England v India Test Series!!..
Whilst the bazball era has 100% produced some stupid dismissals I'm not too concerned with Duckett's there. It's the scoops and big hits that put the bowlers off their length on a moving pitch. If they'd just played classical shots and leaves then we'd probably have half the runs and the Indian bowlers would've been able to find their length much more quickly and we'd still be 1 or 2 down.

In this instance - with a nibbling pitch and a low score to aim at - playing scoops etc is 'playing the conditions' in the way that defending and grinding it out with proper shots might be in another instance.
Reply
(08-01-2025, 11:48 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(08-01-2025, 11:44 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(08-01-2025, 11:25 AM)Jacko Wrote: Bazball usually comes to the fore when the ball is doing a bit. Bowlers tend to bowl fuller looking for late movement. They're going at nearly 8 an over.

(08-01-2025, 11:33 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Begs the question, why didn't India take a look at the pitch and the conditions and have a bit of a dip rather than hanging around waiting to get a ball with your name on it. As Sudharsan, Jadeja, Sundar, Rahul, Nair all found out.

(08-01-2025, 11:32 AM)richbaggie Wrote: Bazball comes off,  it's brilliant batting.

Play same shots and get out, gets called brainless on here.

Personally, I love the approach and accept that there will be days it doesn't come off. The record under the regime justifies the means.

The point is, this is a great way to come out and play whilst the ball is doing a bit against fresh bowlers. If these pair bat like this for 15-20 overs, there is no need for Pope, Root and Brook to come in and do the same. That's how you turn 120-1 into 150-5, which given the situation of the match and the series we do not need or want.

Also doesn't detract from the times when the situation didn't call for this, but we did it anyway and threw games away. This series the team really look to have grown and started to play the situation more, certainly gives me more confidence heading to Australia than I perhaps had 18 months ago.

My point remains, if we'd lost quick wickets playing so attackingly, it would have been slammed as brainless. It's a thin line between praise and brickbat.

As Jacko says, given the conditions it's probably fair enough today. Otherwise you prod around for 30 balls, score 3 and then get one that's unplayable anyway.

This is the only way to play for me, when the ball is moving the way it is.  Can’t see the point in playing defensively when any  ball can have your name on it. Totally the best approach, a great 50 from Crawley.
Reply
(08-01-2025, 11:54 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(08-01-2025, 11:51 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(08-01-2025, 11:48 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(08-01-2025, 11:47 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: See, that Duckett wicket is so frustrating.

Yes he has hit two sixes from scooping. He went for a scoop and miss timed it, then went again and threw his wicket away.

I accept the risk and reward argument, and it has been a brilliant start and innings from him, but you can't tell me that that wicket wasn't brain-dead batting?

Take a ball or two to reset after the first failed scoop. We've gotten off to a flier, it's OK to reign it in and settle back in. It really is frustrating, and yes, needless.

It's still an exceptional start from England.

Stops watch.

Grow up. 

It's a great start and I've thoroughly enjoyed Duckett's innings. Exactly what we needed this morning. 

But you have to accept that it's reasonable to find his dismissal frustrating. To not acknowledge that would be childish.

Considering he's left us 92-1 off 13 overs, not really. If he'd done it second ball then maybe.

Short of batters never getting out and bowlers never getting hit for four, I don't know what they need to do to placate you.

No, that's not what I'm saying. It's been an excellent start and I'm not trying to be critical of Duckett. It was the exact sort of innings I feel we needed from him. I really enjoyed it. 

My argument is against Rich, who is moaning at people moaning about aggressive shots. My point is that you can see why people will be frustrated at that wicket. He got a warning the ball before. That was the time to maybe take a step back and reset a little. 

I'm all for the aggressive nature, but I see no reason why you can't have some sensible batting mixed in there. Anyway, I really liked that innings and it's given us a great platform to build a good first innings lead. I'm happy with where we are in this match, and I'm happy with the role Duckett played, so no negativity towards Duckett from me. 

But I'll let childish people draw their own conclusions and put words into my mouth.
Reply
(08-01-2025, 11:51 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(08-01-2025, 11:48 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(08-01-2025, 11:47 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: See, that Duckett wicket is so frustrating.

Yes he has hit two sixes from scooping. He went for a scoop and miss timed it, then went again and threw his wicket away.

I accept the risk and reward argument, and it has been a brilliant start and innings from him, but you can't tell me that that wicket wasn't brain-dead batting?

Take a ball or two to reset after the first failed scoop. We've gotten off to a flier, it's OK to reign it in and settle back in. It really is frustrating, and yes, needless.

It's still an exceptional start from England.

Stops watch.

Grow up. 

It's a great start and I've thoroughly enjoyed Duckett's innings. Exactly what we needed this morning. 

