of generations without the risk of being subject to ANOTHER genocide themselves, then you may find a more moderate political response.

As I keep saying. Both sets of leadership needs removing. They need replacing with younger, more moderate people who's sole ambition it is to change the tide of hatred and resentment.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
(08-03-2025, 08:46 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Various polls at the time showed that between 40-70% of Palestinians across both Gaza and The West Bank supported the 7th of October attacks. That's not a small minority, even if you take the low ball number. Of course support for Hamas is now falling in light of them losing the war, but that wasn't always the case. Of course it doesn't mean they deserve to be starved to death.

The reality here is, a formally oppressed peoples, who lost 6,000,000 of their own during the second world war are choosing to support a regime that is seen to be protecting them. It is a trauma response. Especially when you consider that neighbouring nations are shadily funding proxys to attack them at every given opportunity.

But even with that nuance. The deaths of non combatants, and the mass, forced displacement of people is a form of genocide and needs to be called out, regardless of how difficult the war has been for Israel to fight. It's civilians however need to live for a couple of generations without the risk of being subject to ANOTHER genocide themselves, then you may find a more moderate political response.

As I keep saying. Both sets of leadership needs removing. They need replacing with younger, more moderate people who's sole ambition it is to change the tide of hatred and resentment.

I agree with all of that but suspect the generational capacity for reconciliation ship has now sailed. And who can say they would respond in any other way after all of this.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: