The Sinner takes it all ..
#41
(07-14-2025, 09:37 AM)KRO Wrote: So he got banned without committing an offence?
Behave. You’ve just said he’s responsible.for his entourage. Intent or not he’s guilty

He got a short ban because it was non deliberate and an amount which did not enhance performance.

He’d have got 2 years if it would have been deliberate and performance enhancing.

So he’s guilty of negligence, not of deliberate doping.

Christ how hard can this be?
Reply
#42
(07-14-2025, 09:37 AM)KRO Wrote: So he got banned without committing an offence?
Behave. You’ve just said he’s responsible.for his entourage. Intent or not he’s guilty

(07-14-2025, 09:36 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(07-14-2025, 09:35 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(07-14-2025, 09:02 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(07-14-2025, 08:55 AM)KRO Wrote: It’s pretty simple. Black or white. He had traces of a banned substance in him. Doesn’t matter how much. The substance is banned. Not allowed. Any trace means guilt. He had traces of it in him. Whether he meant or not he committed a punishable offence. Intention doesn’t come into it. 
Hence his ban

He was punished, in accordance with the level of the banned substance found in his sample and given the circumstances of it getting there.

Correct. Because intent, or lack of, does come into it when it comes to the ban length. As does the amount. Any trace does not mean guilty of deliberate doping, but I think some folk are struggling with the nuances here tbh.

Fairly sure it's deliberate in the attempt to boil some piss.

In ban length. Not guilt though. He’s guilty.

Sigh. Pathetic.
Reply
#43
FFS he`s the Wimbledon champion your not taking it away from him move on.
Reply
#44
(07-14-2025, 08:18 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(07-14-2025, 08:08 AM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(07-14-2025, 07:41 AM)George Stagefright Wrote:
(07-13-2025, 09:22 PM)KRO Wrote: By an independent panel.
Not WADA

"Mr Sinner did not intend to cheat".
"Did not provide any performance enhancing benefit"
"Took place without his knowledge"

From WADA.

As AB says above, a lot of bollocks spouted in this thread.  The anabolic steroid clostebol is found in Trofodermin, which is available in Italy over the counter without prescription.  It's widely used to make cuts heal quicker, which is what Sinners physiotherapist used it for - provided to him by Sinners fitness trainer.  Both members of his team were subsequently fired. The amount of clostebol detected was less than 1 billionth of a gram.

Sinner is not the first Italian athlete to test positive for this, let alone the first Italian tennis player.

So he took a banned substance to speed up the process of an injury? I think that would qualify as a drugs cheat, albeit unwittingly.  Ignorance of the law is no defence. 

Branded as a drugs cheat in this instance would seem somewhat unfair, but getting a 3 month ban between Slams is also unfair. He’s effectively got away with breaking the rules on drug treatments to heal an injury.

Just showing you're ignorance on this, and inability to read. I've highlighed the key part from George.

No, Sinner didn't take anything. His trainer/massuer used a cream legal to buy in Italy (much like us buying Savlon here) on himself (the trainer). It was then on his hands whilst he was massaging Sinner. 1 billionth of a gram was in Sinner's system for two tests over one week, and never before or again. Sinner is obviously, completely unaware of this. Why would the masseur tell him about a cream he used to heal a cut, which is very common in Italy?

Sinner/his team took the course of action to fire them as soon as this came to light. You can absolutely make the case that this type of cream should have been nowhere near Sinner at all, given how extensive the banned list of substances is for tennis players (please watch the Roddick video I posted). BUT it was clearly an obvious mistake. He's obviously not gaining any advantage whatsoever from 1 billionth of a gram. If he was actually trying to cheat, the level would be much higher.

So, given he has some responsibility for the cream being near him, despite not being aware, he has to take some sort of ban, which was why he received the 3 month ban. Again, nuance. It isn't "taken any banned substance, banned forever", in any sport, neither is it in tennis.