But you have to accept that it's reasonable to find his dismissal frustrating. To not acknowledge that would be childish.

No need for the abuse Josh.

I've pointed out that there is a thin line between praise and brickbat which you have shown today. Your cricket opinions are all over the place. You hate Bazball, yet praise it when it works, slam it when it doesn't. Youve done it all summer.
Reply
(08-01-2025, 11:56 AM)wba13 Wrote:
(08-01-2025, 11:48 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(08-01-2025, 11:44 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(08-01-2025, 11:25 AM)Jacko Wrote: Bazball usually comes to the fore when the ball is doing a bit. Bowlers tend to bowl fuller looking for late movement. They're going at nearly 8 an over.

(08-01-2025, 11:33 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Begs the question, why didn't India take a look at the pitch and the conditions and have a bit of a dip rather than hanging around waiting to get a ball with your name on it. As Sudharsan, Jadeja, Sundar, Rahul, Nair all found out.

(08-01-2025, 11:32 AM)richbaggie Wrote: Bazball comes off,  it's brilliant batting.

Play same shots and get out, gets called brainless on here.

Personally, I love the approach and accept that there will be days it doesn't come off. The record under the regime justifies the means.

The point is, this is a great way to come out and play whilst the ball is doing a bit against fresh bowlers. If these pair bat like this for 15-20 overs, there is no need for Pope, Root and Brook to come in and do the same. That's how you turn 120-1 into 150-5, which given the situation of the match and the series we do not need or want.

Also doesn't detract from the times when the situation didn't call for this, but we did it anyway and threw games away. This series the team really look to have grown and started to play the situation more, certainly gives me more confidence heading to Australia than I perhaps had 18 months ago.

My point remains, if we'd lost quick wickets playing so attackingly, it would have been slammed as brainless. It's a thin line between praise and brickbat.

As Jacko says, given the conditions it's probably fair enough today. Otherwise you prod around for 30 balls, score 3 and then get one that's unplayable anyway.

This is the only way to play for me, when the ball is moving the way it is.  Can’t see the point in playing defensively when any  ball can have your name on it. Totally the best approach, a great 50 from Crawley.

100%

What I would say if playing aggressively brought 4 wickets for 50 runs, say. Then I'd like to see us dig in in that situation to try and build some form of first innings score. It hasn't come to that, but you can't keep throwing your bat at every ball if you're loosing wickets. 

In this situation, now we have runs on the ball, and only one wicket down, it's fair enough. 

It's been an excellent first session today. All England.

(08-01-2025, 12:00 PM)richbaggie Wrote:
(08-01-2025, 11:51 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(08-01-2025, 11:48 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(08-01-2025, 11:47 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: See, that Duckett wicket is so frustrating.

Yes he has hit two sixes from scooping. He went for a scoop and miss timed it, then went again and threw his wicket away.

I accept the risk and reward argument, and it has been a brilliant start and innings from him, but you can't tell me that that wicket wasn't brain-dead batting?

Take a ball or two to reset after the first failed scoop. We've gotten off to a flier, it's OK to reign it in and settle back in. It really is frustrating, and yes, needless.

It's still an exceptional start from England.

Stops watch.

Grow up. 

It's a great start and I've thoroughly enjoyed Duckett's innings. Exactly what we needed this morning. 

But you have to accept that it's reasonable to find his dismissal frustrating. To not acknowledge that would be childish.

No need for the abuse Josh.

I've pointed out that there is a thin line between praise and brickbat which you have shown today. Your cricket opinions are all over the place. You hate Bazball, yet praise it when it works, slam it when it doesn't. Youve done it all summer.
I don't see the abuse...

I credit good bowling & batting when I see it. I criticise bad bowling & batting when I see it. There's no agenda here. I just discuss and form an opinion on what I see. 

Yesterday I felt we were poor with the ball. I said as much. This morning we've been excellent with the bat, I've said as much. 

It's better than having a one eyed view that everything under Baz is Rosey and the best ever, or that it's the worst style ever and we shouldn't ever be aggressive. 

As with everything, I try and be balanced. The aggressive style is neither the best way to play every situation, nor is it totally wrong. It's all about applying the right style in the right match situation. Sometimes we do, sometimes we don't. 

When we go aggressive for the sake of it, regardless of where we are in the match, then I get frustrated. When I see batsmen out to shots that weren't necessary, I ges frustrated.

Why are they calling that wicket a send off from Deep. Behave. Nothing to see here.
Reply
(08-01-2025, 12:02 PM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(08-01-2025, 11:56 AM)wba13 Wrote:
(08-01-2025, 11:48 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(08-01-2025, 11:44 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(08-01-2025, 11:25 AM)Jacko Wrote: Bazball usually comes to the fore when the ball is doing a bit. Bowlers tend to bowl fuller looking for late movement. They're going at nearly 8 an over.

