England v India Test Series!!..
(06-24-2025, 05:41 PM)Even Flow 2.0 Wrote: India let England off the hook more than once this test and England punished them for it. Great batting performance from England.

This is the absolute key. In most of history, England just wouldn't have had the ruthlessness to take advantage of India's mistakes.

But India had two dreadful batting collapses, must've dropped about 10 catches and their bowling wasn't good enough.
Reply
(06-24-2025, 06:04 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(06-24-2025, 05:41 PM)Even Flow 2.0 Wrote: India let England off the hook more than once this test and England punished them for it. Great batting performance from England.

This is the absolute key. In most of history, England just wouldn't have had the ruthlessness to take advantage of India's mistakes.

But India had two dreadful batting collapses, must've dropped about 10 catches and their bowling wasn't good enough.

Looks like someone is taking away what a great victory this was, great bowling from Tongue, not just a batting collapse as for the catching, well England  dropped 4 catches in India’s second innings so if we had have held on to them perhaps we wouldn’t have needed to chase as many. We weren’t let of the hook we took our chance.As I said great victory.
Reply
(06-24-2025, 06:24 PM)wba13 Wrote:
(06-24-2025, 06:04 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(06-24-2025, 05:41 PM)Even Flow 2.0 Wrote: India let England off the hook more than once this test and England punished them for it. Great batting performance from England.

This is the absolute key. In most of history, England just wouldn't have had the ruthlessness to take advantage of India's mistakes.

But India had two dreadful batting collapses, must've dropped about 10 catches and their bowling wasn't good enough.

Looks like someone is taking away what a great victory this was, great bowling from Tongue, not just a batting collapse as for the catching, well England  dropped 4 catches in India’s second innings so if we had have held on to them perhaps we wouldn’t have needed to chase as many. We weren’t let of the hook we took our chance.As I said great victory.

Both things can be and are true. India were 430-3 to 471 all out, and 287-3 to 364 all out. They are two criminal batting collapses and a massive reason why they lost the game. Another is their catching.

HOWEVER, as I originally said if you actually read what I put rather than just assuming, we had the ruthlessness to take advantage of these mistakes and come away with what felt like a routine win, despite being our 2nd highest chase ever. The fact there was so little drama on Day 5 is a huge compliment to England's performance. But if India had consolidated that first innings total to 600+ like it should have been, or set 430-450 to win as they could have, England weren't winning that game.
Reply
First team to ever lose a Test having scored 5 centuries.
Reply
(06-24-2025, 06:56 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(06-24-2025, 06:24 PM)wba13 Wrote:
(06-24-2025, 06:04 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(06-24-2025, 05:41 PM)Even Flow 2.0 Wrote: India let England off the hook more than once this test and England punished them for it. Great batting performance from England.

This is the absolute key. In most of history, England just wouldn't have had the ruthlessness to take advantage of India's mistakes.

But India had two dreadful batting collapses, must've dropped about 10 catches and their bowling wasn't good enough.

Looks like someone is taking away what a great victory this was, great bowling from Tongue, not just a batting collapse as for the catching, well England  dropped 4 catches in India’s second innings so if we had have held on to them perhaps we wouldn’t have needed to chase as many. We weren’t let of the hook we took our chance.As I said great victory.

Both things can be and are true. India were 430-3 to 471 all out, and 287-3 to 364 all out. They are two criminal batting collapses and a massive reason why they lost the game. Another is their catching.

HOWEVER, as I originally said if you actually read what I put rather than just assuming, we had the ruthlessness to take advantage of these mistakes and come away with what felt like a routine win, despite being our 2nd highest chase ever. The fact there was so little drama on Day 5 is a huge compliment to England's performance. But if India had consolidated that first innings total to 600+ like it should have been, or set 430-450 to win as they could have, England weren't winning that game.

You only win what’s put in front of you, we did what we had to do, not our fault India dropped catches or got bowled out for less than expected. As I said Tongue deserves praise for blitzing out the tail. Great bowling.
Reply
(06-24-2025, 07:01 PM)wba13 Wrote:
(06-24-2025, 06:56 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(06-24-2025, 06:24 PM)wba13 Wrote:
(06-24-2025, 06:04 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(06-24-2025, 05:41 PM)Even Flow 2.0 Wrote: India let England off the hook more than once this test and England punished them for it. Great batting performance from England.

This is the absolute key. In most of history, England just wouldn't have had the ruthlessness to take advantage of India's mistakes.

But India had two dreadful batting collapses, must've dropped about 10 catches and their bowling wasn't good enough.

Looks like someone is taking away what a great victory this was, great bowling from Tongue, not just a batting collapse as for the catching, well England  dropped 4 catches in India’s second innings so if we had have held on to them perhaps we wouldn’t have needed to chase as many. We weren’t let of the hook we took our chance.As I said great victory.

Both things can be and are true. India were 430-3 to 471 all out, and 287-3 to 364 all out. They are two criminal batting collapses and a massive reason why they lost the game. Another is their catching.

HOWEVER, as I originally said if you actually read what I put rather than just assuming, we had the ruthlessness to take advantage of these mistakes and come away with what felt like a routine win, despite being our 2nd highest chase ever. The fact there was so little drama on Day 5 is a huge compliment to England's performance. But if India had consolidated that first innings total to 600+ like it should have been, or set 430-450 to win as they could have, England weren't winning that game.

You only win what’s put in front of you, we did what we had to do, not our fault India dropped catches or got bowled out for less than expected. As I said Tongue deserves praise for blitzing out the tail. Great bowling.

You seem incapable of understanding my point.
Reply
Great win for England in a cracking test match, glad I snapped up one of the last remaining seats for the 1st day at Edgbaston.
Reply
I can't understand why some people struggle with the concept of saying 'great performance, England, but India threw their momentum away and handed over the initiative'.

To say England were gifted the win would be wrong, and overlooks everything they did well, but to say they weren't given a helping hand is also incorrect.
Reply
An excellent all round performance by us. Especially as we are missing 2 or 3 of our better seamers,and the pressure on both Crawley and Pope must have been immense. Kudos to both for contributing in a big way. Would still like them to hopefully get Bethel into the team sometime this series. That kid is going to be some player.
Reply
(06-24-2025, 07:28 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: I can't understand why some people struggle with the concept of saying 'great performance, England, but India threw their momentum away and handed over the initiative'.

To say England were gifted the win would be wrong, and overlooks everything they did well, but to say they weren't given a helping hand is also incorrect.

Nail on head. Thank you Josh.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 11 Guest(s)