Whenever some people hear "tested positive for banned substance", they automatically just think "he's doping and cheating" and that's that. Don't bother to read the situation or facts, don't bother to try and critically think about it, just go to instant frenzy. Sad indictment for society.

Without the insults eh?  I haven't read the full report I was merely going off what you'd typed.

Your "which is what Sinners physiotherapy used it for" doesn't make it clear.  I took that to mean the physio used it for a cut on Sinner.

If you're going to be cunty to people when they misunderstand your message then you need to ensure your message is better written so misunderstandings don't happen, be precise not ambiguous.
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
#45
(07-14-2025, 09:42 AM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(07-14-2025, 08:18 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(07-14-2025, 08:08 AM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(07-14-2025, 07:41 AM)George Stagefright Wrote:
(07-13-2025, 09:22 PM)KRO Wrote: By an independent panel.
Not WADA

"Mr Sinner did not intend to cheat".
"Did not provide any performance enhancing benefit"
"Took place without his knowledge"

From WADA.

As AB says above, a lot of bollocks spouted in this thread.  The anabolic steroid clostebol is found in Trofodermin, which is available in Italy over the counter without prescription.  It's widely used to make cuts heal quicker, which is what Sinners physiotherapist used it for - provided to him by Sinners fitness trainer.  Both members of his team were subsequently fired. The amount of clostebol detected was less than 1 billionth of a gram.

Sinner is not the first Italian athlete to test positive for this, let alone the first Italian tennis player.

So he took a banned substance to speed up the process of an injury? I think that would qualify as a drugs cheat, albeit unwittingly.  Ignorance of the law is no defence. 

Branded as a drugs cheat in this instance would seem somewhat unfair, but getting a 3 month ban between Slams is also unfair. He’s effectively got away with breaking the rules on drug treatments to heal an injury.

Just showing you're ignorance on this, and inability to read. I've highlighed the key part from George.

No, Sinner didn't take anything. His trainer/massuer used a cream legal to buy in Italy (much like us buying Savlon here) on himself (the trainer). It was then on his hands whilst he was massaging Sinner. 1 billionth of a gram was in Sinner's system for two tests over one week, and never before or again. Sinner is obviously, completely unaware of this. Why would the masseur tell him about a cream he used to heal a cut, which is very common in Italy?

Sinner/his team took the course of action to fire them as soon as this came to light. You can absolutely make the case that this type of cream should have been nowhere near Sinner at all, given how extensive the banned list of substances is for tennis players (please watch the Roddick video I posted). BUT it was clearly an obvious mistake. He's obviously not gaining any advantage whatsoever from 1 billionth of a gram. If he was actually trying to cheat, the level would be much higher.

So, given he has some responsibility for the cream being near him, despite not being aware, he has to take some sort of ban, which was why he received the 3 month ban. Again, nuance. It isn't "taken any banned substance, banned forever", in any sport, neither is it in tennis.

Whenever some people hear "tested positive for banned substance", they automatically just think "he's doping and cheating" and that's that. Don't bother to read the situation or facts, don't bother to try and critically think about it, just go to instant frenzy. Sad indictment for society.

Without the insults eh?  I haven't read the full report I was merely going off what you'd typed.

Your "which is what Sinners physiotherapy used it for" doesn't make it clear.  I took that to mean the physio used it for a cut on Sinner.

If you're going to be cunty to people when they misunderstand your message then you need to ensure your message is better written so misunderstandings don't happen, be precise not ambiguous.

Wasn't my post, not sure how I could be more precise. Also ignorance isn't an insult, it's just lack of knowledge. The problem comes when people speak absolutes from a position of ignorance (which in fairness, you didn't really do).

"Ignorance is no defense". Your words. Ignorance is no excuse for calling a player a drugs cheat when, at worst, they're guilty of team negligence.
Reply
#46
(07-14-2025, 09:39 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(07-14-2025, 09:37 AM)KRO Wrote: So he got banned without committing an offence?
Behave. You’ve just said he’s responsible.for his entourage. Intent or not he’s guilty

He got a short ban because it was non deliberate and an amount which did not enhance performance.

