England v India Test Series!!..
(07-24-2025, 01:14 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(07-24-2025, 01:12 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(07-24-2025, 01:11 PM)wba13 Wrote:
(07-24-2025, 01:05 PM)Jacko Wrote: It's quite simple, if he's going to bat without a runner, he should be made to keep wicket.

I’m in total agreement with you, he hardy did anything but bat in the last test.The rules are wrong and should be changed.

Ok let's not play to the rules.

It's been said a few times RS, but this is an issue with the rules rather than the player/team.
I agree. But until they are changed the continued  petty sniping at Pant, who is quite obviously injured,  is unseemly and very childish.
Reply
358 all out. Decent total given the conditions. We need to match it.
Reply
(07-24-2025, 12:40 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(07-24-2025, 12:28 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(07-24-2025, 12:11 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(07-24-2025, 11:30 AM)Jacko Wrote: Colour me shocked...

He's clearly injured though in fairness to him.

Issue with the rule here, and the reason why there wasn't this uproar when Nathan Lyon did it, is that you can replace him with Jurel. Either you're allowed to make full substitutions, which would ruin the game, or someone else should have to take the gloves midway through the game. If it was Thakhur who had gone down injured, India don't get the option of replacing him with Deep or Krishna, why should they be allowed t replace Pant in the field?

The rules need looking at but currently Jurel can come on to take the wicket keeping gloves from Pant. 
A preselected substitute before the match starts be nominated. Whether he's a keeper, bowler or batsman. Only to come on as a fielder.

I'm not sure I like the substitute idea. The roles within the game are too different and it leaves it open to abuse.

Injuries that rule a player out during a game are rare, perhaps Pant should have a look at the way he's getting injured? Diving in front of first slip for catches, trying to reverse paddle the England opening bowler, dare I say FAFO?

I don't think India are trying to use it to their advantage here, but if it were a bowler, they'd be a 'man' down. Why can't Rahul take the gloves? He's kept before. I don't mind him batting on one leg, but India should be using a sub fielder and having to give the gloves to another member of the XI.

Game is really in the balance, anything around 350 in these conditions and with Bumrah and Siraj is more than competitive.

This, Rahul has kept before so would be an able fill in. The wicketkeeper is a specialist position, so perhaps it should be akin to the same rules as if a bowler had to go off.

I was trying to see if I could link it to a football goalkeeper being sent off in a match, and then not being able to be replaced with one off the bench, but it doesn't really work given substitutes are so ingrained within football.
Reply
(07-24-2025, 01:17 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(07-24-2025, 01:14 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(07-24-2025, 01:12 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(07-24-2025, 01:11 PM)wba13 Wrote:
(07-24-2025, 01:05 PM)Jacko Wrote: It's quite simple, if he's going to bat without a runner, he should be made to keep wicket.

I’m in total agreement with you, he hardy did anything but bat in the last test.The rules are wrong and should be changed.

Ok let's not play to the rules.

It's been said a few times RS, but this is an issue with the rules rather than the player/team.
I agree. But until they are changed the continued  petty sniping at Pant, who is quite obviously injured,  is unseemly and very childish.

I don't think it's been that bad really RS. 

358 a more than handy total, I would not want to be Crawley or Duckett wandering out to face Bumrah in these conditions.
Reply
Pant’s foot broken? Extraordinary that he batted with a broken metatarsal apparently.
Reply
358 feels about par, maybe even slightly better. ball moving though so the openers must be patient.
Reply
(07-24-2025, 01:05 PM)Jacko Wrote: It's quite simple, if he's going to bat without a runner, he should be made to keep wicket.

There’s no doubt your bias is clouding your single digit IQ Malcom Marshall came out to bat with a broken arm in 1984 against England would you have made him bowl?.
Pant has obviously broken a bone in his foot came out to bat for his team despite the obvious pain.
Only a masochistic ignorant would expect to see him wicket keep too!!.
Grow up. Angry
Reply
(07-24-2025, 01:47 PM)pindgill Wrote:
(07-24-2025, 01:05 PM)Jacko Wrote: It's quite simple, if he's going to bat without a runner, he should be made to keep wicket.

There’s no doubt your bias is clouding your single digit IQ Malcom Marshall came out to bat with a broken arm in 1984 against England would you have made him bowl?.
Pant has obviously broken a bone in his foot came out to bat for his team despite the obvious pain.
Only a masochistic ignorant would expect to see him wicket keep too!!.
Grow up. Angry

Assuming the sub fielder wasn't a gun bowler who was allowed to open the bowling? If you're going to make daft comparisons at least try and get the details right.

Once again, the issue is with the rules rather than the player or the team.
Reply
TMS with an interesting stat. Crawley averages 25 against fast medium and medium pace but averages 80 against fast (88mph+) bowling. How strange.
Reply
Brilliant session for England. The Indian bowlers have extracted very little from extremely helpful conditions.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: