Posts: 2,916
Threads: 33
Joined: Nov 2021
Reputation:
11
(07-11-2025, 02:00 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: On balance i disagree.
If a player is charged with a serious offence then yes i would agree the club shouldn't play him.
But under investigation not so sure.
The problem in this case is the amount of time it took to decide they had enough of a case to charge, 3 years is excessive and that's where the problem lies.
Anyway as a fanbase who are we to criticise. Hughes played after he was charged with serious crimes and don't remember anyone on here criticising our club. Being charged a few days after his contract ended is some coincidence. Or corruption.
Posts: 13,574
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
(07-11-2025, 04:07 PM)KRO Wrote: (07-11-2025, 02:00 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: On balance i disagree.
If a player is charged with a serious offence then yes i would agree the club shouldn't play him.
But under investigation not so sure.
The problem in this case is the amount of time it took to decide they had enough of a case to charge, 3 years is excessive and that's where the problem lies.
Anyway as a fanbase who are we to criticise. Hughes played after he was charged with serious crimes and don't remember anyone on here criticising our club. Being charged a few days after his contract ended is some coincidence. Or corruption.
They probably rushed so he couldn't flee the country
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
(07-11-2025, 12:49 PM)Duffers Wrote: I get that they couldn’t do anything to him contractually, just as we couldn’t with Hughes until there was an actual conviction. But it’s scumbag behaviour to have kept picking him throughout this period.
They need to start looking at their contracts. It has been interesting comparing the way Arsenal have handled this to the way SM Entertainment (colossal Kpop company) have dealt with one of their singers being investigated and subsequently convicted of rape, especially considering that the music industry is not known for a deep sense of morality and the South Korean music industry is no exception.
Despite this, even at the investigation stage, there was a public statement made initially stating he would be removed from the group and then a few months later " Taeil is currently under investigation by the prosecution for a criminal case. This not only constitutes grounds for termination under our contract but also makes it impossible to maintain trust in him as an artist. As a result, both parties have mutually agreed to terminate the contract".
Meanwhile, at one of the biggest football teams on earth, they've decided to brush everything under the carpet and learn nothing from the Adam Johnson case. You would think there would be some additional contract clauses after that.
Posts: 2,465
Threads: 34
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
I thought contracts had standard wording about a contract being terminated if a player behaved in a way that brought the club into disrepute. And it would be for the club, really, to decide what constituted that.
Anybody got a footballer's contract to hand?
Posts: 5,323
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
(07-11-2025, 05:57 PM)baggie_ray Wrote: I thought contracts had standard wording about a contract being terminated if a player behaved in a way that brought the club into disrepute. And it would be for the club, really, to decide what constituted that.
Anybody got a footballer's contract to hand?
But the point is this there hasn't been a trial yet to determine whether Partey is guilty of the charges made against him, so the question of whether he has brought the club into disrepute is yet to be determined.
No one is denying this is a very tricky set of events to navigate.
Butas a general rule of thumb, If the police and the cps do not think they have a strong enough case to bring charges against an individual, then I think it is reasonable for an employee to make no change to an employers work situation.
Posts: 11,938
Threads: 800
Joined: Oct 2022
Reputation:
50
The burden of proof for an employer to dismiss is much lower than criminal cases. I forget the wording but uts effectively 'with reasonable belief' rather than 'beyond reasonable doubt.
Then, specifically to sportspeople I would imagine their are specific clauses around bringing a brand into disrepute...
So there's little doubt in my mind that Arsenal could have terminated the contract, but chose not to.
Of course, if we had a functional CPS, Court system and didn't live in a country where over 90% of rape complaints don't end up in court, we may have seen a speedier outcome altogether.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Posts: 27,985
Threads: 1,168
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
64
(07-11-2025, 06:34 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (07-11-2025, 05:57 PM)baggie_ray Wrote: I thought contracts had standard wording about a contract being terminated if a player behaved in a way that brought the club into disrepute. And it would be for the club, really, to decide what constituted that.
Anybody got a footballer's contract to hand?
But the point is this there hasn't been a trial yet to determine whether Partey is guilty of the charges made against him, so the question of whether he has brought the club into disrepute is yet to be determined.
No one is denying this is a very tricky set of events to navigate.
Butas a general rule of thumb, If the police and the cps do not think they have a strong enough case to bring charges against an individual, then I think it is reasonable for an employee to make no change to an employers work situation.
Problem is though, specifically in the case of Partey, what can the club do if it’s just allegations and heresay? Not sure the Partey stuff was ever formally reported in the media beyond the whole “31 year old footballer” thing so despite everyone knowing who it was there was nothing formal to pin on him in terms of bringing the club into disrepute
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
(07-11-2025, 06:34 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (07-11-2025, 05:57 PM)baggie_ray Wrote: I thought contracts had standard wording about a contract being terminated if a player behaved in a way that brought the club into disrepute. And it would be for the club, really, to decide what constituted that.
Anybody got a footballer's contract to hand?
But the point is this there hasn't been a trial yet to determine whether Partey is guilty of the charges made against him, so the question of whether he has brought the club into disrepute is yet to be determined.
No one is denying this is a very tricky set of events to navigate.
Butas a general rule of thumb, If the police and the cps do not think they have a strong enough case to bring charges against an individual, then I think it is reasonable for an employee to make no change to an employers work situation.
(07-11-2025, 08:02 PM)Duffers Wrote: (07-11-2025, 06:34 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (07-11-2025, 05:57 PM)baggie_ray Wrote: I thought contracts had standard wording about a contract being terminated if a player behaved in a way that brought the club into disrepute. And it would be for the club, really, to decide what constituted that.
