06-25-2025, 06:13 PM
Can you whip a rebellion of well over a hundred? Going to be some deals done over the weekend for a lot of constituencies.
|
Disability vote
|
|
06-25-2025, 06:13 PM
Can you whip a rebellion of well over a hundred? Going to be some deals done over the weekend for a lot of constituencies.
06-25-2025, 06:15 PM
I hope they succeed to be honest. It’s been very poorly thought through and would be best implemented with more consideration for sustainable change than it has been. With it not due to come in till nearly 2027 anyway it’s gonna be a weight around Starmers neck for sure
06-26-2025, 08:13 AM
(This post was last modified: 06-26-2025, 09:03 AM by Derek Hardballs.)
Ultimately this is a poorly thought out bill, that has been handled appallingly by Starmer, Kendall, Reeves and their merry band of advisers. They have dressed up cuts to balance the books with reform of the system and at least 120 of their MPs can see it for what it is.
Over several threads I have said it was flawed and cruel for the following reasons… The ‘leak’ was handled dreadfully regardless of who leaked it to the press. They could have shut down speculation the same day, instead they hid behind protocol (which they pick and choose to stick to, depending upon what is best for them) and created needless stress and anxiety for those who are disabled and sick. They have and are pressing ahead with cuts/reform without consulting disabled charities and others first. How can a socially responsible government do this without expecting both criticism and push back? It’s arrogance in the extreme to say these are ‘reforms’ without the input from those it will impact most. They are demanding that a vote takes place before MPs see the full impact of these proposals, again how is that an acceptable way to make policy? Even going by the government’s own figures it’ll push 250,000 people into poverty, and those figures are disputed to be too low by other organisations who are experts in the sector. They have not set-out any plans to show how they intend to get more disabled people back into work. Some wishy-washy figure of £1bn to help with this, is not detailed plan it’s just a random figure without any real substance behind it. Are they going to subsidise companies to make their workplace accessible? Is there going to be the equivalent of a ‘New Deal’ for those who can work? Is there going to be tax or financial incentive for companies to take on those with a disability? What happens if those who want to work cannot find jobs because people won’t employ them? Are they to live in reduced money? The messaging has been appalling, dividing people into ‘working people’ so deserving of Labour’s time and the rest who are a burden on society because work is the only arbiter of worthiness. Then there is the muddying of the water to suggest PIP is an out of work benefit when in reality it is there to help people to work and live as normal a life as possible, and without PIP some may not be able to continue the job they do. Oh and as I predicted it’s tearing the Labour Party apart internally as Blue Labour think they can ride roughshod over everyone else in party, take for granted disabled and carers who would vote them ordinarily and it turns out without watering down their proposals they’ve tried to implement with disgraceful zeal they can’t. This is a shitshow of Starmers, Reeves and Kendall’s own making. We all know the system needs reform, however these are cuts first and reform has been tacked on as an afterthought, or maybe just a slogan in reality given the paucity of consultation and detail. If this was the Conservatives who were pushing this bill through, the criticism on here would be loud and clear but sadly some cannot take off their red scarf and admit this is a dreadfully thought out policy at best at worst a callous and cynical policy that has nothing to to with reform and all to do with cuts.
06-26-2025, 02:05 PM
(This post was last modified: 06-26-2025, 02:05 PM by Kit Kat Chunky.)
(06-26-2025, 08:13 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Ultimately this is a poorly thought out bill, that has been handled appallingly by Starmer, Kendall, Reeves and their merry band of advisers. They have dressed up cuts to balance the books with reform of the system and at least 120 of their MPs can see it for what it is. Last paragraph sums it up, Dekka. Many people who deserve and need these benefits are due to lose them unless Labour change course. Unfortunately they have a funding shortfall of their own making to fund, and can't gouge taxpayers for any more. This means they then hit the vulnerable.
06-26-2025, 05:25 PM
Kit Kat Chunky is more left wing than some Labour voters on here.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
06-26-2025, 05:57 PM
He’s more in the my enemies enemy camp and doesn’t want cuts or tax increases. He thinks everything will sort itself out if we only had the right government in place, the one like we had erm, you know, erm that one time in bandcamp.
06-26-2025, 05:58 PM
I think it's possible to believe that the system as it is now is unsustainable. In particular the sharp increase in young people claiming disability benefits due to mental illness needs to be examined:
https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-66592814 But at the same time, this attempt at reform seems to be very poorly thought out. It just seems that whoever is in power, Conservative or Labour, the can just gets kicked down the road. Happened with funding social care and it's happening with welfare reform too.
06-26-2025, 05:59 PM
We’re working ourselves into a position where even the most needy won’t be able to get help. The constant kicking the can down the road will bite us hard soon enough.
06-26-2025, 06:21 PM
(06-26-2025, 05:58 PM)Squid Wrote: I think it's possible to believe that the system as it is now is unsustainable. In particular the sharp increase in young people claiming disability benefits due to mental illness needs to be examined: Any application and measurement process which is so predominantly subjective that it can’t really be assessed properly is fucked. Which is what this is. (06-25-2025, 06:02 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Browns tax credits lifted 1 million kids out of poverty. Whether you think they were for “feral” people or not, that was some transformation Imagine a world, where instead of creating a bureaucracy and dependency on "tax credits" that Brown just hadn't taken that money off the poor in the first place? Tax Credits were designed to, and have succeeded in creating a client state. Just as some commercial tax credits have for certain types of business (see the balance there?) |
|
« Next Oldest | Next Newest »
|