(08-01-2025, 11:33 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Begs the question, why didn't India take a look at the pitch and the conditions and have a bit of a dip rather than hanging around waiting to get a ball with your name on it. As Sudharsan, Jadeja, Sundar, Rahul, Nair all found out.


The point is, this is a great way to come out and play whilst the ball is doing a bit against fresh bowlers. If these pair bat like this for 15-20 overs, there is no need for Pope, Root and Brook to come in and do the same. That's how you turn 120-1 into 150-5, which given the situation of the match and the series we do not need or want.

Also doesn't detract from the times when the situation didn't call for this, but we did it anyway and threw games away. This series the team really look to have grown and started to play the situation more, certainly gives me more confidence heading to Australia than I perhaps had 18 months ago.

My point remains, if we'd lost quick wickets playing so attackingly, it would have been slammed as brainless. It's a thin line between praise and brickbat.

As Jacko says, given the conditions it's probably fair enough today. Otherwise you prod around for 30 balls, score 3 and then get one that's unplayable anyway.

This is the only way to play for me, when the ball is moving the way it is.  Can’t see the point in playing defensively when any  ball can have your name on it. Totally the best approach, a great 50 from Crawley.

100%

What I would say if playing aggressively brought 4 wickets for 50 runs, say. Then I'd like to see us dig in in that situation to try and build some form of first innings score. It hasn't come to that, but you can't keep throwing your bat at every ball if you're loosing wickets. 

In this situation, now we have runs on the ball, and only one wicket down, it's fair enough. 

It's been an excellent first session today. All England.

(08-01-2025, 12:00 PM)richbaggie Wrote:
(08-01-2025, 11:51 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(08-01-2025, 11:48 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(08-01-2025, 11:47 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: See, that Duckett wicket is so frustrating.

Yes he has hit two sixes from scooping. He went for a scoop and miss timed it, then went again and threw his wicket away.

I accept the risk and reward argument, and it has been a brilliant start and innings from him, but you can't tell me that that wicket wasn't brain-dead batting?

Take a ball or two to reset after the first failed scoop. We've gotten off to a flier, it's OK to reign it in and settle back in. It really is frustrating, and yes, needless.

It's still an exceptional start from England.

Stops watch.

Grow up. 

It's a great start and I've thoroughly enjoyed Duckett's innings. Exactly what we needed this morning. 

But you have to accept that it's reasonable to find his dismissal frustrating. To not acknowledge that would be childish.

No need for the abuse Josh.

I've pointed out that there is a thin line between praise and brickbat which you have shown today. Your cricket opinions are all over the place. You hate Bazball, yet praise it when it works, slam it when it doesn't. Youve done it all summer.
I don't see the abuse...

I credit good bowling & batting when I see it. I criticise bad bowling & batting when I see it. There's no agenda here. I just discuss and form an opinion on what I see. 

Yesterday I felt we were poor with the ball. I said as much. This morning we've been excellent with the bat, I've said as much. 

It's better than having a one eyed view that everything under Baz is Rosey and the best ever, or that it's the worst style ever and we shouldn't ever be aggressive. 

As with everything, I try and be balanced. The aggressive style is neither the best way to play every situation, nor is it totally wrong. It's all about applying the right style in the right match situation. Sometimes we do, sometimes we don't. 

When we go aggressive for the sake of it, regardless of where we are in the match, then I get frustrated. When I see batsmen out to shots that weren't necessary, I ges frustrated.

Why are they calling that wicket a send off from Deep. Behave. Nothing to see here.

Who on here has the opinion that everything under Baz is rosey?
Reply
For the love of god, stop quoting whole massive posts
Reply
No one, just using it as an example. I have a default opinion that 'Bazball' is too aggressive, and it's not how I like to see the game played. However, that doesn't mean I'm too stubborn to appreciate when it works or when we play well, like we have this morning.

What's the alternative, for me to hold a stubborn view and not appreciate anything or give any performance any sort of credit. That would be ridiculous and childish!

I've enjoyed the start of this innings, I can understand why we're going aggressive, as has been rightly said defending and playing sensibly would probably backfire as the ball is doing a lot and you're bound to get an unplayable delivery sooner or later.

Please don't take this as being negative, as I believe we've earned this - but we have ridden some luck so far! Big Grin

You create your own luck, as they say.

Good knock from Crawley. Rode his luck a few times, didn't really look settled, but played some lovely shots.
Reply
This is now the perfect situation for Pope and Root to shift and still be positive but without trying to reverse paddle everything for six, they've had a great platform set and this pitch will only get better to bat on. These two need to bat out this session and if England are still batting come the end of the day we're looking at a position where we could potentially only have to bat once. Tomorrow will be the best day for batting.
Reply
Very unlikeable bunch this India team
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)