Anybody got a footballer's contract to hand?
But the point is this there hasn't been a trial yet to determine whether Partey is guilty of the charges made against him, so the question of whether he has brought the club into disrepute is yet to be determined.
No one is denying this is a very tricky set of events to navigate.
Butas a general rule of thumb, If the police and the cps do not think they have a strong enough case to bring charges against an individual, then I think it is reasonable for an employee to make no change to an employers work situation.
Problem is though, specifically in the case of Partey, what can the club do if it’s just allegations and heresay? Not sure the Partey stuff was ever formally reported in the media beyond the whole “31 year old footballer” thing so despite everyone knowing who it was there was nothing formal to pin on him in terms of bringing the club into disrepute
According to The Athletic
"Arsenal were also subsequently (after September 2021) contacted by the police to inform them that Partey was being investigated for serious sexual offences.
Arsenal were aware that the Crown Prosecution Service — which decides whether cases should be prosecuted — was in the process of making its charging decision when they entered into talks with Partey about a new contract earlier this year"
Company contracts don't have to abide by innocent until proven guilty, especially if there's reputational damage at stake. Arsenal should have acted much more swiftly, because that reputational damage has now definitely occured. Instead, they were even considering extending his contract and kept playing him.
The Athletic article indicates that there are some legal difficulties in terms of length of suspension and how much power the club has to take unilateral action prior to criminal conviction. However, upthread, I gave an example of an contract being terminated by mutual consent. Had Arsenal said, you have two options: 1) You will be training alone and you will not be selected (like Everton did with Sigardsson) or 2) You mutually agree to terminate your contract, they wouldn't have been in this state.
It all smacks of a fundamental failure to take sexual violence seriously
Posts: 4,108
Threads: 50
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
13
(07-11-2025, 08:50 PM)Squid Wrote: (07-11-2025, 06:34 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (07-11-2025, 05:57 PM)baggie_ray Wrote: I thought contracts had standard wording about a contract being terminated if a player behaved in a way that brought the club into disrepute. And it would be for the club, really, to decide what constituted that.
Anybody got a footballer's contract to hand?
But the point is this there hasn't been a trial yet to determine whether Partey is guilty of the charges made against him, so the question of whether he has brought the club into disrepute is yet to be determined.
No one is denying this is a very tricky set of events to navigate.
Butas a general rule of thumb, If the police and the cps do not think they have a strong enough case to bring charges against an individual, then I think it is reasonable for an employee to make no change to an employers work situation.
(07-11-2025, 08:02 PM)Duffers Wrote: (07-11-2025, 06:34 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (07-11-2025, 05:57 PM)baggie_ray Wrote: I thought contracts had standard wording about a contract being terminated if a player behaved in a way that brought the club into disrepute. And it would be for the club, really, to decide what constituted that.
Anybody got a footballer's contract to hand?
But the point is this there hasn't been a trial yet to determine whether Partey is guilty of the charges made against him, so the question of whether he has brought the club into disrepute is yet to be determined.
No one is denying this is a very tricky set of events to navigate.
Butas a general rule of thumb, If the police and the cps do not think they have a strong enough case to bring charges against an individual, then I think it is reasonable for an employee to make no change to an employers work situation.
Problem is though, specifically in the case of Partey, what can the club do if it’s just allegations and heresay? Not sure the Partey stuff was ever formally reported in the media beyond the whole “31 year old footballer” thing so despite everyone knowing who it was there was nothing formal to pin on him in terms of bringing the club into disrepute
According to The Athletic
"Arsenal were also subsequently (after September 2021) contacted by the police to inform them that Partey was being investigated for serious sexual offences.
Arsenal were aware that the Crown Prosecution Service — which decides whether cases should be prosecuted — was in the process of making its charging decision when they entered into talks with Partey about a new contract earlier this year"
Company contracts don't have to abide by innocent until proven guilty, especially if there's reputational damage at stake. Arsenal should have acted much more swiftly, because that reputational damage has now definitely occured. Instead, they were even considering extending his contract and kept playing him.
The Athletic article indicates that there are some legal difficulties in terms of length of suspension and how much power the club has to take unilateral action prior to criminal conviction. However, upthread, I gave an example of an contract being terminated by mutual consent. Had Arsenal said, you have two options: 1) You will be training alone and you will not be selected (like Everton did with Sigardsson) or 2) You mutually agree to terminate your contract, they wouldn't have been in this state.
It all smacks of a fundamental failure to take sexual violence seriously
Never a truer thing said. This is and has always been the case. As stated above in the thread, something like 90% of rape allegations don't even make it to court, and it's something like 2/3% actually end up in convictions. And there are so so many examples of people getting away with it.
Look at America, they have a rapist as the President. They're now denying all knowledge of the Epstein list even existing.
There is a West Indian cricketer who is currently being accused of 11 rapes, yet allegedly the Guyanese police and Windies team are doing all they can to sweep it under the carpet.
Mason Greenwood is stlil playing professional football.
Cristiano Ronaldo has had several allegations yet barely anyone speaks about it.
There was Dutch beach volleyball player who had been convicted still played at the Olympics.
Too many NFL players to name, Deshaun Watson being a recent example. 20+ accusations of sexual assault, gets given a $250m contract despite the legal procedings.
It goes on and on and on, and it's utterly sickening.
Sadly this case with Partey and Arsenal is the norm, not the exception.
|