He’d have got 2 years if it would have been deliberate and performance enhancing.

So he’s guilty of negligence, not of deliberate doping.

Christ how hard can this be?
Easy for me. He’s guilty as you admit. Guilty of failing a test because of a banned drug
Reply
#47
I'm not sure there is a single post of the almost fifty in this thread that disputes whether or not Sinner 'took' the banned substance.
Reply
#48
It was me that typed that, not AnelkasBeard.

Interesting that you think 1 billionth of a gram can speed up the recovery process of an "injury".
Reply
#49
(07-14-2025, 09:33 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(07-14-2025, 09:30 AM)KRO Wrote:
(07-14-2025, 09:02 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(07-14-2025, 08:55 AM)KRO Wrote:
(07-13-2025, 10:13 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: Hell of a lot of misinformed shite on this thread.

Someone using Nick Kyrgios as the bastion for truth takes the absolute biscuit Big Grin jesus christ.

https://youtu.be/ESb5xDZxMmo?si=YCOlRcqeFwhS5d_r

If some of you can be bothered to look past a headline and actual learn some detail about the situation, here is Andy Roddick talking about it as the story was breaking at the US Open. He's a great voice for this I feel as he's able to nuance his opinion and look at details, which he provides here, and give some actual perspective (including how the drug testing actually works etc). It's not reactionary hot take bollocks just to generate clicks.

Really worthwhile to see that Sinner really wasn't remotely cheating.

It’s pretty simple. Black or white. He had traces of a banned substance in him. Doesn’t matter how much. The substance is banned. Not allowed. Any trace means guilt. He had traces of it in him. Whether he meant or not he committed a punishable offence. Intention doesn’t come into it. 
Hence his ban

Yep which is exactly what I said. However, intention absolutely and obviously comes in to it. As with any crime, which I'm sure you know. If you can't admit to that, you're just not talking in good faith.

But let's not pretend he was trying to cheat, which is exactly what you were doingg.

Not commenting on the frankly bizarre other comment you made.
Trying to cheat or not he took banned a substance. He’s a drugs cheat. Unwittingly or not. If you kill someone driving a car, you’ll still be found guilty of a crime. That’s the important bit. More importantly is I’ve made my mind up. He’s a cheat.

So if someone runs out in front of your car, you had no chance of seeing them, and you accidentally run someone over and they die, you're a murderer?

I've made my mind up. You're a murderer. You realise how stupid you sound?

Either that or you're just on some WUM phase which is a bit sad.

He's been a WUM for a while now, best to just ignore.
Reply
#50
(07-14-2025, 09:52 AM)albion_pigeon Wrote:
(07-14-2025, 09:33 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(07-14-2025, 09:30 AM)KRO Wrote:
(07-14-2025, 09:02 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(07-14-2025, 08:55 AM)KRO Wrote: It’s pretty simple. Black or white. He had traces of a banned substance in him. Doesn’t matter how much. The substance is banned. Not allowed. Any trace means guilt. He had traces of it in him. Whether he meant or not he committed a punishable offence. Intention doesn’t come into it. 
Hence his ban

Yep which is exactly what I said. However, intention absolutely and obviously comes in to it. As with any crime, which I'm sure you know. If you can't admit to that, you're just not talking in good faith.

But let's not pretend he was trying to cheat, which is exactly what you were doingg.

Not commenting on the frankly bizarre other comment you made.
Trying to cheat or not he took banned a substance. He’s a drugs cheat. Unwittingly or not. If you kill someone driving a car, you’ll still be found guilty of a crime. That’s the important bit. More importantly is I’ve made my mind up. He’s a cheat.

So if someone runs out in front of your car, you had no chance of seeing them, and you accidentally run someone over and they die, you're a murderer?

I've made my mind up. You're a murderer. You realise how stupid you sound?

Either that or you're just on some WUM phase which is a bit sad.

He's been a WUM for a while now, best to just ignore.

Yeah, valid and noted. A shame.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)