England v India Test Series!!..
(08-01-2025, 06:56 PM)Jacko Wrote: Nope it's just the catching. Restricting them to 220 was fine. A lead of 26 was fine. Dropping 3 catches in 45 minutes that would have decimated their 2nd innings, not fine.

Yes, in isolation it was fine. 

But that's not to say you can't criticise how we bowled first innings. It's widely accepted by pundits, including Athers, whose expertise is gospel as far as I'm concerned, who know a lot more than you and I, that we didn't bowl well at all and we could, and should, have bowled India out for less than we did. 

As I said, 30 plus extras in that innings tells you all you need to know. 

So yes, it's more than dropped catches.
Reply
From all my weather forecasts today appears to be the driest day left. Tomorrow and Monday looking quite wet. I have India as slight favourites. Despite England's modest 1st innings lead, I think losing a bowler (and he's a half decent batsman) just tilts it in favour of the tourists.
Reply
If Woakes wasn't injured I couldn't call it. But being a man down really is a hindrance.
Reply
Best batting day weather wise today you would feel critical to the Tests outcome.
Reply
Another dropped catch. It's laughable now!
Reply
This bullshit of outside the line , it’s utter crap it would have hit middle halfway up.if his foot hadn’t got in way it would smash into the stumps, if it’s hitting the stumps it’s fucking out.
Reply
Have to admit that regardless of England's sloppiness at times and interesting selection choices, the last five days of cricket from India across the end of the last test and this have been excellent. Real mental toughness, what test cricket has been about.
Reply
(08-02-2025, 02:43 PM)wba13 Wrote: This bullshit of outside the line , it’s utter crap it would have hit middle halfway up.if his foot hadn’t got in way it would smash into the stumps,  if it’s hitting the stumps it’s fucking out.

It favours the bowler each time.
But them have been the rules for nearly a century.
Reply
(08-02-2025, 03:18 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(08-02-2025, 02:43 PM)wba13 Wrote: This bullshit of outside the line , it’s utter crap it would have hit middle halfway up.if his foot hadn’t got in way it would smash into the stumps,  if it’s hitting the stumps it’s fucking out.

It favours the bowler each time.
But them have been the rules for nearly a century.

It’s about balance between bat and ball. Go back 100 years and the ball also had to pitch in line with the stumps to be out lbw. Then they allowed the ball to pitch outside off stump after the “bat had got on top of the ball” (and pad play became common), but not outside leg stump.

But yes it still has to hit in line, and this is required to maintain a reasonable balance between bat and ball.
Reply
(08-02-2025, 03:18 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(08-02-2025, 02:43 PM)wba13 Wrote: This bullshit of outside the line , it’s utter crap it would have hit middle halfway up.if his foot hadn’t got in way it would smash into the stumps,  if it’s hitting the stumps it’s fucking out.

It favours the bowler each time.
But them have been the rules for nearly a century.

I know but I never have understood why, if you miss it and it hits the stumps your out but if you miss it and it hits your leg which is outside the line of the off stump your not out.there is no freakin’ for it if it’s hitting the stumps and it’s missed your bat it’s out there should be no plausible excuses for not giving it. Don’t the batsmen get enough leeway anyhow.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 7 Guest(s)