Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(07-12-2025, 02:24 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote: The Labour manifesto of 2017 was their best one since 1945. It aspired for real change rather than the usual tinkering at the edges that Labour in govt do. The people didn't want it and the Labour Party machinery didn't want it. Nor did Dekka or Peter Mandelson.
And so here we are. More tinkering and changing nothing.
I didn’t want Momentum or Corbyn as leader, because whether people like it or not his popularity didn’t equate into votes due to the baggage he brought with him as did Momentum. It wasn’t the policies that were a problem, they were very popular it was the sales people selling them.
Posts: 11,928
Threads: 798
Joined: Oct 2022
Reputation:
50
(07-12-2025, 02:24 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote: The Labour manifesto of 2017 was their best one since 1945. It aspired for real change rather than the usual tinkering at the edges that Labour in govt do. The people didn't want it and the Labour Party machinery didn't want it. Nor did Dekka or Peter Mandelson.
And so here we are. More tinkering and changing nothing.
The main problem with 2017 was that it tried to do too much and therefore appeared unachievable/unaffordable. Imo.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Posts: 7,446
Threads: 372
Joined: Sep 2024
Reputation:
33
07-12-2025, 07:15 PM
(This post was last modified: 07-12-2025, 07:16 PM by tHEgLASSdOORS.)
Corbyn was and always will be the main problem. That’s not my view of him as an individual, but it’s the reality that it is for too much of the electorate. Even if he had somehow cobbled a win together, he’d have lasted less time than Liz Truss
Posts: 6,720
Threads: 355
Joined: Mar 2024
Reputation:
40
(07-12-2025, 07:15 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Corbyn was and always will be the main problem. That’s not my view of him as an individual, but it’s the reality that it is for too much of the electorate. Even if he had somehow cobbled a win together, he’d have lasted less time than Liz Truss
Also more of an intellectual than a leader. He'd have been ok as a minister maybe. Perhaps Burnham would have been more credible. He had his try and lost. But he's doing ok as Mayor. Maybe he will have a go yet. But even someone like him would be like Lenin in the eyes of the current cabal.
Imagine the markets the day after a Corbyn win with McDonnell as chancellor.
Posts: 7,446
Threads: 372
Joined: Sep 2024
Reputation:
33
Agree with all of that. If Streeting wasn’t around I’d have fancied Burnham to have another crack at some point
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
(07-11-2025, 04:01 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (07-11-2025, 02:57 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: I think you’re right to crucifies them. I just think that people with your political profile end up getting frustrated they don’t see a party that represents them and what they want in government because as we found out under Corbyn and Kinnock, the UK electorate won’t lean that far left. So you can either take the progress on areas like health, housing, employment rights and the new Sure Starts, for example, or getting angry about the other stuff you don’t like and end up shouting from the sidelines forever
I’m not left wing, I’m further to the right than I expect you are on drugs, anti-social behaviour, poor behaviour in school, the lack of politeness/decency in society etc. I’m not and never have been Corbyn admirer, far too bogged down with baggage and I dislike the cult that surrounds him. However all I see is with Labour is a principle free, party that has ducked every ‘grown up’ decision that doesn’t punch down apart from tuition fee’s.
What do Labour stand for?
I don’t want to point out the obvious here but portraying the left as soft on drugs, anti-social behaviour and politeness in society is simply wrong. Why you think that those are ‘right’ attributes I’m not certain.
Posts: 4,258
Threads: 263
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
(07-11-2025, 02:53 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (07-11-2025, 02:15 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: (07-11-2025, 02:07 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (07-11-2025, 12:18 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: It’s inevitable that the Labour left will fracture the party in the coming years as always happens eventually. Blair had more clout and better circumstances than Starmer to hold it off for a much longer period. What will happen to centre of UK politics in the coming years is anyone’s guess
It’s the Tory/Blue Labour that are overseeing the potential break up of the Labour Party. That’s what happens when you abandon any notion that you have any principles and have abandoned the centre left ground and moved towards out reforming Reform.
It’s old ground but it’s a perennial problem for Labour. They go centre to get power and fracture left and become an old man shouting at a cloud
Probably missed a chance to straddle that line back when they chose the wrong Miliband
Unfortunately Derek, sometimes if you want any representation at all, you have to suck up the parts that you don’t like. That’s life
If I had any clue what Labour now stand for then I’d be more inclined to not criticise them. All I’ve seen is them go after easy and vulnerable targets, abandon their principles, fail to talk to their MPs outside of a small clique in the cabinet and some truly abysmal advisers and use divisive language about working and non-working people. What do Labour actually stand for?
What I'm seeing in you, Derek, is a true Labour traditionalist. Your instinct is to protest against something, everything. When your party is in power they become the target. Starmer said long ago that Labour needs to become the party of power, not the party of protest. Sadly I think there's absolutely no chance of that happening ever, especially if people carry on with the stereotype. 1940s and 50s Labour members were passionately pro-Palestinian (understandably at the time) which led to unacceptable Anti-Semitism across the party. 1970s Labour members were opposed to joining the Common market - Jeremy Corbyn and Seamus Milne's aversion to Europe prevented Labour from fighting a serious campaign to remain. At every point where a Tory government lacking principles and/or competence has ridden roughshod over the people, culture and economy of Britain, you can point to Labour's role in empowering them. We've had Tory governments for two thirds of my long life, because Labour Parliamentarians or Trade Unionists have fucked things up for every Labour government.
And to answer your final question - does it matter? Ask anyone what the Tories stand for. Whatever it takes to stay in power is the answer. Three completely different approaches in one Parliament. Starmer's been handed a crock of shit, knowingly made worse by the other parties forcing him to rule out tax increases etc. He might have won a majority if he'd said "I'm putting income tax up by 1% across the board", but who could be sure? So we are where we are. Britain is full of wealthy pensioners who don't need the Fuel Allowance (I'm one), it is full of working people who claim PIP for their "mental health" but don't actually use the money for support servicers of any kind. It's too easy to go off on the sick, it always has been. We've got to stop giving money away. But that's against Labour "principles"? Do Labour governments have to be a soft touch?
|